Key Takeaways:

  • Salaried employees receive a fixed annual income divided over pay periods, offering stability but often requiring extra work without overtime pay.
  • Hourly employees are paid per hour worked, ensuring compensation for extra hours but possibly leading to fluctuating income and limited benefits.
  • Legal distinctions under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) determine whether an employee is exempt from overtime pay.
  • Benefits for salaried workers often include health insurance, retirement plans, and paid time off, whereas hourly workers may receive fewer benefits.
  • Employer considerations include payroll budgeting, employee classification, and compliance with labor laws.
  • Tax implications differ for salaried and hourly workers, affecting deductions and withholdings.
  • Job security and career growth are often stronger for salaried employees, while hourly positions may offer more flexibility.
  • Overtime laws vary by state and affect how hourly and some salaried workers are compensated for extra hours.
  • Choosing between salary and hourly depends on career goals, financial stability, and work-life balance preferences.

Differences Between Salaried and Hourly Employees

The differences between salaried and hourly employees are outlined by different laws and policies. Employees are classified by salary versus hourly and by the kind of work they do. A salaried employee is defined as a worker who receives a fixed amount of compensation paid weekly, biweekly or monthly. An hourly worker receives an hourly wage for their services. Federal and state employment laws require a classification of salary or hourly.

Key Legal Considerations for Salary vs Hourly Pay

The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) establishes whether an employee qualifies as salaried (exempt) or hourly (non-exempt).

  • Exempt Employees: Salaried workers earning above a threshold ($35,568 annually in 2024) and meeting the “white-collar” duties test (executive, administrative, professional roles) are not entitled to overtime.
  • Non-Exempt Employees: Hourly workers are entitled to overtime pay (1.5x hourly rate) for working more than 40 hours per week.
  • State Regulations: Some states, like California, have stricter salary thresholds and overtime rules.
  • Misclassification Risks: Employers that incorrectly classify employees can face lawsuits, back pay claims, and penalties.

What is a Salaried Employee?

Though an employee paid by salary receives payment weekly, the monetary amount determining the weekly pay is annual. This annual amount is divided between pay periods the company determines for that year according to the 2,080-hour ruling. When hired, a salaried employee receives a contract stating the amounts and time of payment. In general:

  • A salaried employee does not fill out a timesheet or track their time.
  • A salaried employee may work more than 40 hours or less than 40 hours and the salary remains the same unless the employer makes special conditions.
  • Salaried positions offer more job security in most industries and often have opportunities for advancement into higher paying management positions.
  • Often benefits like 401(k) come with the position.
  • Salaried employees may or may not be exempt from overtime (extra pay for extra hours).
  • Alternatively, these employees may be compensated by benefits instead of additional pay.

Benefits and Disadvantages of Salary Pay

Having a salaried position often gives a worker higher status. It entitles a worker to a set of benefits hourly workers do not receive, such as bonuses and annual raises. Salaried positions are also considered more secure.

There can be disadvantages to salaried positions, such as demanding an employee to work more than 40 hours a week. It may even require working holidays with no extra pay. Once a salary becomes accepted, renegotiating it becomes more difficult, and often an employee has to change positions to get a higher salary. Salaried workers are often exempt from overtime under the Fair Labor Standards Act.

Tax Implications of Salary vs Hourly Pay

Salaried and hourly workers are taxed differently based on withholding structures and deductions.

  • Salaried Employees: Have consistent tax withholdings, which makes budgeting easier. They may benefit from employer-sponsored retirement plans and pre-tax benefits like healthcare.
  • Hourly Employees: Taxes fluctuate based on earnings. Workers relying on overtime may see higher tax liabilities but may also qualify for earned income tax credits if their annual wages are lower.
  • Self-Employment and Freelance Considerations: Some hourly workers operate as independent contractors, requiring them to manage self-employment taxes.

What is an Hourly Position?

Hourly employees have a different setup. They are paid a set amount by the hour. Some contracts exist, but it has to do with union agreements with the company or working conditions. In general:

  • Most are paid for hours worked.
  • An employer sets the number of hours.
  • These workers use a time carded system or complete a timesheet which verifies the house worked for payroll.
  • On average, most hourly employees work 40 hours a week.
  • Those who work less than 40 hours a week usually classify as part time.
  • Different pay rates, time off, and benefits exist for a full time and part time in a company.
  • Schedules vary as well but are set by the employer.
  • If hourly employees work more than 40 hours per week state law and the Department of Labor requires those workers be paid overtime in most industries.

Benefits and Disadvantages of Hourly Work

Hourly employees often get double wages for working holidays. In some industries, being paid hourly and receiving overtime pay results in a higher annual wage than salaried workers who work the same hours. Hourly employees may or may not have additional benefits. In most cases, an employer that has 50 full-time employees will have employer sponsored health insurance. Even workers who work part time may be eligible for the insurance.

There are a few disadvantages of being an hourly employee. If a business closes early or cuts back hours, however, an hourly worker will receive less pay. If laws change or the company has a turbulent time, often hourly employees become impacted first as in laid off or fewer hours. Less opportunity may exist for training or advancement.

What Determines if an Employee is Salaried or Hourly?

A combination of laws and employer policies determine a salaried or hourly classification on a position. The distinction often becomes based on the kind of work done in a position. The Federal and state laws favor paying hourly employees over time while other laws favor other compensations such as benefits, or compensatory days for salaried positions. Professional trades, managers, and supervisors often are exempt from overtime and are therefore considered salaried.

Impact on Career Growth and Job Security

Career advancement opportunities often differ between salaried and hourly positions:

  • Salaried Employees: Frequently have clearer paths to promotions and leadership roles, with structured performance reviews and salary negotiations.
  • Hourly Employees: May find career growth slower but benefit from transitioning to salaried positions over time.
  • Job Security: Salaried employees often receive more protections in layoffs, while hourly workers are more vulnerable to reduced hours or job loss in economic downturns.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can an employee switch from hourly to salaried? Yes, employees can transition if their role meets FLSA exemption criteria and employer policies align.

2. Do salaried employees ever get overtime? Only if classified as non-exempt or if state law mandates it (e.g., some California-based salaried workers).

3. Are hourly workers always entitled to benefits? No, benefits depend on company policy. Some part-time hourly employees lack healthcare and paid time off.

4. What happens if an employer misclassifies a worker? The employer may face legal penalties, back pay requirements, and IRS audits.

5. Which is better: salary or hourly? It depends on job stability, financial goals, and work-life balance preferences. Salaried jobs offer stability, while hourly jobs provide flexibility.

If you need help with creating policies for hourly or salaried employees, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel hires only the top 5 percent of lawyers into its site. Most have 14 years of legal service and have worked with small business to corporate. Their level of expertise ensures you the best and latest legal advice.