Key Takeaways

  • Coordination of Benefits (COB) determines how multiple insurance plans share payment responsibilities.
  • COB prevents overpayments and ensures claimants receive full entitled benefits.
  • COB applies across various insurance types—health, auto, dental, Medicare, workers’ compensation, and more.
  • The primary insurer pays first, followed by the secondary, and potentially a tertiary.
  • Determination rules include subscriber status, employer coverage, birthday rule, and Medicare-specific coordination.
  • COB is crucial in minimizing out-of-pocket expenses and avoiding claim denials or delays.
  • Timely and accurate information sharing between policyholders and insurers is vital to effective COB.

Coordination of Benefits: Everything You Need to Know

Also referred to as COB, coordination of benefits occurs when an individual is in possession of more than one insurance policy and when it comes to processing a claim, the policies are assessed to determine which will be assigned with the primary responsibility for covering the predominant share of the claim costs.The process also involves assessing the extent that other policies held will contribute toward the claim. This article will provide you with everything that you need to know about coordination of benefits.

What Is Coordination of Benefits?

The primary intentions of coordination of benefits are to make sure that individuals who receive coverage from two or more plans will receive their complete benefit entitlement and to prevent benefits from being duplicated when an individual has more than one policy in place. This process covers insurance pertaining to several sectors including health insurance, car insurance, retirement benefits, workers compensation, and others.

The order in which the insurance policies are coordinated is dictated by insurance law and cannot be decided by a company or an individual. This process takes place only when multiple insurance plans are involved. If only one plan is held, then all responsibility is put onto the sole plan.

Predominantly, coordination of benefits happens when an individual has two plans in place (primary and secondary), but it may also include a tertiary plan in some circumstances. The primary insurance plan is given the responsibility of being the first payer, the secondary plan is the second payer, and so on depending on how many plans the individual holds.

How Coordination of Benefits Works in Practice

In real-world scenarios, coordination of benefits ensures that insurance claims are processed without duplication and within the scope of each policy’s responsibility. For example, if you are injured and both your employer's health insurance and your spouse's insurance provide coverage, COB identifies which policy pays first and which follows.

A key aspect of this process is the use of standardized industry rules and forms—like the HIPAA-compliant COB form—to collect data on all active policies. The information typically required includes policy numbers, group numbers, and dates of coverage.

The primary insurer processes the claim as if no other insurance exists. Afterward, the claim is forwarded to the secondary insurer, which reviews the remaining balance and pays its share—up to the plan's allowable limits.

Why Is COB Important?

There are numerous reasons why COB is an important process. These are summarized below:

  • A lack of coordination between the plans a person holds can result in the claim not being paid until the COB has been confirmed, thus potentially causing financial difficulties.
  • Either the individual or the insurance provider could be subjected to expenses that they did not need to pay if the insurance plans are not coordinated correctly.

Benefits of COB for Patients and Providers

Coordination of benefits offers a host of advantages:

  • Patients benefit from reduced out-of-pocket costs, as the secondary insurance often covers what the primary doesn’t.
  • Prevention of duplicate payments, which ensures that no provider is reimbursed more than once for the same service.
  • Faster claims processing when information is correctly coordinated at the start.
  • Compliance with federal and state laws, particularly in the case of Medicare or Medicaid.
  • Improved accuracy and reduced administrative costs for providers, as COB limits payment disputes and billing redundancies.
  • Efficient COB practices help maintain the integrity of the insurance ecosystem by supporting financial accountability and transparency.

Order of Benefit Determination

The primary plan is always considered as the predominant provider of benefits, and it must provide these as though the claim holder does not have a second or third policy in place. The COB provisions that are specified in the insurance policy outline which plan is the primary plan. Once identified, the primary plan's benefits are applied to the claim first.

It is important to note that the primary plan is always considered as the first payer, regardless of the specifics written in its clauses. This means that any plan that does not include the COB provisional clause may not incorporate the benefits offered by a claimant's other plan into their considerations when assessing what benefits are due.

Any unpaid balance owed to the patient is typically paid by the claimant's second plan, within the limits of its responsibility. This secondary insurance plan can take the benefits of the patient's other plans into consideration only when it has been confirmed as being the secondary — not primary — plan.

The payments that are delivered to the patient by their combined insurance plans do not exceed 100 percent of the charges for necessary covered services. The benefits are usually coordinated between all of the plans held by the patient.

If a family is making a claim, each individual and their COB will be assessed separately, as there is a possibility that the order of plans and benefits may differ between each member.

There may be some differences to the "order of benefit determination" as laid out here if the claimant's policy is held with Medicare, but otherwise, these rules should be followed as a standard process.

Special COB Considerations with Medicare

When Medicare is involved in coordination of benefits, specific federal rules dictate how it interacts with other insurance:

  • Medicare as Secondary Payer (MSP): If you have group health coverage through an employer and are over 65, Medicare may act as the secondary payer.
  • Medicare as Primary Payer: In cases where no other primary coverage exists, Medicare takes the lead role.
  • Medicare and COBRA: If you're covered under COBRA and also eligible for Medicare, Medicare is typically the primary payer.
  • End-Stage Renal Disease (ESRD): For individuals with ESRD, a 30-month coordination period usually applies during which group health plans are primary.

It’s important that individuals update the Coordination of Benefits Contractor (COBC) about any changes in coverage. Failure to do so can lead to claim denials or billing issues.

Understanding Various COB Rules

Common COB circumstances and how the COB rules are then applied are outlined below.

  • Plan Type Rule
    If the individual has both a commercial insurance plan and Medicaid, then the commercial plan will always be considered as the primary policy, and Medicaid is secondary.
  • Subscriber or Dependent Rule
    If a patient subscribes to two or more policies, where one policy is as a subscriber, and another is as a dependent, then the policy under which they are classified as a subscriber is the primary policy, and that where they are a dependent will fall as the secondary policy.
  • Timeline Rule
    If the patient is the primary subscriber to two commercial plans, then the plan to which they have been subscribed the longest is considered as the primary plan, and the newer plan is the secondary.
  • Employer Coverage Rule
    If the individual has coverage both through their employer and as a dependent through another commercial plan, then the employer-operated plan will always be considered as the primary plan.
  • Dependent Child (under 18) with Separated/Divorced Parents Rule
    A copy of the parent's divorce decree is needed before the order of benefits can be confirmed. If terms within the decree specify one of the parents as being responsible for the child's health insurance coverage or health care, and the parent is aware of this, then that plan is considered as primary. If the parent who has responsibility for health insurance has no coverage for the child's health care but their former spouse does, then the spouse's plan is deemed as primary.

    If the divorce decree does not exist, or there is no specification as to which parent is responsible for the child's healthcare coverage, then the responsible parent — and thus policy — is determined first by:
    • 1. The birthday rule of the parent (whoever's occurs earlier in the year) and,
    • 2. The length of policy rule of the policy holders (whichever commenced first).
  • Dependent Child (Parents Not Separated or Divorced) Rule
    If a child's parents are together, then determining the primary plan is done by using the birthday rule (i.e. whoever was born earlier is responsible).

Common Scenarios Where COB Applies

Here are some typical situations where coordination of benefits comes into play:

  • Dual employment coverage: When both spouses have insurance through their respective employers.
  • Children covered under both parents’ plans: The birthday rule and custodial arrangements come into play here.
  • Retirees with group and Medicare coverage: COB helps determine whether the employer plan or Medicare is primary.
  • Workers' Compensation overlaps with health insurance: Health plans may defer to workers’ compensation for work-related injuries.
  • Auto accidents: Auto insurance may pay first for accident-related medical care, with health insurance following.

Each scenario may involve different COB rules, and insurers rely on established industry standards and documentation to determine payment responsibilities.

COB Best Practices for Individuals and Employers

For individuals and HR teams, adopting best practices can streamline COB and minimize claim issues:

Individuals should:

  • Notify all insurance providers when coverage changes occur.
  • Keep copies of Explanation of Benefits (EOBs) from each insurer.
  • Use updated COB forms to prevent delays in processing claims.

Employers should:

  • Provide timely and accurate eligibility data to insurers.
  • Educate employees during onboarding and open enrollment on how COB works.
  • Coordinate with benefits administrators to resolve claim discrepancies.

By proactively managing COB, policyholders, and employers alike can ensure smoother experiences during the claim process.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does coordination of benefits mean?It refers to the process of determining which of multiple insurance plans pays first and how remaining costs are divided among the other plans.

Who decides which insurance is primary?The determination is based on standard rules such as the birthday rule, employer coverage, and federal law, particularly when Medicare is involved.

Can coordination of benefits reduce my out-of-pocket expenses?Yes, if correctly applied, COB ensures that you get the full benefit of your combined coverage, minimizing what you need to pay.

How do I know if I need to complete a COB form?Insurers typically request a COB form when they become aware of another policy or when a claim is submitted that suggests dual coverage.

What happens if I don’t update my insurance about another policy I have?Failure to update can delay your claims, result in partial payments, or even cause the claim to be denied due to incomplete COB information.

If you are currently processing an insurance claim, and you are unsure of the correct process to follow as per COB, then you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top five percent of lawyers to its site, and these professionals come from schools such as Harvard Law or Yale. Our lawyers have an average of 14 years of legal experience, which includes working with prestigious companies like Google and Airbnb.