Key Takeaways:

  • Consideration is a fundamental element of a legally binding contract, requiring an exchange of value between parties.
  • Consideration can take various forms, including monetary payments, goods, services, or promises to act or refrain from acting.
  • A contract lacking valid consideration may be unenforceable in court.
  • Courts generally do not question the adequacy of consideration unless fraud, coercion, or bad faith is involved.
  • Some contracts may be exempt from consideration requirements, such as promissory estoppel and contracts under seal.
  • Real-world and hypothetical examples illustrate the concept of consideration in both unilateral and bilateral contracts.
  • Consideration must be lawful; illegal or illusory promises do not constitute valid consideration.
  • A failure to provide agreed consideration can lead to contract cancellation or legal disputes.
  • UpCounsel connects clients with experienced contract attorneys for assistance with drafting, reviewing, or enforcing contracts.

Consideration in Contracts

Consideration in contracts refers to the benefit each party receives in exchange for what it gives up in the contract. It is a vital element that must be present in a contract in order to make it legally binding on the parties. A contract, whether oral or in writing, becomes invalid if there is no consideration involved.

Essential Elements of Consideration

In order to form a valid contract, consideration must meet the following conditions:

  • It must be something worth bargaining for.
  • It must benefit all the parties to the contract.
  • It must be something of value.

Exceptions to the Consideration Requirement

While consideration is generally required to form a valid contract, there are a few exceptions where a contract may still be enforceable without consideration:

  • Promissory Estoppel: If one party relies on a promise to their detriment, the court may enforce the promise even in the absence of consideration.
  • Contracts Under Seal: Some jurisdictions recognize contracts under seal (often notarized or stamped) as enforceable without explicit consideration.
  • Debts Discharged by Bankruptcy: In certain cases, obligations that are otherwise unenforceable due to bankruptcy may still be recognized without fresh consideration.
  • Modifications in UCC Contracts: The Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) allows contract modifications without new consideration under specific circumstances, particularly in the sale of goods.

Types of Consideration

There are two types of consideration:

  • Consideration in a bilateral contract involves exchanging a promise for a promise.
  • Consideration in a unilateral contract involves one party making a promise and the other party doing something in return.

Real and Hypothetical Examples of Consideration in Contracts

To better understand how consideration functions, here are some real-world and hypothetical contract examples:

  • Employment Contract Example (Real): An employer offers a job to a new employee. In return for the employee's labor and adherence to company policies, the employer provides salary, benefits, and other compensation. The mutual exchange of obligations constitutes valid consideration.
  • Freelance Design Agreement (Made-Up): A graphic designer agrees to create a business logo for a startup. In exchange, the startup agrees to pay $1,000. The designer's service is one form of consideration, while the payment is the other.
  • Unilateral Contract Example (Real): A homeowner promises a $500 reward to anyone who finds and returns their lost dog. A neighbor who locates the dog and brings it back is entitled to the payment, as they provided the requested action.
  • Service Exchange Agreement (Made-Up): A yoga instructor and a website developer agree to trade services. The yoga instructor offers 10 private lessons in exchange for the developer creating a website. Both parties receive something of value, making it a valid contract.

These examples demonstrate the wide range of valid consideration in contract law.

Consideration Need Not Be Monetary

Consideration can be in the form of money, property, promise, services, or something else. It can be something as simple as a promise to do or not to do something. For example, if you enter into a contract with your neighbor wherein he agrees not to sue you for the damage you caused to his property, and in return, you agree to pay him a sum of $800, then the amount of $800 is the consideration your neighbor gets, whereas his promise to not sue you is the consideration you get from the contract.

Consideration in Business Contracts

Businesses often engage in contracts where consideration extends beyond monetary exchange. Here are common forms of consideration in business agreements:

  • Equity in Exchange for Services: A startup may offer equity shares to a software developer instead of a traditional salary.
  • Non-Compete Agreements: An employee agrees not to work for competitors in exchange for continued employment or a severance package.
  • Supply Contracts: A manufacturer agrees to supply a retailer with exclusive products at a discounted rate in exchange for a long-term purchasing commitment.
  • Franchise Agreements: A franchisee pays licensing fees in return for the right to operate under a company's brand and receive ongoing business support.

Understanding how consideration applies in business contracts helps companies navigate negotiations and ensure enforceability.

Disproportionate Consideration

Consideration can be as big or small as the parties mutually agree to exchange between themselves. For example, when you go to buy a dress, it's between you and the seller to agree upon the price. When a valid consideration is present, courts rarely interfere to decide whether the deal is unfair or disproportionate. However, if a party is tricked into an unfair deal by hiding some important information or otherwise acting in bad faith, then it can affect the legal validity of the contract.

Is It Mandatory to Mention the Word 'Consideration'?

Most contracts contain a line or two to the effect that a valid and sufficient consideration forms the basis of the contract. However, just mentioning something in the contract does not prove the existence of valid consideration. Likewise, a consideration does not become invalid if it doesn't find a mention in the contract. No

What Happens When a Contract Lacks Consideration?

If there is no consideration present in a contract, the contract becomes invalid, and the courts may refuse to enforce the contract. Sometimes, a contract may lack consideration though it may seem at the surface that the parties are exchanging something of value.

Following are some of the scenarios where there is no valid consideration involved:

  • When a party promises to perform something he or she was already legally bound to perform. For example, when a policeman promises to catch the thief.
  • When the consideration is more of a gift and does not require bargaining or mutual agreement between the parties. For example, when a mother creates a legal document promising to buy her son a car if he graduates with good marks.
  • When a party promises to give something in exchange for some "past consideration" by the other party.
  • When the promise to do something is illusory. For example, when a mango juice company enters into a contract with a farmer, saying that the company will buy all its mango requirements from the farmer, and the farmer can sell to the company as many mangoes as he wants, then the consideration given by the farmer is illusory since he is not legally bound by the contract to sell the mangoes to the company.

Legal Consequences of a Lack of Consideration

A contract lacking valid consideration is generally unenforceable, but legal consequences may vary depending on the circumstances:

  • Void Contract: If no consideration exists, courts may declare the contract void from the outset.
  • Unilateral Revocation: If one party has not yet performed their obligations and no consideration exists, the other party may revoke the agreement without penalty.
  • Lack of Standing to Sue: Without valid consideration, an aggrieved party may lack legal grounds to enforce the contract.
  • Remedies in Equity: In some cases, courts may enforce agreements lacking consideration if promissory estoppel applies.

These consequences highlight the critical role of consideration in determining the enforceability of contracts.

Failure to Provide Consideration

If a party fails to provide the promised consideration, the other party can cancel the contract. The defaulting party can also be sued for damages or specific performance.

The following instances are tantamount to failure of consideration:

  • When the provided consideration is worth less than promised.
  • When the provided consideration is damaged or destroyed.
  • When the performance is not carried out as promised or expected; for example, when a mechanic does not repair a car properly.

It is worth noting that a promise to do something illegal or immoral does not serve as a valid consideration.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can a contract be valid without consideration?

In most cases, no. However, exceptions such as promissory estoppel, contracts under seal, and certain UCC modifications allow enforceability without direct consideration.

2. What is an example of illusory consideration?

An agreement where one party has the discretion to fulfill or ignore their obligations, such as a promise to sell goods "if I feel like it," is considered illusory and unenforceable.

3. How do courts determine if consideration is sufficient?

Courts generally do not assess the fairness of consideration but will examine whether both parties exchanged something of legal value. Fraud, duress, or unconscionability can invalidate consideration.

4. Is past consideration valid in a contract?

No, past consideration—where one party offers something already given or performed—is generally not valid. Consideration must be contemporaneous with the contract formation.

5. Can love and affection be considered valid consideration?

Generally, no. Courts typically do not recognize emotional or sentimental considerations as legally sufficient to support a contract.

If you need help with consideration in contracts, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.