Key Takeaways

  • Employee reviews are valuable tools for communication, motivation, and professional development when conducted thoughtfully.
  • Performance reviews can take different forms—self-assessments, peer reviews, team evaluations, and managerial reviews—all serving unique purposes.
  • Conducting employee reviews in person fosters trust and encourages honest feedback.
  • Common pitfalls include vague feedback, personal criticism, and overly formalized processes.
  • Integrating reviews with goal-setting and continuous feedback promotes long-term growth.
  • Managers should align reviews with organizational objectives and foster a culture of two-way communication.

What Are Employee Reviews?

Employee reviews are an evaluation of an employee’s performance, usually conducted by the employee’s manager. Employee reviews are an uncomfortable yet necessary part of a company’s hiring and employee retention process. For many, these meetings seem arbitrary, a corporate requirement with no real intent or value. However, when used properly and performed well, employee reviews can help mold long-term employees into members of the team.

Employee Reviews

A common joke made among people in the human resources industry is that employee reviews are like fruitcakes because they come once a year whether you want them to or not. Just like a fruitcake, reviews are most common during the holidays—the time when the work has been piling up, employees are most focused on their bonuses, and their last vacation seems so far away.

Much of the stress of reviews could be avoided if, as experts in the field suggest, employees were reviewed earlier in the year, and more frequently overall. This would result in positive changes not just for the individual, but for the company as a whole. It is generally recommended that reviews take place at least twice per year—once at the midway point, and then as an end-of-year review which would cover possible raises or bonuses.

Performance reviews are critical for employers. They provide an opportunity for the employer to give constructive feedback to make sure their business is operating at peak efficiency. The process also allows employers to praise employees for a job well done, give them guidance for what they might be doing wrong, and let’s both parties engage in an open discussion about the future of the company as well as what potential exists for employee growth. Performance reviews are rarely a fun experience, but they can be an effective way to create more loyalty among employees when done well.

Types and Frequency of Employee Reviews

Employee reviews can take several forms, depending on company size, goals, and management style. Common types include:

  • Self-assessment reviews: Employees evaluate their own strengths, weaknesses, and achievements, fostering self-awareness and accountability.
  • Peer reviews: Colleagues assess one another’s teamwork and interpersonal skills, promoting collaboration and mutual respect.
  • Team performance reviews: Evaluate how groups work together to meet collective objectives, highlighting communication and coordination.
  • Manager performance reviews: Provide insight into leadership effectiveness, including motivation, delegation, and results.

The frequency of employee reviews should balance timeliness with depth. Many companies find quarterly or biannual reviews effective for maintaining ongoing dialogue while allowing time for measurable progress. Frequent feedback, such as monthly check-ins or project-based evaluations, helps keep employees aligned and motivated.

Tips for Creating Effective and Successful Employee Performance Reviews

Performance review methods might differ from company to company, but there are universal principles about how to discuss work performance with an employee. Whether you’re conducting a performance review, implementing a performance improvement plan (PIP), or negotiating a salary adjustment, there are core strategies you can employ in any situation.

The following are a few tips for ensuring that your performance review process is as effective as possible. Keep in mind that these tips can enhance your relationship with your employees/co-workers, improve the overall performance of your organization, and enhance the company’s employee-manager communication significantly (which is a huge win for customers and work relationships). You should also find many applicable in everyday conversations with employees. Follow these tips, and you’ll find more efficiency in your reviews, and have more productive employees after a successful meeting.

Why Employee Reviews Matter

Employee reviews play a vital role in aligning individual performance with organizational objectives. They ensure employees understand how their work supports company goals, providing a sense of purpose and direction. Reviews also facilitate continuous feedback, encouraging real-time improvement and reducing the risk of miscommunication.

When used effectively, employee reviews:

  • Strengthen engagement and productivity by reinforcing expectations.
  • Help managers identify skill gaps and training opportunities.
  • Encourage accountability through measurable goals and follow-up discussions.
  • Foster career development and retention by aligning employee aspirations with business strategy.

Separate Reviews for Pay Increases from Conversations About Professional Development

A major reason why you will want to arrange a midyear meeting with every employee is, so you can separate the session when you discuss an employee's performance from one where compensation is determined. According to the chairman of management consulting firm TruePoint, Michael Beer, it is extremely difficult to have anyone focus on feedback about their performance if they know that salary or bonuses will be discussed during the meeting.

Be Honest

Everyone says that “honesty is the best policy,” but in this case, it is actually true. Paul Falcone, an HR export, has stated that many employers try to avoid confrontations with their employees by overinflating their positive feedback. While this tactic prevents argument, it won’t help employees grow, and will make the termination process more difficult in the long run. Remain open-ended in the conversation, allowing the employee time to respond to feedback in the room. Make the conversation about the issues, not the person.

Avoiding Common Review Mistakes

Even experienced managers can fall into traps that reduce the effectiveness of employee reviews. To ensure fairness and clarity:

  1. Avoid ambiguity. Give precise examples of performance, both positive and negative, to prevent misunderstandings.
  2. Don’t make it personal. Focus on behaviors and outcomes rather than personality traits.
  3. Don’t delay feedback. Waiting too long between evaluations reduces relevance and impact.
  4. Avoid one-sided discussions. Encourage employee input to make the process collaborative.

Constructive and balanced feedback keeps the conversation productive and supports mutual growth.

Put Down the Forms

Some managers give a performance review by just running down the company's required employee feedback form point by point, simply spitting out grades or remarks for each. This process is actually the worst way possible to conduct such an evaluation, because it leaves no room for discussion. These meetings can be far more productive once the form has been set aside, or at the very least waiting until after the meeting to fill it out.

A better strategy than using the form at all would be just to have a conversation about the employee’s performance since the last review, including any problems that have come up and how they were resolved. Once everything has been discussed, you are better equipped to formulate strategies for improvement, and set up an even more productive process when the time comes for the next review meeting.

Shift the Review to the Employee

One of the best strategies for a successful, open discussion or review is to switch around the roles in the conversation and have the employee do the reviewing. Managers are better positioned to motivate employees when they let the employee assess his or her own work. You can open up the session to productive discussion by asking the employee to review their supervisor's performance in addition to their own. Try asking an employee four core questions during the review:

  • How do you feel you’ve performed this year?
  • What can I do as your supervisor to build your skills?
  • What are your goals for the next year?
  • What are some measurable outcomes of those goals?

Roughly 70 percent of your employees will be successful with this assignment, while 10 percent might not even respond. However, 20 percent of your employees will take these questions to heart and walk away highly motivated. In general, these are the people who become the company's top performers.

Conducting Employee Reviews In Person

Whenever possible, conduct employee reviews face-to-face. In-person meetings foster trust and allow for open, two-way communication. Employees are more likely to share candid feedback and express their goals or concerns in a private, supportive setting. Body language and tone can also help prevent misunderstandings, making the discussion more meaningful and encouraging stronger manager-employee relationships.

Come Prepared

To create an effective employee review, it is crucial to gather as many specific examples of good and bad behavior as you possibly can. You should also gather objective information on the employee’s performance. This should not wait until just before a performance review; rather, achievements and mistakes must be tracked throughout the year. On the day of the review, create an outline of all desired discussion topics and set forth ground rules for a productive conversation.

Do the work ahead of time to prep for the discussion with an employee. Never go into a performance review without being fully prepared. You could miss key opportunities for feedback or improvement. Further, the employee won’t feel any encouragement about their successes. The records you keep during a performance review period serves to prepare you for an employee's performance review.

Practice various approaches with human resources staff, your colleagues, or a manager as needed. Write down notes with your primary points of feedback. Make sure to include some bullet points to illustrate the points you plan to make to that employee. The more often you can identify patterns and provide clear examples, the better the employee will be able to understand and act upon your feedback. After a meeting, do not forget to follow up and summarize the discussion. Begin observations for that employee’s next review immediately.

Reviews Shouldn’t Be the First Time You Provide Feedback

The employee should not hear about positive performance or performance in need of improvement for the first time at your formal performance meeting unless you have new data or insight. An effective manager discusses positive performance alongside areas that can regularly be improved, not just twice a year. Managers should work hard to make a performance review discussion more of a re-emphasis of vital points.

When a manager understands the value of regular, consistent feedback, performance reviews stop being an annual occurrence. Many successful employers prefer quarterly meetings for monitoring performance reviews. The semiannual meetings are specifically for long-term planning and evaluation. In this system, you are discussing an employee’s career and evaluating performance at least four times each year.

Set Goals

Regardless of the specific components of a given performance review process, the first step will always be goal setting. The key to this process is that the employee understands exactly what is expected of their performance. Your periodic talks about performance should be focused on these major aspects of the employee’s job. If you don’t have a written agreement and shared vision of the employee’s career goals, it will be difficult for them to succeed.

Aligning Reviews with Development and Organizational Goals

Effective employee reviews not only evaluate performance but also chart a path for growth. Align individual goals with the company’s broader mission to ensure that progress benefits both the employee and the organization. Using the SMART framework—Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound—helps make goals actionable and trackable.

Managers should also support employees in achieving these goals through resources, mentorship, and follow-up reviews to assess improvement. This ensures reviews contribute to long-term employee development and retention.

Make the Employee Evaluation Performance Clear

During the goal setting and preparation phase, you should clarify how you will evaluate the employee’s performance. Take the time to describe specifically what you are looking for from them and exactly how you will assess their performance. Discuss the employee’s role in their own evaluation process.

Your organization’s performance review process may include an employee self-evaluation. If so, share the form with the employee and discuss what a self-evaluation entails. Share the performance review format with the employee in detail so they won’t be surprised at their next review. One of the most important parts of this evaluation discussion is sharing with employees how your organization will assess their performance.

Any employee should understand that if they do what is expected of them, they will be considered a well-performing employee. On a five-point scale, you should consider an average employee to be a three. An employee should do more than just perform their regular tasks to be considered as an outstanding employee.

Do Not Only Focus on Recent Events

Rather than judging the employee’s ranking performance based on recent events, you should be responsible for making note of positive occurrences like completed projects alongside any negative occurrences like a missed deadline, over a full-time period that the performance review covers. Many organizations call the documenting of an employee's positive and negative occurrences a “critical incident report.” Be sure to ask your employee to also keep meticulous records so together you can develop a complete look at their overall performance during that time.

Solicit Feedback

Ask for feedback from colleagues who have worked closely with any employee with whom you’re about to meet. Soliciting feedback from colleagues who work closely with them is referred to as 360-degree feedback. This is because you are collecting feedback from everyone surrounding that employee: their boss, co-workers, and all reporting staff. Then, you will use that feedback to broaden the performance information provided in the review. Begin the process with informal discussions to better obtain feedback information. Think about developing a consistent, simple format, so the feedback is easier to digest and share with the employee’s manager.

If your company is going to use a form that must be filled out in advance, give the full performance review to the employee ahead of the meeting. Giving them their performance review in advance allows them to digest its contents before the discussion. Further, giving the performance review to an employee early may remove some emotion or outbursts from the actual meeting.

Spend Plenty of Time on the Positive Aspects

When you meet with an employee, take care to spend time on several positive aspects of their performance. This discussion about positive components should be longer than the conversation about any negative issues.

Giving positive feedback and discussing how the employee might be able to grow their performance should be the majority of your discussion. This makes the review a more motivating and rewarding experience. You shouldn’t have any employees with only negative performance. If you do, the problem is with your training and termination process, rather than the review process. That said, you should not neglect any areas which need improvement. If an employee is underperforming, be direct and address the issues. Make the importance clear, and take the time to ensure that they understand your feedback.

Performance reviews are often a manager’s least favorite part of their job. Without proper training and preparation, the process is uncomfortable and often counterproductive. Fortunately, implementing these simple strategies will allow managers to look forward to their reviews as simply a part of the process of growing the company’s success.

The Future of Employee Reviews

Traditional employee reviews are evolving into continuous feedback systems that emphasize growth over evaluation. Many experts recommend supplementing annual reviews with real-time feedback and coaching sessions to make development ongoing rather than episodic.

Regular, specific, and timely communication builds engagement and reduces the anxiety associated with annual reviews. Ultimately, companies that move toward an open-feedback culture experience improved morale, higher retention, and stronger performance.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. How often should employee reviews be conducted?
    Most organizations find quarterly or biannual reviews effective, with additional informal check-ins throughout the year.
  2. What are the main goals of employee reviews?
    They align employees with company goals, identify development opportunities, and promote open communication.
  3. How can managers make reviews more effective?
    By providing specific feedback, encouraging dialogue, and following up on progress.
  4. Should reviews include peer feedback?
    Yes, peer feedback adds valuable perspective and supports collaboration and trust.
  5. Can employee reviews be replaced by continuous feedback systems?
    Continuous feedback complements formal reviews by addressing issues in real time and fostering a culture of ongoing growth.

If you need help with employee reviews, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.