Key Takeaways

  • An arm's length transaction ensures fair market value by keeping parties independent and unaffiliated.
  • It is crucial in real estate, tax assessments, and international transfer pricing.
  • Non-arm’s length transactions can lead to tax issues, financing difficulties, and legal complications.
  • Legal tests (e.g., common control, acting in concert) help determine arm's length status.
  • Documentation like an “Affidavit of Arm's Length Transaction” may be required in certain real estate scenarios.

What Is an Arm's Length Transaction?

"Arm's length" refers to a legal transaction in which buyers and sellers of products or services have no relationship to one another either by blood, marriage, or business dealings. Without a relationship, buyers and sellers can act independently. Without previous ties, an arm's length transaction makes sure neither person feels pressured by the other or acts in connection with one another.

The idea of an arm's length transaction, also known as an arm-in-arm transaction, came about in the real estate market as a way of handling tax authorities. Generally, family members and businesses with related shareholders are not acting at arm's length, which can cause ethical problems. Such ethical issues include a company's supervisor who forces an employee, under the threat of termination, to buy real estate using the boss's name.

In the 1997 case McNichol et al v. The Queen, the tax judge suggested three tests or criteria to be used when deciding whether individuals involved in legal cases act at arm's length. These tests include:

  • A common mind directing the negotiations and bargaining for both parties in the transaction
  • Parties acting in concert without separate interests
  • De facto control

One question can summarize these points: Does one individual have control over another? If so, the transaction is not considered at arm's length.

Legal and Regulatory Relevance

Arm’s length transactions are foundational in tax law and regulatory compliance. Tax authorities, including the IRS and CRA, use the concept to evaluate the legitimacy of pricing in transactions, especially where related parties are involved. In international business, arm’s length principles underpin OECD guidelines for transfer pricing, ensuring that cross-border transactions reflect market value and prevent tax base erosion.

Why Is an Arm's Length Transaction Important?

An arm's length transaction serves as a basis for figuring out fair market value (FMV). This value is the estimated price of a property based on what a buyer would pay based on values in the current real estate market.

When trying to decide a property's market value, an arm's length transaction is necessary to find the right price. If not, the agreed-upon purchase price could be different from the property's actual fair market value.

Arm's Length Examples

When a homebuyer purchases a house from a seller, the negotiated purchase price is more likely to be close to market value. The reason is that the buyer wants to keep the price as low as possible, but the seller wants the highest possible price. Each person involved in this real estate transaction has equal bargaining power.

When family members become involved, the result can be different. Parents who sell their house valued at $250,000 for the bargain price of $150,000 to their child is one example. The transaction won't likely produce the same result if it occurred between two people with no relationships between them.

A real estate transaction directly impacts financing, local taxes, stamp duty, and other factors. This transaction also sets comparable prices on the market, which is why maintaining arm's length transactions is so important. A non-arm's length transaction is a higher risk to lenders because of possible inflated sales prices, unsupported values, and misrepresentation. As such, qualifying for financing if you're purchasing a home from a relative can be more difficult.

Financial Effects

In fact, FHA (Federal Housing Administration) loans require an 85 percent "Loan-to-Value" (LTV) ratio in a non-arm's length transaction. The term LTV gets used in risk assessment to express the ratio of the loan to the value of the asset being purchased. In some cases, the 85 percent LTV can be waived if the buyer has lived at the property for six months or more before the purchase. Other exceptions include one of a home builder's employee buying a house.

Arm's length transactions are also important to prevent real estate transactions under coercion. If someone gets forced to sign an agreement under duress, the transaction won't hold.

Another example is when one person lacks the capacity to participate in the transaction. An example of this situation involves a parent trying to conduct a transaction with a minor child. An arm's length approach essentially protects you from buying or selling real estate against your will.

Key Characteristics of an Arm’s Length Transaction

To qualify as an arm's length transaction, several conditions should be met:

  • Independence: The parties must be unrelated and free of any undue influence or pressure.
  • Equal Bargaining Power: Each party must have equal ability to negotiate the terms.
  • Full Disclosure: All material information must be transparently shared.
  • Market-Based Terms: The transaction terms should reflect current market conditions.

These factors help establish that both parties acted in their own self-interest, supporting the accuracy of the fair market value.

What Could Happen If You Buy Property in a Non-Arm's Length Transaction?

A non-arm's length transaction often has tax consequences. You could be hit with more taxes resulting from a real estate transfer occurring at less than fair market value. If you're considering a short sale purchase, you should consider tax penalties.

However, short sale lenders often require individuals to sign an Affidavit of Arm's Length Transaction, which states that all people involved are unrelated to one another. This document ensures that everyone is acting in the best interests to complete the transaction at a fair market price.

Arm's length requirements in Short Sales have some of the following issues:

  • Short-sale lenders don't allow real estate agents to list their own properties as short sales.
  • Short-sale lenders don't allow a real estate agent related to the seller to list the property.

These lenders demand that all people not be associated through family or business to get a true fair market value. As such, FHA buyers and those considering a short-sale transaction should be aware of these conflicts. Disclose any conflicts of interest early in the process; otherwise, you could risk losing the real estate.

In the case of family transactions, the law will check to make sure the property gets sold at fair market value and that all facts are correctly represented. If a seller wants a relative to buy a home below market price, the transaction could be considered a gift instead of an arm's length transaction.

Non-Arm’s Length Transactions and Tax Implications

In non-arm's length transactions, pricing may not reflect fair market value, potentially triggering tax consequences such as:

  • Gift Tax: If property is sold below market value to a family member, the IRS may classify the difference as a gift, resulting in additional tax liability.
  • Capital Gains Adjustment: Tax authorities may recalculate the capital gains based on FMV, not the transaction price.
  • Audit Risk: Unusual pricing in related-party deals may prompt audits or scrutiny.

Maintaining arm's length standards helps mitigate these risks and supports defensible tax reporting.

Do You Need Help Determining an Arm's Length Transaction?

Common Examples in Business and Finance

Examples of arm's length transactions outside real estate include:

  • Commercial Contracts: A vendor and client negotiating terms without prior relationship.
  • Stock Purchases: Buying shares on the open market, where buyers and sellers act independently.
  • M&A Deals: Acquisitions involving third-party due diligence and fair value assessments.

These scenarios illustrate the importance of maintaining independence to validate the fairness of transaction terms.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What does it mean for a transaction to be at arm’s length?
    It means the parties involved act independently without any special relationship, ensuring the transaction reflects fair market value.
  2. Why does the IRS care about arm’s length transactions?
    To prevent tax avoidance and ensure accurate reporting of income, gains, and deductions in related-party transactions.
  3. Can business partners have an arm’s length transaction?
    It depends. If they can act independently without undue influence or shared control, it may still qualify.
  4. Is an arm’s length affidavit legally binding?
    Yes, especially in real estate short sales and FHA-financed deals. It affirms no relationship exists that could affect the sale terms.
  5. What’s the difference between arm’s length and fair market value?
    Fair market value is often the outcome of an arm's length transaction, which is the process ensuring the value is unbiased.

If you need help with arm's length transaction, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.