Key Takeaways

  • An illusory promise lacks mutual obligation, making the contract unenforceable.
  • Courts evaluate enforceability based on mutuality, definiteness, and consideration.
  • Common phrases like “I may” or “if I choose” often signal an illusory promise.
  • Exceptions such as good faith obligations, promissory estoppel, and implied terms can sometimes make such promises enforceable.
  • Understanding the risks of illusory promises helps avoid unenforceable agreements in business deals.

An illusory promise is one that is unenforceable. This is due to a lack of mutuality or indefiniteness where only one party is bound to perform. An illusory promise is based on deception or parameters that are indefinite, making it unclear what must be done or if performance is optional.

Overview of Illusory Promise

When a contract contains a statement by the promisor that requires no actual obligation on the part of that person to fulfill, the promise is an illusory promise. This is also referred to as an illusory contract. An example of an illusory contract would be if a seller agrees to sell "all the goods he wants to" to a buyer. In this case, the promisor has no actual obligation clearly stated.

The language used in this type of agreement makes it unclear whether the promising party must perform due to the lack of clarity in the language used.  Even if the party is compensated, the language does not make that clear. Because the agreement does not clearly outline the performance required by one party and appears to bind the other only to pay or perform, the agreement is unenforceable in a court of law.

An example would be a situation where one person states that he or she "may" sell you an item if you pay a specified amount of money. The seller's use of the word "may" allows them to perform or not perform, meaning they may or may not sell you the item. This type of promise is illusory. 

Why Illusory Promises Are Problematic

Illusory promises undermine the foundation of contract law because they fail to create a binding obligation. Without clear duties for both parties, the contract lacks the mutual consideration necessary for enforceability. Courts typically strike down these agreements because they provide one party the discretion to perform or not perform, creating uncertainty and preventing reliance by the other party.

Example Phrases That May Signal an Illusory Promise:

  • “I will provide services if I feel like it.”
  • “I may choose to deliver products if I decide to do so.”
  • “We reserve the right to cancel at any time without notice.”

Such language allows one party to avoid commitment, leaving the other exposed to risk without legal recourse.

Conditions for an Illusory Contract

A valid contract contains a promise for one party to perform services or provide goods. The other party must pay a specified sum for these goods or services or provide another form of compensation in return. An illusory contract, however, only contains the illusion of a promise. This holds true whether it is an oral or written agreement.

For a contract to be considered enforceable, it must cover obligation, performance, and consideration.  

Key Elements That Help Prevent an Illusory Contract

To avoid an illusory contract, ensure the following elements are present:

  • Definiteness of Terms: The duties of both parties should be clearly defined.
  • Reciprocal Obligations: Each party must undertake a clear obligation or performance.
  • Commitment to Act: Phrases like "shall" or "will" instead of "may" or "if desired."
  • Specific Timeframes and Conditions: Specify deadlines or conditions under which obligations must be fulfilled.

Including these elements reduces ambiguity and increases the likelihood of enforceability.

Obligation and Performance

The contract must specify mutual obligations to perform and valid consideration. This means performance is required by all parties and something of value must be offered in return.

Difference Between Illusory Promise and Conditional Promise

A conditional promise is enforceable when performance depends on the occurrence of a specified event. This is distinct from an illusory promise, where performance is entirely optional for one party.

Example:

  • Illusory Promise: “I may sell you my car if I feel like it.”
  • Conditional Promise: “I will sell you my car if it passes the mechanic’s inspection.”

In the conditional promise, the obligation becomes clear once the condition is met, whereas the illusory promise offers no genuine commitment.

Consideration

The definition of consideration in this context means it is a benefit, profit, or interest to one party of a contract or a loss or detriment that is undertaken or suffered by the other party. A consideration can be a:

  • Promise.
  • Object.
  • Act.

In contract law, consideration is more important and carries a higher legal value than monetary value. In unilateral contracts, consideration is the promise provided by one party and performed by the other party. In bilateral contracts, both parties make promises that constitute consideration. An illusory promise is the exception and does not apply to mutual obligation in bilateral agreements. 

Intent and Good Faith

A promise made by a party that has the ability/capability to fulfill is not considered illusory if it is shown the party tried to fulfill the promise through reasonable effort. In general, a court will take into consideration the intent of the parties when they drew up their contract. 

Good Faith and Fair Dealing as a Safeguard

Even where language may initially seem illusory, courts can enforce a promise if an obligation of good faith and fair dealing is implied by law. This often applies in:

  • Exclusive Dealing Agreements: The Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) implies a duty to use best efforts in such contracts.
  • Requirements and Output Contracts: These contracts are typically upheld when good faith is shown, even if exact quantities are not specified upfront.

Good faith prevents parties from acting arbitrarily or failing to make reasonable efforts to perform.

Implied Good Faith Terms

A contract may contain a clause that releases a party from their obligation to pay if not satisfied with provided goods or services. This, in effect, creates an illusory contract because there is no obligation on the part of the paying party to pay. 

Fraud and Bad Faith

It is not uncommon for illusory contracts to be created due to misunderstandings and errors by laypeople creating contracts. However, it is possible for someone to deliberately create a vague contract regarding their performance with the intention of defrauding the other party.

Promissory Estoppel

Courts may enforce an illusory promise as being a valid contract by invoking the doctrine of promissory estoppel. The doctrine comes into play when a promise is made to a promisee who relies on the promise to his or her detriment.

Circumstances Where Illusory Promises May Be EnforcedContent:While an illusory promise is generally unenforceable, courts may enforce the agreement in certain circumstances:

  1. Promissory Estoppel: When one party reasonably relies on a promise to their detriment, even if the promise was vague.
  2. Partial Performance: If one party begins to perform, courts may view this as evidence of mutual intent.
  3. Implied Terms by Law: Courts may supply missing terms, especially in business relationships where standard practices imply obligations.

These exceptions help protect parties who may otherwise suffer unfair harm due to unclear contract language.

Types of Illusory Promises

There are three types of illusory promises:

  1. Personal satisfaction clause.
  2. Exclusive dealing contracts.
  3. Requirements and outputs contracts.

Courts generally follow the premise that the parties involved in creating a contract had the intention of making it valid. Because of this, courts lean toward not interpreting contracts as illusory promises.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What makes a promise "illusory"?
    A promise is illusory if it lacks a firm obligation for one party to perform, often using language like "may" or "if I choose," leaving performance entirely optional.
  2. Are illusory promises always unenforceable?
    Typically, yes. However, they may still be enforced under exceptions like promissory estoppel, implied good faith obligations, or partial performance.
  3. How can I avoid making an illusory promise in a contract?
    Use clear, definite language that outlines specific obligations and mutual consideration. Avoid vague terms that allow one party sole discretion.
  4. Can a conditional promise be mistaken for an illusory promise?
    Yes, but the key difference is that conditional promises become enforceable once the condition occurs, whereas illusory promises lack any binding commitment.
  5. What is an example of an illusory promise clause in a contract?
    A clause stating, "Party A agrees to purchase goods if and when they desire," would likely be considered illusory because it provides no clear obligation to purchase.

If you need help with illusory promise, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.