Key Takeaways

  • A valid contract of sale requires offer, acceptance, consideration, intention to create legal relations, and capacity of parties.
  • Under UCC Article 2, sales contracts can be valid even without a precise moment of agreement or complete terms.
  • Offers can be revoked unless they are firm merchant offers in writing.
  • Acceptance can be made in any reasonable manner, and contracts can still be valid despite differing terms.
  • Statute of Frauds generally requires contracts for goods $500+ to be in writing.
  • Contracts may be modified without new consideration, but must follow agreed formalities.
  • Buyer and seller have specific performance obligations, including delivery, payment, and risk allocation.
  • Breach of contract occurs when parties fail to meet obligations; remedies vary based on the nature of breach.

Formation of a contract requires several important elements, including the goal of creation of a legal relationship between two parties.

Formation of Contract Basics

The easiest way to understand a contract is as a legal agreement between two parties. Several elements go into the formation of contract, but the initial step is one party making an offer and the other party accepting. At least two parties are required for a contract to be formed, as there must be both an offeror and an offeree. 

Another important factor in forming a contract is a meeting of the minds. This is when the two parties negotiate the terms of the contract, which they intend to be legally binding, and then agree on those terms.

If there is a dispute between the two parties, such as a breach of contract lawsuit, courts will examine multiple elements to determine if the agreement was valid, including the:

  • Offer.
  • Acceptance.
  • Consideration.

Additional elements that can be examined include:

  • Whether formalities were observed.
  • The legal capacity, or lack thereof, of the parties.
  • Whether the parties intended to create a legal relationship.

UCC Rules and Contract Formation for Sale of Goods

The formation of a contract of sale is governed by general contract principles and, in the case of goods, the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) Article 2. The UCC simplifies contract formation and enforces agreements even when some terms are left open. For example, a contract can be valid without specifying the exact time of delivery or even a set price, as long as the intent to contract is clear.

Additionally, while a precise moment of mutual agreement isn’t required under the UCC, there must be clear offer and acceptance. This approach facilitates smoother commercial transactions by prioritizing intent and performance over formality.

What is an Offer?

Making an offer is the first step in the formation of contract. With an offer, one party proposes to another that they will enter a legal contract with defined terms. The intent of the offer must be serious, and it should be easily understood by all parties involved.

An offer can also be understood as the inclination to enter into a legally binding contract as soon as the offeree accepts. It's important to understand that an invitation to treat is different from an offer. An invitation to treat means a party is open to hearing offers, which they will then decide whether to accept or not.

Offers can be made to individuals and even the world at large, meaning the scope of an offer can vary widely.  When an offer is made, it should include language that indicates the offeror is willing to enter into a contract without any additional negotiations taking place upon acceptance. 

Auctions are the perfect example of how offers work. When the auctioneer opens bidding, it would be considered an invitation to treat, as they are ready to hear offers. In this case, the offers are the attendees' bids. If the auctioneer accepts the bid, a contract is formed.

Firm Offers and Revocation Rules Under UCC

Under UCC § 2-205, if a merchant makes an offer in writing to buy or sell goods and includes an assurance that the offer will be held open, that offer is considered a firm offer and cannot be revoked for the stated time or, if unspecified, for a reasonable period up to three months. This rule encourages commercial reliability and prevents opportunistic revocations before the offeree can respond.

What is Acceptance?

Acceptance occurs when the party who was made an offer accepts it without qualification.

Acceptance can take place in many forms. For example, a person can accept an offer either verbally or orally and can also accept an offer through their conduct.  A contract cannot be legally binding unless the offer and acceptance match.

Several requirements must be met for an acceptance to be legal:

  • The acceptance needs to mirror the offer.
  • The offeree must have full knowledge of the offer before accepting.
  • The offeree must clearly communicate their acceptance to the offeror. Once the acceptance has been communicated, the contract becomes binding.

If there is a condition that accompanies the acceptance, the contract is not binding. 

Acceptance with Additional or Different Terms

UCC § 2-207 allows an acceptance to be valid even if it contains terms that differ from the original offer. If both parties are merchants, those differing terms can become part of the contract unless:

  • The offer expressly limits acceptance to its own terms,
  • The new terms materially alter the contract, or
  • The original offeror objects to the new terms in a timely manner.

This flexibility aims to prevent minor discrepancies from invalidating contracts, particularly in high-volume commercial transactions where form exchanges are common.

Making a Counter Offer

It's possible that the offeree can make a counter offer instead of accepting the original offer. With a counter offer, the offeree would propose new terms or a change in the original terms. The party that originally made the offer has the ability to either reject or accept the counter offer. Once a counter offer is made, acceptance of the original offer is no longer possible, as a counter offer is considered a rejection of the first offer.

Communicating Acceptance

As a rule, the offeree must clearly communicate their acceptance to the offeror. Contracts do not become legally binding until this communication occurs. The offeree can either communicate their acceptance themselves, or they can authorize a representative, such as an attorney, to alert the offeror that their offer has been accepted.

If someone accepts an offer without the authorization of the offeree, the acceptance is not considered legal.  Additionally, offerors cannot hold the offeree to contracts if no response is given. If the acceptance occurs via an instant form of communication, such as an email or telex, the contract becomes binding as soon as the offeror receives the notification. 

Statute of Frauds and Written Contract Requirements

The UCC’s Statute of Frauds generally requires that a contract for the sale of goods priced at $500 or more be in writing and signed by the party to be charged. However, there are exceptions:

  • If the goods are specially manufactured,
  • If part performance has occurred (goods delivered and accepted or payment made),
  • If the party admits in court that a contract exists.

This rule is designed to prevent fraud while still allowing some informal contracts to be enforceable when supported by conduct or acknowledgment.

Modifying Contracts of Sale

Unlike general contract law, the UCC does not require additional consideration to enforce a contract modification. This is particularly helpful in long-term or evolving sales agreements. However, the modification must meet any formal requirements specified in the original contract, such as being in writing or signed by both parties. Failure to comply with such formalities may render the modification unenforceable.

Performance Obligations in a Contract of Sale

Once a contract is formed, the seller’s obligation is to deliver conforming goods, and the buyer’s obligation is to accept and pay for them. The UCC outlines rules related to:

  • The time, place, and manner of delivery,
  • Risk of loss before delivery,
  • Inspection rights before acceptance,
  • Payment terms, including the possibility of cash on delivery.

Non-performance or delivery of non-conforming goods may constitute a breach, entitling the buyer to reject or revoke acceptance under certain conditions.

Breach and Remedies Under Contract of Sale

Both buyers and sellers have remedies when the other party breaches a contract of sale:

  • Buyer Remedies: Right to reject goods, claim damages, or cover by purchasing substitute goods.
  • Seller Remedies: Right to withhold delivery, resell goods, or claim damages.
  • Right to Assurance: If one party has reasonable doubts about the other’s performance, they can demand written assurance. Failure to provide it within 30 days constitutes anticipatory repudiation.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is the formation of contract of sale under UCC?
    It involves offer, acceptance, and intent to form a binding agreement. UCC Article 2 applies specifically to goods and allows some flexibility in terms.
  2. Does a contract of sale need to be in writing?
    Yes, if the value of the goods is $500 or more, unless exceptions like partial performance or specially manufactured goods apply.
  3. Can an offer be revoked before acceptance?
    Generally yes, but not if it's a merchant's firm offer in writing, which is irrevocable for a reasonable period up to three months.
  4. Is new consideration required to modify a sales contract?
    No. Under the UCC, a contract can be modified without additional consideration as long as both parties agree and any formalities are met.
  5. What happens if goods delivered do not match the contract?
    The buyer may reject the goods, demand replacements, or claim damages, depending on the severity and timing of the breach.

If you need help with formation of contract, you can post your legal needs on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.