Key Takeaways

  • The formation of contract depends on mutual agreement, offer and acceptance, consideration, legality, and intent to create legal relations.
  • A valid offer must be clear, definite, and communicated to the other party.
  • Acceptance must mirror the offer and be communicated through authorized or recognized channels; silence generally does not count as acceptance.
  • Consideration must have value and move from both parties; it distinguishes enforceable contracts from mere promises or gifts.
  • Contracts require legality of purpose, capacity of parties, and certainty of terms to be enforceable.
  • Modern contract formation includes electronic communications, digital signatures, and even smart contracts under evolving laws.
  • “Subject to contract” and pre-contract documents like letters of intent can delay binding obligations until finalization.

How are contracts formed? Contracts are a legally binding agreement between two parties.

Contract Basics

Contracts have requirements they must follow in order for them to be enforced in a court of law. Every contract will differ depending on the agreement they are protecting regarding certain goods and/or services. When entering into a contract, both parties should fully understand all of the rights and responsibilities included in the agreement before signing. 

Intention to Create Legal Relations

A crucial yet often overlooked element in the formation of a contract is the intention to create legal relations. This principle ensures that parties genuinely mean to enter into a legally enforceable agreement rather than a casual or social arrangement. Courts typically presume an intention to create legal relations in commercial agreements, whereas domestic or social arrangements—such as agreements between family members—are presumed not to have legal intent.However, these presumptions can be rebutted with clear evidence. For example, a business agreement marked “subject to contract” signals that the parties do not yet intend to be legally bound until a formal document is signed.

In modern practice, emails, text messages, and even emoji responses can inadvertently demonstrate contractual intent. Businesses should therefore ensure that informal communications cannot be interpreted as binding commitments unless that is their intention

Elements of a Contract          

Contracts can only be formed when all parties involved in the contract are in full agreement on the promises made in the contract, which is called the meeting of the minds. If a contract is brought before a court, it will be reviewed to be sure that it is valid and enforceable.

There are four basic elements to a creating a valid contract:

  • Offer
  • Acceptance
  • Consideration
  • Legality

Certainty and Completeness of Terms

For the formation of contract to be valid, the agreement must be certain and complete. Courts will not enforce vague or ambiguous terms that make it impossible to determine the obligations of each party.Essential elements like the subject matter, price, quantity, and timing must be sufficiently clear. If key terms remain “to be agreed,” the contract may be considered incomplete and therefore unenforceable.Courts may, however, imply terms based on prior dealings, trade usage, or statutory provisions to fill minor gaps, ensuring that business efficacy is preserved wherever possible

Offer

The first step to forming a contract is an offer, which is sometimes viewed as the element that is most frequently disputed. When one party offers goods or services to another in exchange for something else, this is considered an offer. Offers manifest the willingness of the parties to enter into a contract with one another, so they need to be clearly defined.

An offer has to be presented so that both parties are aware that a contract will be formed if the offer is accepted. Offers may stay open or available for a certain amount of time depending on what is being offered and by whom. 

The following elements can affect the time span of an offer's availability:

  • Type of contract
  • Contract language
  • State in which the contract is formed

Offer Acceptance

The next step towards forming a contract is the offer acceptance, which is when the party to whom the offer of goods or services was extended agrees to it and to the terms included. Usually, an offer is only accepted when the terms are not changed, but sometimes that rule changes depending on the type of contract being offered.

Whether the offer is for goods or service will determine if the terms of the offer may be changed upon acceptance. Acceptance must be made clear to both parties involved in the contract, and not only expressed to a third party. In some cases, the offer acceptance may be communicated between two authorized persons on behalf of the involved parties. 

If anyone who is unauthorized tries to accept an offer in the place of one of the involved parties, the acceptance will not be valid. Offers accepted via mail are exceptions to this rule and the act of sending a written form of offer acceptance makes it valid. Silence does not equal acceptance of an offer. If there is no response, the offer is considered unaccepted. 

Any change to the terms of the offer is called a counteroffer. Counteroffers themselves do not constitute acceptance. A new offer has virtually been formed, so the process restarts. In this case, the party who made the original offer now needs to decide whether or not to accept this new offer. When a counteroffer is made, the original offer is considered rejected and the rejecting party cannot later decide to accept the original offer. 

Termination and Revocation of Offers

An offer does not last indefinitely. It may be revoked, rejected, or expire due to lapse of time. The general rule is that an offer can be revoked at any time before acceptance, provided the revocation is communicated to the offeree.An offer may also terminate automatically upon the death or incapacity of the offeror, or when the conditions for acceptance are not met within the specified period. A counteroffer, as mentioned earlier, effectively rejects the original offer, bringing negotiations back to the proposal stage.In commercial negotiations, parties often issue letters of intent or heads of terms, which express preliminary agreement but usually state that they are not legally binding until a full contract is executed. These documents can still influence later disputes about whether a contract was intended to be formed.

Communication and Mode of Acceptance

Acceptance must be communicated through an appropriate channel specified or implied by the offeror. Under the postal rule, acceptance is effective when posted, even if it is delayed or lost, but this does not apply to instant communications like emails or text messages, where acceptance is typically effective upon receipt.Electronic transactions, including click-wrap and digital signature agreements, are recognized under modern contract law, provided they show clear consent to the terms. Courts may also uphold implied acceptance if parties begin performing the contract before formal documentation is completed.

Contract Consideration

Consideration in contracts is a vital part of forming a valid contract and refers to what each of the involved parties gains from the agreement. Without consideration, one side is giving something to the other while getting nothing in return. This is called a gift. Considerations usually involve products or services being exchanged for money or a promise of money.

There are three types of contract consideration:

  • Present consideration: money is given at the beginning of a contract
  • Past consideration: the service or product has already been given without any exchange and at this point, it is too late to form a contract.
  • Future consideration: a promise is made by one or both parties to provide something for the exchange. 

Adequacy vs. Sufficiency of Consideration

Consideration must be sufficient but need not be adequate. This means that while the consideration must have some measurable value in the eyes of the law, it doesn’t have to be equal in economic value to what is received in return. For example, a court will uphold an agreement to sell a car for $1, as long as both parties intended it to be a valid bargain.However, past consideration—something done before the promise—is not valid for the formation of contract. Similarly, performing a pre-existing duty, such as one required by law or an existing contract, does not usually constitute valid consideration unless additional benefits or obligations are introduced.

Legality

Contracts can only be formed legally when the products or services being exchanged are legal. Illegal contracts will not be enforced by a court, so if a two parties form a contract regarding the sale of an illegal substance, neither party can be held to that promise by a court. 

Capacity and Consent

A contract cannot be validly formed unless both parties have legal capacity and genuine consent. Minors, persons of unsound mind, and entities acting beyond their authority may lack capacity, rendering the contract void or voidable.Consent must be freely given—contracts entered into through misrepresentation, duress, undue influence, or mistake may be voided by the affected party. Courts will examine whether the consent was obtained voluntarily and with full understanding of the terms involved.This requirement ensures that each party’s participation in the contract reflects an informed, intentional decision to assume the associated obligations.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What are the main elements required for the formation of contract?

The key elements are offer, acceptance, consideration, intention to create legal relations, legality, and certainty of terms.

2. Can a contract be formed by email or text message?

Yes. Courts recognize digital communications as capable of forming valid contracts if they demonstrate clear agreement and intention to be bound.

3. What happens if a contract term is uncertain or incomplete?

If essential terms are vague or missing, the contract may be unenforceable unless courts can imply reasonable terms based on context or prior dealings.

4. Is past consideration valid in the formation of contract?

No. Consideration must be given in exchange for a current or future promise—past actions or services generally do not qualify.

5. Can a contract be enforced if formed under duress or misrepresentation?

No. A contract formed without genuine consent—such as through coercion or deceit—can be voided by the affected party.

If you need help with understanding how contracts are formed, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.