Key Takeaways:

  • A binding contract is an agreement enforceable by law and must include an offer, acceptance, consideration, and mutual intent.
  • Essential contract elements include legality, capacity, and clear terms and conditions.
  • Contracts can be written or verbal, but written contracts are more enforceable, especially in complex agreements.
  • Common contract breaches include failure to perform duties, non-payment, and misrepresentation.
  • Certain contracts, like real estate agreements and contracts exceeding one year, must be in writing.
  • Electronic contracts and signatures are legally binding if they meet federal and state law requirements.
  • Non-binding agreements can outline intentions without enforceability, commonly used in preliminary negotiations.
  • If uncertain about contract enforceability, consulting an attorney is advisable.

What Is a Legally Binding Contract?

Legally binding contracts are agreements made between two or more parties that are enforceable by law and are valid according to federal and state contract laws. Since a contract is legally binding, all parties are obligated to adhere to its terms and fulfill their contractual duties.

There are many ways a legally binding contract can be created. The best way is for both parties to draft a contract together and put it in writing with the terms and conditions clearly outlined. However, emailing, faxing, or calling someone and agreeing to an exchange of services is also considered creating a legally binding contract.

If parties think the contract has been broken and want to dispute the legality of their arrangement, they may have to take the case to court where a judge will decide if there has been a breach of contract by looking at certain criteria. However, legal action shouldn't be taken lightly, especially because contract law can be complex and time-consuming.

For a contract to be legally binding, it must contain the following essential elements:

  • An agreement
  • Consideration

In addition to the two required elements, other provisions can be added to increase a contract's legality. These items include things like:

  • Terms
  • Conditions
  • Offer
  • Performance
  • Obligations
  • Payment terms
  • Liability
  • Breach of contract

To enter into a contractual agreement, both parts must be competent and cannot be under the age of 18 or under the influence of drugs or alcohol. All parties must be of sound mind when entering the contract and have the legal power to join the agreement, which is especially important for companies or third parties. A contract that was created by force or coercion isn't considered legally binding, nor is one that involves illegal activity, such as a contract to sell illegal drugs. In some cases, such as with the sale of real estate, contracts must be in writing to be valid.

Types of Binding Contracts

A legally binding contract can take various forms, each suited for different transactions:

  1. Written Contracts – Formalized in a document, these provide strong legal enforceability.
  2. Verbal Contracts – While legally binding in some cases, proving terms can be difficult.
  3. Implied Contracts – Created through actions rather than explicit words or writing.
  4. Unilateral Contracts – One party makes a promise in exchange for an act (e.g., reward offers).
  5. Bilateral Contracts – Both parties agree to mutual obligations (e.g., employment agreements).
  6. Executed vs. Executory Contracts – Executed contracts are fully performed, while executory contracts have obligations yet to be fulfilled.

Each type has different legal implications, and the level of enforceability varies based on the circumstances and applicable laws.

Important Elements of a Contract

1. Offer

A contract must clearly state an offer to do something, such as an offer for a job. The offer can include counteroffers and negotiations between the two parties. An offer must include a timeframe and has to be precise. An offer lapses when the timeframe for acceptance has passed or if the offer is withdrawn. An offer can be written or oral, except in contracts for real estate or those that last more than a year, which must be agreed to in writing. Contract requirements vary by state, so it is important to find the correct laws for your state.

2. Acceptance

Acceptance of a contract can only include what is in the offer, and the terms and conditions must be accepted exactly as they are proposed. Counteroffers and negotiations can happen before acceptance to tailor the offer to the correct terms and conditions. If new terms are proposed, it is considered a counteroffer. Negotiations for a contract end when the terms are accepted, no matter which party makes the final offer. Acceptance can be written, verbal, or done by performing actions from the contract that indicates acceptance, such as completing the service from the offer. 

3. Intention of Legal Consequences

All parties involved in the contract must realize they are entering a legally binding agreement and should state they will follow the contract or risk being taken to court. A contract doesn't have to specifically state this, however, because the intention to create legal relations is assumed when entering a contract. In order for a contract to not be legally enforceable, all parties must agree that the contract is not to be legally bound.

4. Consideration

Valuable consideration is required for a contract to be legally binding. That means that one party is agreeing to do something in return for a promise of value from the other party. Essentially, consideration is a trust agreement between the two parties. It is often a monetary price for the service being exchanged, but can also be anything of value. All parties in the contract have to receive something of value or else it is considered a gift instead of a contract.

When Does a Contract Become Enforceable?

For a contract to be legally binding, it must meet certain enforceability criteria:

  • Written Requirement – Some contracts, such as those involving real estate or agreements lasting more than a year, must be in writing under the Statute of Frauds.
  • Electronic Signatures – Digital contracts and e-signatures are enforceable under the Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce (E-SIGN) Act and Uniform Electronic Transactions Act (UETA).
  • Performance-Based Acceptance – In some cases, fulfilling an obligation (such as providing a service) confirms contract acceptance.
  • Mutual Assent – Even in informal agreements, clear agreement from both parties is necessary for enforceability.

A court may void a contract if these conditions are not met.

Binding vs. Non-Binding Contracts

Not all contracts are legally binding. Some agreements serve as preliminary documents rather than enforceable commitments. Key distinctions include:

  • Binding Contracts – Clearly define obligations and are enforceable by law.
  • Non-Binding Agreements – Typically used for letters of intent, preliminary negotiations, or agreements stating they are not legally enforceable.

Understanding these distinctions helps businesses and individuals determine the enforceability of their agreements under the law.

Common Breaches of Contract

A contract breach occurs when one party fails to fulfill its obligations. Common types include:

  1. Material Breach – A significant violation preventing contract fulfillment.
  2. Minor Breach – A partial failure that does not completely undermine the agreement.
  3. Anticipatory Breach – When one party indicates in advance that they will not fulfill the contract.
  4. Fundamental Breach – A severe violation allowing the non-breaching party to terminate the contract.

Legal remedies for breach of contract may include compensation for damages, contract termination, or specific performance.

Frequently Asked Questions 

  1. What makes a contract legally binding?
    A contract must include offer, acceptance, consideration, legality, and mutual intent to be enforceable.
  2. Are verbal contracts enforceable?
    Yes, but proving terms can be difficult. Some contracts, like real estate agreements, must be in writing.
  3. Can an email agreement be legally binding?
    Yes, emails can form a contract if they contain clear intent and agreement on terms.
  4. What happens if someone breaches a contract?
    The non-breaching party may seek damages, contract termination, or enforcement through legal action.
  5. Are electronic contracts legally binding?
    Yes, electronic contracts and signatures are valid under federal and state laws.

If you need help with legally binding contracts, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.