Key Takeaways

  • An offer is a definite proposal made with intent to create a binding contract once accepted.
  • Offers must include clear terms and be communicated to the offeree.
  • Revocation is possible before acceptance, except in cases like option contracts.
  • Valid offers must reflect mutual intent, legality, and clarity.
  • The nature of an offer can vary by industry (e.g., real estate vs. finance).

The best definition of an offer is a promise made from one party to another. Making an offer is the first step of forming a contract, and when the receiving party accepts the offer, the contract becomes legally binding.

Facts About Offers

Offers are promises made voluntarily, but they come with a condition. The person making the offer is the offeror, and the person receiving the offer is the offeree. Once the offeree accepts the offer, there will be an agreement between the two parties that will be legally enforceable. It's important to understand that an offer is different from a solicitation. With an offer, a person is indicating their desire to enter an agreement with another party. Offers should make it clear to any outside party that accepting the offer would create a binding agreement.

It's common for offers to include a deadline for acceptance. Generally, the assumption is that the deadline for acceptance is 30 days after making the offer unless stated otherwise. Offers can include a variety of conditions and terms:

  • Delivery date
  • Discounts
  • Price
  • Quantity
  • Shipping costs

The person making an offer has the right to withdraw the offer as long as doing so would not harm the other party. This means you can only revoke an offer before acceptance has occurred. Offers related to sales can take place in several ways:

  • A proposal by a buyer to purchase an asset from a seller
  • Offering to sell an asset to another person
  • Making a bid on an asset

There are a variety of offers that can be made, and each type of offer will have distinct characteristics:

  • Requirements for pricing
  • Applicable rules and regulations
  • Assets involved in the offer
  • The motivations of the buyer and the seller

When a home is being sold, for instance, the buyer will make an offer to the person selling the home, and this offer will usually describe the buyer's maximum acceptable price. In terms of debt and equity offerings, the offer would be the price set by the underwriting investment bank for the issued securities. When there is an offer to purchase company stock for current stockholders, this is a tender offer.

When forming a contract, three crucial steps must take place:

  1. Making of an offer
  2. Acceptance of the offer
  3. The parties exchange consideration

Consideration is the most important part of a contract. Consideration is a promise to perform an act or performance of the act itself. The promise to not perform an act can also be a type of consideration. Without consideration, a contract cannot exist.

When there is a dispute related to a contract, one of the most common questions is if an offer was actually made. If you are making an offer, you are communicating your willingness to enter into a contract with another person. To determine if an offer took place, courts will examine whether a reasonable person would have understood that an offer was made for the purposes of forming a contract.

For instance, if you say to another person that you will sell them an item for a set price on a specific date, most courts would decide that this was clearly an offer. On the other hand, if you merely mentioned that you were considering selling the item in question, this would not constitute an offer, because you did not specify any concrete terms.

Types of Offers

Offers can take various forms depending on the context:

  • Express Offer: Clearly stated terms in writing or spoken words.
  • Implied Offer: Inferred from actions, conduct, or circumstances.
  • General Offer: Made to the public at large, such as a reward offer.
  • Specific Offer: Directed at a specific individual or party.
  • Cross Offer: When two parties make identical offers without knowledge of each other’s, no contract is formed.

Each type of offer has different implications for how it may be accepted and whether it results in a binding agreement.

Elements of a Valid Offer

To be legally enforceable, an offer must meet several key criteria:

  • Intent to Create Legal Obligations: The offeror must demonstrate a serious intention to be bound by the offer.
  • Definiteness of Terms: The offer should contain sufficiently definite terms, including subject matter, price, quantity, and time of performance.
  • Communication to the Offeree: The offer must be effectively communicated to the intended recipient, meaning the offeree must know about the offer in order to accept it.
  • Legal Purpose: The offer’s subject matter must be lawful.
  • Certainty and Clarity: Vague or indefinite offers typically cannot form the basis of an enforceable contract.

Courts use an objective standard to determine whether a reasonable person in the position of the offeree would interpret the communication as a serious offer.

How Offers Work

Let's imagine you're interested in buying a house and you search advertisements looking for an available property. You then find an ad in a desirable location for a price that you can afford. This advertisement would constitute an offer, as the current owner of the house has indicated their willingness to sell.

A valid contract necessarily includes an offer. There are, however, five other elements that must exist for a contract to be legally binding:

  1. Acceptance
  2. Consideration
  3. Mutuality
  4. Capacity
  5. Legal terms

Making an offer is the first step of contract formation, and offers come in a variety of forms, including letters, websites, and even behavior. In many cases, an offer will involve money, but it can also be the promise of performance.

Real-World Examples of Offers

Here are examples to illustrate how offers function in different legal and commercial contexts:

  • Real Estate: A buyer makes an offer to purchase a home at a specified price and terms, which the seller can accept, reject, or counter.
  • Employment: A company sends a written offer of employment outlining compensation, duties, and start date.
  • Tender Offers: A corporation publicly offers to buy back shares from shareholders at a fixed price.
  • Service Contracts: A contractor offers to remodel a kitchen for $20,000, including materials and labor, with a 60-day completion timeline.

These examples highlight how diverse offers can be across industries and how essential clarity and intent are in every case.

Offer vs. Invitation to Treat

It’s important to distinguish between an offer and an invitation to treat (or invitation to negotiate). The latter is not an offer but an indication that someone is open to receiving offers. Common examples include:

  • Advertisements (unless exceptionally specific)
  • Store displays or online listings
  • Auction announcements

For example, a product listed on a retail website is not necessarily an offer; it is typically an invitation for consumers to make an offer to buy, which the seller can accept or reject.

Termination of Offers

An offer can be terminated in several ways before acceptance occurs:

  • Revocation by the Offeror: The offeror can withdraw the offer any time before acceptance, unless it’s an irrevocable offer (e.g., option contract).
  • Rejection by the Offeree: A clear refusal or counteroffer terminates the original offer.
  • Lapse of Time: If the offer specifies a time for acceptance, it expires when that time passes; otherwise, it expires after a reasonable time.
  • Death or Incapacity: If either party dies or becomes legally incapacitated before acceptance, the offer terminates.
  • Illegality: If the subject matter of the offer becomes illegal after the offer is made but before it is accepted, the offer is voided.

Understanding these termination principles is critical when evaluating if a contract was actually formed.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is an offer in simple terms? An offer is a proposal made by one party to another to form a legally binding agreement if accepted.

2. Can an offer be revoked after it is made? Yes, but only before it is accepted, unless the offer is part of an option contract or otherwise made irrevocable.

3. What’s the difference between an offer and a contract? An offer is a preliminary step; a contract is formed when an offer is accepted and supported by consideration.

4. Is an advertisement considered an offer? Usually not. Most ads are treated as invitations to negotiate, unless they are clear, definite, and leave nothing open to negotiation.

5. What happens if the terms of an offer are unclear? If terms are too vague, the offer may not be enforceable because a valid contract requires clear and definite terms.

If you need help with the definition of an offer, you can post your legal needs on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.