Key Takeaways

  • Signing papers while under the influence can render a contract voidable if impairment prevents understanding.
  • Courts assess the level of impairment to determine contract enforceability.
  • Mental incapacity claims require substantial evidence, and contracts signed before impairment generally remain valid.
  • Precautions such as court-appointed guardians and witnesses can prevent disputes over contract validity.
  • Fraud or undue influence can invalidate a will, requiring proof of deception or coercion.
  • Specific legal and state requirements govern who can legally sign documents.
  • Electronic signatures may be subject to additional legal scrutiny when impairment is suspected.

Contract Basics

Oftentimes, business owners enter contracts to purchase real estate or obtain legal advice. If the other party wants out of the contract, that person might claim impairment. The ability to cancel the contract depends on the circumstances involving the signing, as well as the party's degree of mental impairment.

While contract laws vary depending upon the state, they typically require that parties be competent and not under duress. Most laws specify that if a person cannot understand the agreement, it is a sign of duress.

According to the law, contracts must have a few specific aspects, including:

  • An offer. One party must accept an offer presented by the other.
  • Agreement terms. Both parties must agree on the material terms.
  • Exchange of consideration. The parties must exchange something of value.

In addition, the agreement terms must remain clear so the court can enforce them. If a party was drunk or impaired at the time of the signing, the impaired party may not have understood what the agreement terms were.

Legal Requirements for Valid Signatures

Legal signatures must meet certain requirements to be enforceable. Beyond competency and duress considerations, the following factors influence a signature’s validity:

  • Age of Majority: In most jurisdictions, individuals must be 18 or older to sign a legally binding document unless an exception applies.
  • Legal Authority: For businesses or entities, only authorized representatives can sign contracts.
  • Electronic vs. Wet Signatures: Electronic signatures are legally binding under the Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce (E-SIGN) Act, but challenges can arise if a signatory was impaired at the time of signing.
  • Notarization and Witnesses: Some documents require notarization or witnesses to confirm authenticity and prevent future disputes.

Impairment When Signing a Contract

If a party signs but cannot understand a contract, the party can sue to void the contract. State and federal laws allow courts to decide whether or not a contract is voidable. The court must also determine if mental impairments prevent a person to agree to the contract.

If a party becomes mentally impaired after signing a contract, the contract typically remains valid. However, if the party signs a contract without an attorney to represent the business and later suffers a brain injury, the court might not make the party carry out the contract or sue for damages.

How Courts Assess Impairment in Contract Law

When determining whether a contract signed under the influence is voidable, courts examine:

  1. Degree of Impairment: Minor intoxication may not be sufficient, but extreme intoxication leading to an inability to understand the contract can be a valid defense.
  2. Burden of Proof: The impaired party must present medical records, witness testimony, or other evidence demonstrating their incapacity.
  3. Intent and Awareness: If the impaired party understood the nature of the agreement at the time of signing, courts may uphold the contract.

In cases where an individual attempts to void a contract due to alleged impairment, courts weigh whether they attempted to benefit from the contract before seeking invalidation.

Contract Signing Under the Influence

Someone who uses drugs or alcohol could become temporarily impaired. Signing a contract while under the influence can become an issue and the contract may be voidable. It usually depends on the extent of the influence and whether the party knew what he or she was doing.

If the court determines that the contract came into existence, the drunken party must show why the contract should be voidable. The court may rule the contract voidable, allowing the impaired party to void the contract.

Special Considerations for Business Contracts

When signing business contracts, impairment can lead to disputes over enforceability. Employers and companies should take extra steps to ensure that:

  • Signers are of sound mind at the time of execution.
  • Employee or executive contracts contain clauses addressing potential disputes arising from impaired signing.
  • Record-keeping and documentation practices include timestamps, witness verification, and consent confirmations to mitigate future legal issues.

Preventing Impairment Claims

If you happen to sign a contract with someone who has a mental illness or developmental delay, take extra precautions to make sure the contract is valid. You can find a court-appointed guardian to sign on behalf of the impaired person. In addition, most states require at least one witness to be at the contract signing.

Legal Safeguards for Signing Important Documents

To prevent disputes related to impairment when signing papers, consider these legal safeguards:

  • Use a Notary Public: Notarization adds an extra layer of legal protection, ensuring the signer understands the document.
  • Video Record the Signing Process: This is useful for high-value contracts or estate planning documents.
  • Consult Legal Counsel: Having an attorney present can help mitigate future claims of impairment.
  • Delay Signing if Needed: If impairment is suspected, postponing the signing until all parties are of sound mind can prevent legal challenges.

Statutory Requirements for a Valid Written Will

When it comes to a written will, there are four main requirements for its formation.

  • It must hold testamentary intent. This means the testator stated the document in question states his or her will at the time.
  • The testator must have testamentary capacity. This involves knowing that he or she is making the will, what the will entails, what the nature of the property is, and understanding the disposition of the assets.
  • The will must be free of fraud, duress, mistakes, or undue influence.
  • The will must go through a proper ceremony.

Many states do not require the testator sign the will at the end of the document. The signature can occur almost anywhere. The will must have the signature of a witness, who must be competent, mature enough, and have sufficient mental capacity so they can testify in court if needed.

The Impact of Impairment on Estate Planning

When creating a will, impairment can lead to disputes over its validity. Common challenges include:

  • Lack of Testamentary Capacity: Courts require proof that the testator understood their estate and beneficiaries.
  • Undue Influence: Family members or caregivers who manipulate an impaired individual to alter their will can face legal consequences.
  • Medical Evaluations: Some individuals opt for a medical examination before signing their will to verify capacity.

If a will is successfully contested on these grounds, the court may invalidate the document and revert to an earlier version or intestacy laws.

Will Invalidation Via Fraud or Undue Influence

Will invalidation by fraud involves falsifying statements of facts whether it involves deceiving the testator or other parties. This can cause the testator to act in reliance on the false statements.

There are two different types of fraud, including fraud in the execution. This occurs when the testator is deceived about the documents he or she is signing. The other is fraud in the inducement, which happens when the testator relies upon a false representation of a material fact made by someone who knew it was false.

Undue influence means that another person's desires replace that of the testator. However, it is difficult to prove because the evidence must be substantial. Simply having a motive or ability to exert influence doesn't provide enough reason for it to happen.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Can a contract be invalidated if signed while drunk?
    Yes, but only if the impaired party can prove they were unable to understand the contract's terms at the time of signing.
  2. What legal protections exist to prevent disputes over impairment?
    Using notaries, witnesses, and video recordings can provide evidence that a signer was competent at the time of signing.
  3. Are electronic signatures affected by impairment claims?
    Yes. While legally binding, electronic signatures may be challenged if impairment can be proven, especially in high-stakes agreements.
  4. Does signing under the influence automatically void a contract?
    No. Courts evaluate the level of impairment, intent, and whether the signer sought to void the contract before enforcement.
  5. How can businesses protect themselves when having contracts signed?
    Businesses should ensure contracts are signed in controlled environments, with witnesses and documentation verifying the signer’s state of mind.

If you need help with signing legal documents under the influence, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.