What Makes a Contract Invalid? Key Reasons & Legal Insights

Key Takeaways

• A contract is invalid if it lacks essential elements such as mutual consent, consideration, or legality.
• A void contract is unenforceable from the beginning, while a voidable contract can be legally enforced unless one party opts to void it.
• Contracts can be invalidated due to illegality, incapacity, fraud, coercion, undue influence, or misrepresentation.
• Public policy violations, such as contracts promoting illegal activities, can also render agreements void.
• Mistakes, including mutual and unilateral errors, may affect contract validity.
• Certain contracts require written documentation under the Statute of Frauds to be enforceable.
• Hiring a lawyer ensures proper drafting and legal compliance to avoid invalid contracts.

Wondering when is a contract invalid? Contracts are legal documents formed between two or more parties that legally bind the parties. A contract must include all legally required elements to be enforced under state and federal laws and to not be deemed invalid. When elements are not met or are missing, it may make the contract invalid. This should be avoided.

Elements of a Contract

There are four main elements that make up a valid and enforceable contract.

1. Offer and Acceptance

A valid contract contains two basic elements: offer and acceptance. The offer contains an outline of the contract specifics laid out by one party. The acceptance occurs when the other party agrees to the terms of the offer, normally in writing. Typically, a negotiation process will take place to fine-tune the details of the contract so both parties are satisfied.

2. Legal Object and Capacity of Parties

To be valid, the contract must include legal subject matter and both parties must:

• Agree to the terms fully
• Be over the age of legal consent
• Have the mental capacity to carry out the agreement

If these three elements are not met, a contract can be deemed invalid.

3. Consideration

For a contract to be deemed valid, an element of consideration must be agreed upon by both parties and exchanged for completing the action described in the contract. A consideration, either price or value, does not only have to be money. A consideration can be a right, interest, or benefit; must benefit both parties; and be of monetary value. An example of a consideration is the sale of a vehicle. One party — the seller — receives money while the buyer receives the vehicle.

4. Written and Verbal

In some instances, an oral agreement may be enforced, but the norm is that most contracts must be in writing to be valid. Written contracts are required in situations where a considerable amount of time will pass before the contract is honored, such as a last will and testament, which includes high-value assets, debts, or property.

Understanding Contract Legality and Enforceability

A contract is only valid if it meets all legal requirements set by state and federal laws. Certain factors can affect its enforceability, including:

• Legal Purpose: The agreement must not involve illegal activities or violate public policy.
• Competency of Parties: Each party must have legal capacity, meaning they are of sound mind and of legal age.
• Genuine Consent: A contract formed under duress, fraud, or undue influence is legally questionable.
• Clear and Definite Terms: Ambiguous terms or a lack of clarity in obligations can lead to contract disputes.
• Statutory Compliance: Some agreements must comply with the Statute of Frauds, requiring a written format.

When Does a Contract Become Void?

A void contract means the contract:

• Cannot be enforced under state or federal law
• Becomes null from the date of origination

Once a contract is void, neither contract is responsible for the terms of the contract.

Common Reasons a Contract is Void

A void contract is considered invalid from the outset and cannot be enforced. Common reasons include:

1. Illegal Subject Matter – Contracts involving unlawful activities, such as drug trafficking or fraud, are unenforceable.
2. Lack of Consideration – Without an exchange of value, the contract is not legally binding.
3. Contracts Against Public Policy – Agreements that promote unethical practices or restrict legal rights (such as unfair non-compete clauses) may be voided.
4. Incompetence of a Party – If one party was mentally incapacitated or a minor, the contract may be nullified.

When Does a Contract Become Voidable?

A contract becomes voidable when the following instances occur:

• A party was threatened or coerced into signing the agreement
• A party was under the influence
• A party is not mentally competent which can mean mentally ill or the party is a minor
• A breach of contract terms occurs
• There are mistakes on the part of both parties
• There is fraudulent information in the form of missing or falsified information or the intent to carry out the contract
• Misrepresentation or false statement of fact has occurred

What Makes a Contract Voidable?

Unlike void contracts, voidable contracts are legally valid until a party chooses to cancel them. The following circumstances can make a contract voidable:

• Fraud or Misrepresentation: If a party deliberately misleads the other about key contract terms, the deceived party may rescind the agreement.
• Undue Influence or Coercion: If one party was pressured into signing the contract against their free will, they may have grounds to nullify it.
• Breach of Fiduciary Duty: If an agreement arises from an unbalanced relationship (e.g., an employer forcing an employee to sign under threat), it may be voidable.
• Mutual Mistake: If both parties operated under a fundamental misunderstanding, they may have the right to invalidate the contract.

The Contract Law

United States Code, Section 10 states: All agreements are contracts if they are made by the free consent of the parties competent to contract, for lawful consideration and with a lawful object, and are not expressly declared to be void.

Executing a Contract

When entering a contract, there are several tips to follow to properly execute a contract.

• Read it fully to avoid missing any complex stipulations or information.
• Confirm the terms of the contract are specific and clearly stated.
• Verify that any phrasing, definitions, or terms are understood and clear.
• Write down the full terms of the contract and avoid oral agreements.
• Note important dates and deadlines.
• Vet the person you are going into contract with by checking references and confirming their identity.
• Review and contemplate all portions of the contract to avoid later legal issues.

Contracts, many times, are deemed void or voidable when the document is illegal, one of the parties is being taken advantage of, or false information was included.

How to Ensure Your Contract is Enforceable

To prevent a contract from being challenged, follow these best practices:

1. Use Clear and Precise Language – Avoid vague or overly complex wording that could lead to misinterpretation.
2. Ensure Mutual Understanding – All parties should fully comprehend their obligations before signing.
3. Include Essential Clauses – Such as dispute resolution, indemnity, and termination clauses to prevent future conflicts.
4. Check for Compliance with Laws – Ensure the contract aligns with industry-specific regulations and general contract law.
5. Signatures & Witnesses – Always obtain signatures from all parties, and in some cases, have contracts notarized for additional legal standing.

Time For a Lawyer?

Contract law can be cumbersome to understand without proper prior knowledge. To avoid a contract that may be deemed void or voidable, hiring a business lawyer to help with the creation, drafting, or editing a contract is recommended. With proper guidance, the issue of breach of contract or violation of contract laws will decrease but also allows for proper legal representation if court meetings are required.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the difference between a void and a voidable contract?
   A void contract is unenforceable from the start, while a voidable contract is initially valid but may be canceled by one party due to specific legal grounds such as fraud or undue influence.
2. Can a contract be invalid if it’s not in writing?
   Yes, certain agreements, such as real estate transactions or contracts exceeding a year, must be in writing under the Statute of Frauds to be legally enforceable.
3. Does a contract need to be notarized to be valid?
   Not necessarily. Most contracts do not require notarization unless state laws or specific contract types (e.g., wills, property deeds) mandate it.
4. Can a contract be invalidated after both parties sign it?
   Yes, a contract may still be challenged and invalidated if it contains fraud, misrepresentation, or illegal terms, even after being signed.
5. How can I ensure my contract won’t be deemed invalid?
   To avoid an invalid contract, clearly define terms, ensure mutual consent, include necessary legal elements, and seek legal counsel before finalizing agreements.

If you need help with contracts, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.