Key Takeaways

  • Restitution is a legal remedy that focuses on restoring the victim or preventing the unjust enrichment of the wrongdoer.
  • In criminal cases, restitution meaning refers to court-ordered payments to victims for financial losses directly resulting from the crime.
  • Civil restitution aims to restore benefits wrongfully gained by the defendant rather than compensating for the plaintiff's losses.
  • Restitution can include various forms of losses—monetary, property-related, or expenses such as medical bills.
  • The restitution process varies by jurisdiction but generally involves court orders, documentation of losses, and payment enforcement.
  • Failure to pay restitution can result in additional penalties, wage garnishments, or extended probation.

The restitution legal definition depends on the laws in a given area. Restitution in criminal cases is a classification of damages that a criminal defendant may be required to pay to compensate a victim for pecuniary losses that the victim may have suffered as a result of the defendant's alleged criminal acts. Restitution in civil cases are completely separate from any related criminal actions and are the result of a successful civil action brought by a plaintiff. Civil damages are designed to restore the plaintiff's state to their state of being before he or she was wronged.

What Is Restitution?

Restitution is the act of restoration. The term is commonly used in civil and criminal cases. Restitution in civil cases is a remedy correlated with unjust enrichment in which the funds recovered are generally based on the gain of the defendant rather than the loss of the plaintiff. Restitution in criminal cases is a partial or full compensation payment made to a victim for a loss, that is paid by the criminal. 

The order of payment is usually made during sentencing or as a condition of receiving probation. One of the costs imposed on a criminal may be that they return stolen goods or make a payment to the victim for the damages that they've caused. Therefore, in this case, restitution is a condition where the defendant returns the goods or makes a payment in order to receive probation.

The goal of restitution is to attain fairness and avoid the unjust enrichment of an individual or party. Restitution is commonly used in contractual situations when one party has granted a benefit or compensation to another party but is unable to collect because the contract has become defective or no longer exists. 

For example, consider a person who builds a shed on a piece of property that doesn't belong to them. Assume further that the shed is erected without a contract and that the property owner refuses to pay the contractor for the barn. Under the doctrine of restitution, and because there was no contract, the court has the right to make the property owner pay the contractor for the costs of materials and labor.

Restitution will be calculated, not based on the plaintiff's loss, but instead on the gains of the defendant. Restitution requires defendants to relinquish any profits that they've unlawfully obtained and return them to the plaintiff. Restitution seems to be used most often in contract law. 

Parties looking for restitution are not able to seek out lost earnings or profits caused by a breach of contract. Restitution can only be obtained by a plaintiff that includes this claim in their initial complaint. Also, unless the amount can be accurately calculated, restitution will not be granted.

There are two main reasons why restitution is most commonly awarded:

  • To make the plaintiff whole and to restore them to a place financially where they were prior to the offense.
  • To forestall the unjust enrichment of the defendant.

To summarize, restitution comes in two formats:

  • A financial remedy to restore one party to a financial position where they would've been prior to the improper action of another party.
  • Ordered by courts during an administrative penalty or criminal sentence.

Types of Restitution in Law

There are several distinct types of restitution that may arise depending on the nature of the case:

  • Criminal Restitution: Ordered by the court as part of a criminal sentence, requiring the defendant to repay the victim for quantifiable losses—such as property damage, medical expenses, or lost income—resulting from the criminal act.
  • Civil Restitution: Focuses on unjust enrichment. It requires a defendant to return a benefit received unfairly, often arising from contract disputes, fraud, or fiduciary breaches.
  • Equitable Restitution: Involves non-monetary remedies such as the return of specific property or assets wrongfully held.
  • Constructive Trusts: Courts may impose a constructive trust on property gained through wrongful conduct, mandating its return to the rightful owner.

These forms of restitution aim to address different legal wrongs but share the central principle of restoring balance between parties.

When Does Restitution Apply?

Restitution regularly occurs when one party has reaped a benefit at someone else's loss and there is an obligation to make the victim whole. For example, the non-breaching party in a contract cancels the contract and files a lawsuit for restitution against the breaching party. Because the breaching party received a benefit to the non-breaching party's detriment, they may file for restitution in a contract lawsuit. On the other hand, in a criminal case, a restitution judgment may force the defendant to financially compensate the plaintiff for harm caused or the value of goods stolen. This is recognized as criminal restitution.

How Restitution Is Calculated and Enforced

In both criminal and civil contexts, the court assesses restitution based on evidence of loss or unjust gain:

  • Calculation Factors in Criminal Cases:
    • Direct out-of-pocket losses to the victim.
    • Costs of repairs or replacements.
    • Lost wages due to injury or court proceedings.
    • Medical or counseling expenses.
  • Calculation Factors in Civil Cases:
    • Market value of benefits unjustly received.
    • Profits derived from a wrongful act.

Enforcement Methods: Restitution orders are legally binding and can be enforced through:

  • Wage garnishment or tax refund interception.
  • Property liens.
  • Probation conditions (non-payment can result in revocation).
  • Civil judgment enforcement if restitution remains unpaid.

Courts may also issue payment plans, but interest may accrue on unpaid balances. Restitution orders do not typically expire unless satisfied or formally dismissed by the court.

What Is the Difference Between Restitution and Compensation?

The difference between compensation and restitution lies in the way in which the financial award was calculated. Restitution is granted based on how much the defendant financially gained from the transgression. Compensation is granted based on how much the plaintiff financially lost. Sometimes a judge may grant the plaintiff with an option between compensation and restitution. Usually, the plaintiff will decide based on the higher award amount.

Restitution and Victim Rights

Victims have specific rights regarding restitution, which may include:

  • The right to be notified about restitution eligibility.
  • The right to submit evidence of financial harm.
  • The right to receive restitution as a priority over other court-ordered debts.

Some jurisdictions mandate that restitution be considered during plea bargains and sentencing. If a victim is not paid, they may be able to convert the restitution order into a civil judgment to pursue further collection options.

Restitution vs. Other Legal Remedies

While restitution is often confused with damages or fines, each has distinct purposes:

  • Restitution: Seeks to return the victim to their original state by transferring back what was lost or unjustly taken.
  • Compensatory Damages: Aim to make the victim financially whole, often exceeding the actual value lost to include pain, suffering, or emotional distress.
  • Punitive Damages: Designed to punish the wrongdoer rather than benefit the victim.
  • Fines: Paid to the state as a penalty for breaking the law, not to the victim.

Understanding these differences clarifies when restitution is the appropriate legal tool.

The Restitution Process in Criminal Cases

The restitution process begins after a guilty verdict or plea and may involve several steps:

  1. Victim Impact Statement or Loss Documentation: Victims may be asked to submit documentation of financial losses to the prosecutor or probation department.
  2. Court Order: At sentencing, the judge may order restitution based on submitted evidence.
  3. Collection and Disbursement:
    • Payments may be collected by the court, probation office, or a designated agency.
    • Funds are then distributed to victims.
  4. Ongoing Monitoring: Restitution compliance is monitored throughout probation or parole. In some states, unpaid restitution may be pursued even after incarceration or probation ends.

In federal cases, restitution is mandatory for certain crimes (e.g., fraud, child exploitation) under the Mandatory Victims Restitution Act (MVRA).

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What does restitution mean in legal terms? Restitution is a court-ordered remedy that requires a wrongdoer to restore or repay benefits unfairly gained or losses caused to another party.

2. Is restitution the same as a fine? No. Fines are penalties paid to the government, whereas restitution is compensation paid to the victim to cover financial losses.

3. Can restitution be modified or waived? In some cases, yes. Courts may modify restitution orders due to a change in circumstances, or in rare cases, they may be waived based on the defendant’s inability to pay.

4. How is restitution collected from a defendant? Collection methods may include wage garnishments, liens, tax refund interceptions, and court-supervised payment plans.

5. Is restitution taxable for the victim? Generally, restitution is not taxable if it simply reimburses actual losses. However, victims should consult a tax professional for specific advice.

If you need help with the legal definition of restitution, you can post your job on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.