Key Takeaways

  • A "Product-as-a-Service" (PaaS) model provides access to physical products through subscription or usage-based services, not ownership.
  • It merges tangible products with ongoing services and digital capabilities.
  • PaaS supports sustainability, recurring revenue, and stronger customer relationships.
  • The model is adaptable across industries, from transportation and tech to home appliances.
  • Legal considerations include contracts, liability, asset ownership, and data rights.

Is a service a product? There is something called Product-as-a-Service (PaaS), which combines physical products, companion software, and software to monitor the process. This allows for new offerings when a buyer does not own anything in the physical sense. The product is delivered as a virtual experience or service. Customers subscribe to the product and pay a monthly or annual fee, rather than a one-time purchase.

Understanding Products

Products are services and/or goods that are offered to the public and satisfy a need or want. The word product derives from the verb “produce,” and a product is generally defined as something produced by effort or labor, or the end result of a process or act. The thing to remember with products is these are physical items that can be delivered to a buyer and involve an ownership transfer between the seller and buyer.

In the retail industry, a product is merchandise. In the manufacturing industry, they purchase products like raw materials to create a final product that is offered for sale. Raw materials like agricultural products and metals are called commodities. In a project management setting, a product is derived from the project deliverables that make up the project objectives.

Products shouldn't be dated or stagnant. They are designed to meet the needs of a consumer, and buyers don't want to buy something stagnant or outdated. Often, a product can be a complex component or sophisticated software.

Services, Ideas, and Solutions

Services are non-material actions that provide a measurable change of state for the buyer, which is caused by the seller or provider. A service is something that is done for you, which can be paid once for a limited period, or you can continue to pay through subscriptions. Services aren't necessarily designed to quickly fix a problem, so marketing efforts should be geared towards establishing a relationship with the consumer.

You also have intellectual property ideas, that are creations with commercial value, but they are sold as an idea only rather than a finished product or service. This includes copyrighted works and items like business methods, industrial processes, patents, etc.

A solution can combine both products and services, and can even have specific packaging for customers and other businesses that offer solutions to whatever problems consumers have. An example might be retaining a public relations firm for a business solution. PR firms often bundle a variety of services including marketing, product design, copywriting, and more.

Tangible and Intangible Products

You can further classify a product based on whether it's tangible or intangible. Tangible goods are physical objects that can be touched. These include an electronic gadget, a building, or vehicle. Most products are tangible.

Intangible products are indirectly perceived, like a health insurance policy or software subscription. They can be classified as virtual digital goods, or VDG, that are located virtually on a computer's operating system and accessed through various file types like JPG. A VDG requires additional processing or needs to be transformed by a programmer. Their use may be restricted by license or digital transfer. There are also real digital goods, RDG, which can exist within a data program, but they are presentational elements that are separate from conventional file type.

Product-as-a-Service Examples

One of the most common examples of a Product-as-a-Service is vehicle leasing. This is an option offered by many car manufacturers wherein someone purchases the use of the vehicle, and maintenance work is included during the course of the lease. A similar version is the Zipcar model, where Zipcar purchases and maintains a vehicle, and people can drive it on a per-use basis. Uber is another example as it fuses the car and driver together to provide a service — the ride.

Key Features of Product-as-a-Service Models

Product-as-a-Service shifts the traditional sales model to an experience-based offering. The core features include:

  • Access Over Ownership: Customers pay for the use of a product rather than owning it outright.
  • Recurring Payments: Revenue is generated via subscription models or usage-based billing, promoting financial predictability.
  • Bundled Services: Maintenance, upgrades, support, and software updates are often included, enhancing value.
  • Usage Monitoring: Products are embedded with IoT or software capabilities that track usage, performance, and user behavior.
  • Product Lifecycle Management: Companies maintain ownership, enabling refurbishment, reuse, or recycling — supporting circular economy goals.

Industries Using Product-as-a-Service

The PaaS model is gaining traction across various industries:

  • Automotive: Tesla and BMW offer subscription or lease-based services with built-in maintenance.
  • Home Appliances: Companies like BSH Home Appliances provide washing machines on a pay-per-wash basis.
  • Technology & Electronics: Apple and HP deliver devices as part of managed service agreements.
  • Fashion: Some apparel brands offer clothing rental and reuse programs instead of outright sales.
  • Healthcare: Medical equipment providers lease diagnostic tools bundled with technical support and software.

Legal Considerations for Product-as-a-Service

The legal structure behind a product-as-a-service model requires careful planning to protect both providers and users:

  • Service Agreements: These define terms of use, responsibilities, and service scope.
  • Liability & Risk: Providers may retain liability for product defects or failures, especially in transportation or medical sectors.
  • Ownership Rights: Legal contracts should specify that the provider retains ownership of the physical product.
  • Data Usage & Privacy: With smart products collecting user data, providers must comply with privacy laws like GDPR or CCPA.
  • End-of-Life Management: Terms should outline responsibilities for product return, refurbishment, or recycling.

Challenges of Implementing PaaS Models

While the product-as-a-service approach offers benefits, businesses must overcome challenges:

  • Higher Initial Capital Outlay: Businesses must produce and retain ownership of assets.
  • Complex Logistics: Managing ongoing product distribution, maintenance, and returns adds operational complexity.
  • Customer Education: Some customers may prefer ownership and require education on the benefits of access models.
  • Tech Infrastructure: Reliable tracking, billing, and usage monitoring systems are essential.
  • Legal & Regulatory Hurdles: Adapting to laws around asset leasing, warranties, and digital rights management is necessary.

How to Transition to a Product-as-a-Service Model

Businesses looking to adopt a PaaS approach should consider these steps:

  1. Assess Market Demand: Ensure customers are open to non-ownership models.
  2. Redesign Offerings: Reconfigure product design to support repeated use, maintenance, and upgrades.
  3. Develop Subscription Plans: Create pricing structures based on usage or time.
  4. Build Legal Frameworks: Draft clear contracts and data policies aligned with PaaS operations.
  5. Implement Technology Solutions: Deploy software for billing, usage tracking, and customer engagement.
  6. Train Sales & Support Teams: Ensure teams understand the value proposition and can handle ongoing customer relationships.

Advantages of Product-as-a-Service

There are several advantages of a Product-as-a-Service:

  • Allows producers to create recurring revenue
  • Builds long-term relationships with purchasers
  • Sellers can bundle both internal and external services — an example is a seller adding roadside assistance or a maintenance plan on a vehicle lease
  • Can increase the market size for sellers

Product-as-a-Service results in sellers seeing decreased initial sales, which can result in short-term revenue losses. However, statistical reports indicate that in most cases, sellers who move from physical sales to recurring services see more profitable, stable, and larger revenue streams over a one-time purchase.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is the product-as-a-service model?
    It's a business model where customers access a product through a subscription or usage-based plan instead of buying it outright.
  2. How is product-as-a-service different from traditional sales?
    Traditional sales transfer ownership, while PaaS provides access. Services like maintenance or upgrades are bundled into the offering.
  3. What types of businesses can benefit from PaaS?
    Industries including automotive, consumer electronics, medical devices, and home appliances are well-suited for PaaS.
  4. What are the legal implications of using PaaS?
    Legal issues include defining ownership, liability for use, data protection, and service level terms.
  5. How does product-as-a-service support sustainability?
    By extending product life cycles and promoting reuse, PaaS reduces waste and supports the circular economy.

If you need help with is a service a product, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel only accepts the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.