Key Takeaways

  • Manufacturing defects occur when a product departs from its intended design during the production process due to poor materials, human error, or assembly mistakes.
  • These defects differ from design defects and marketing defects because they are unintended and typically affect only some units in a product line.
  • Strict liability often applies to manufacturing defects, meaning manufacturers can be held liable even without proof of negligence.
  • To prove a manufacturing defect, the consumer must show that the product was defective when it left the manufacturer and that the defect caused their injury.
  • Manufacturers can defend against claims using strategies like modification defense or assumption of risk defense.

What Is a Manufacturing Defect?

First, know that there are three types of product defects:

  1. Marketing defects. These are based on the way a product was sold. The product in question wasn't necessarily defective, but the seller and/or producer mislead the consumer.
  2. Design defects. These are intentional, which means that the flaw is a key part of the product's design. However, any injuries caused by the defect may not be intentional.
  3. Manufacturing defects. Unlike a design defect, a manufacturing defect is not intended.

There are two common causes of manufacturing defects. For one thing, if the raw materials used to make something are of poor quality, the final product will be, too. The second cause is human error. If the person who put the product together was careless, relatively unskilled, or inexperienced, the product will likely be flawed.

If a manufacturing defect results in injury, the company that made the product can be liable for civil damages. While not all defective products are dangerous, ineffective products could cause manufacturers to lose money anyway. For example, a dull electric knife has no functional purpose, so the consumers who bought that product might request a refund.

Common Causes of Manufacturing Defects

Manufacturing defects typically occur due to errors or irregularities during the production process, rather than issues with the product’s design itself. Common causes include:

  • Use of substandard or incorrect raw materials: Poor-quality materials may compromise the integrity of the final product.
  • Assembly line errors: Mistakes made during automated or manual assembly can result in defective items.
  • Inadequate quality control procedures: Failure to detect flaws during inspections may allow defective products to reach consumers.
  • Improper maintenance of equipment: Malfunctioning machinery can lead to inconsistencies in product manufacturing.
  • Human error: Mistakes by untrained or careless workers may result in defective goods.

These defects often affect only a portion of the products produced, making them distinct from design defects, which are present in every product due to flawed design plans.

How to Tell If a Product Has a Manufacturing Defect?

If you have a defective product, you can figure out whether the product in your possession has a manufacturing defect by determining if the product's flaws would exist if the product were properly put together. If a product has a design defect, it should exist in every other product made according to the plans for the product. Since a manufacturing defect is unplanned or accidental, there may be only a small percentage of products with similar defects. This will be important in a product liability case.

Examples of Manufacturing Defects

Examples of manufacturing defects can help clarify how these defects arise in real-world scenarios. Some common examples include:

  • A batch of pharmaceutical drugs contaminated during production.
  • A bicycle with a cracked frame due to improper welding.
  • A car with faulty brakes because of missing bolts during assembly.
  • A children’s toy with loose parts that pose a choking hazard.
  • An electrical appliance with a frayed power cord due to poor-quality insulation.

These examples illustrate how defects can make products unsafe or non-functional, even when the design itself is sound.

How Does Someone Report a Defective Product?

If you have an unsafe product in your possession, you can contact the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) or other U.S. agencies whose responsibilities include recalling defective products that fall into certain categories. You can file a report if you and someone you know was injured by a product, especially if that product was used as intended. If there are enough reports filed about a certain product, the agency you contact will likely launch an investigation.

When a product is recalled:

  • The products with manufacturing defects are usually recalled in batches.
  • The agency alerts the public. For example, the CPSC advises consumers about the steps they need to take if they have a defective product.
  • People should stop using the products in question, so they can avoid injury.

Note that the CPSC and other agencies don't investigate all claims; manufacturers can sometimes review claims, and the agencies themselves are not responsible for forming recall plans.

Legal Theories Behind Manufacturing Defect Claims

In manufacturing defect cases, plaintiffs typically rely on one of several legal theories to establish liability:

  • Strict Liability: The manufacturer can be held responsible for defects regardless of whether they were negligent.
  • Negligence: The plaintiff must show that the manufacturer failed to exercise reasonable care during production.
  • Breach of Warranty: This claim asserts that the product failed to meet the express or implied warranties provided by the seller or manufacturer.

Strict liability is the most common theory in manufacturing defect cases because it focuses on the defect itself rather than the manufacturer’s conduct.

How Does a Consumer Prove that a Product Has a Manufacturing Defect?

When someone sues a company for an injury caused by a consumer product, the plaintiff will need to show how the product was involved in their injury. It's quite hard to prove that a product has a manufacturing defect. Since the plaintiff is bringing the manufacturing defect case, the plaintiff has the burden of proof.

One legal doctrine that can help the plaintiff win a case is the malfunction doctrine. When presenting the case, the plaintiff must examine the manufacturer's design or marketing standards and connect it to the flaw in the product. When this principle is used in a case, the court must find that the circumstances of the incident that caused the injury point to a defective product. The plaintiff will have to eliminate other possibilities by producing evidence to that effect, even if the product is damaged or destroyed.

How Can Manufacturers Fight a Product Liability Case?

The manufacturer has two primary options to fight the product liability lawsuit in court: the modification defense or the assumption of risk defense. When the defendant uses the modification defense, the manufacturer must prove that the product was changed after it was purchased or passed on to a distributor. When the defendant uses the assumption of risk defense, the manufacturer must prove that the plaintiff was negligent or knew of the danger of engaging in an activity but proceeded anyway.

Preventing Manufacturing Defects: Best Practices for Manufacturers

Manufacturers can reduce the risk of product liability claims by implementing strong preventive measures. Effective strategies include:

  • Robust quality control systems: Regular testing and inspection at multiple stages of the production process.
  • Supplier audits: Ensuring that raw materials meet required safety and quality standards.
  • Employee training: Educating workers on proper procedures and safety protocols.
  • Routine equipment maintenance: Keeping machinery in optimal working condition to prevent errors.
  • Documentation and traceability: Maintaining detailed records of production batches for easier recall management if necessary.

By focusing on prevention, manufacturers can protect both consumers and their business interests.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What qualifies as a manufacturing defect?
    A manufacturing defect occurs when a product deviates from its intended design during the production process, making it unsafe or non-functional.
  2. How is a manufacturing defect different from a design defect?
    A design defect affects all products made according to a flawed design, while a manufacturing defect typically impacts only some units due to mistakes during production.
  3. Can I sue for a manufacturing defect if I wasn’t injured?
    In most cases, product liability claims require proof of injury or damage caused by the defect. However, certain warranty claims may still apply.
  4. What should I do if I suspect a product has a manufacturing defect?
    Stop using the product immediately, report it to the appropriate regulatory agency like the CPSC, and consult with an attorney to understand your legal options.
  5. Are manufacturers always liable for manufacturing defects?
    Manufacturers are often held strictly liable for manufacturing defects, but they may avoid liability if they can prove defenses like product modification or consumer misuse.

If you need help with a manufacturing defect case, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.