Key Takeaways

  • Firm offer contract law refers to offers that are definite, binding, and cannot be revoked for a certain period, typically under UCC Section 2-205.
  • To qualify, the offer must be in writing, signed by the offeror, and explicitly state that it will remain open.
  • The maximum irrevocability period under the UCC is three months, unless additional consideration is provided.
  • A firm offer is different from an option contract, which requires consideration (payment or value) to keep the offer open longer than three months.
  • The offeror is the “master of the offer” and sets the terms of acceptance, but courts often interpret language based on the reasonable understanding of the offeree.
  • Risks of firm offers include market shifts that make the deal unfavorable; businesses must carefully assess pricing and time commitments.
  • A valid contract also requires the basic elements of an offer: intent, clear terms, and communication to the offeree.

Firm offer contract law is important to know before you embark on any contract, whether for business or personal reasons. A firm offer is a term commonly used in the proposal is definite and binding when the contract is entered into. If the party accepts the firm offer, then the contract becomes legally binding. Once agreed to, the offer cannot be withdrawn.

A firm offer is also used in an agreement where the offeror wishes to avoid protracted or competing negotiations with the same or another party.

Section 2-205

Firm offers often fall under the guideline of the UCC offer rule under section 2-205. Under these rules, a firm offer is considered an offer that is made by a merchant to sell either goods or services in a signed document ensuring that the deal is non-revocable and may have a period of irrevocability that lasts no more than three months.

When the merchant presents the offer in writing, that offer will be open for a set and reasonable period of time. The contract will become a binding agreement if the offeree ends up accepting the goods or services. The term reasonable amount of time will largely depend on each party's circumstances.

The section 2-205 of the UCC code:

  • Deals with the offer made in writing. To be valid, the offer must be signed, and the purpose of drafting it was to make an irrevocable offer.
  • Imposes a limit of three months for the offer to be irrevocable. For example, if an offer is irrevocable up to a year, this section would in effect make it only last for six months. To extend this section, there must be a consideration filed with the offer.
  • Requires that the offer state that the assurances will be held open which means they will not be revoked for a period of time.

It is essential that your language be specific and ambiguous so that it can satisfy the requirements of Section 2-205, specifically the assurance requirement. Such language as "this offer is firm and will remain open for three months," not only indicates the timeframe in which the contract in non-revocable but also that the offer is firm and the offerer does not plan to revoke it ahead of time. Though there is no one phrase that can make the section legal and all language should be carefully looked at to make sure it provides the right implications.

A court will refer to the section of the offer known as assurances to interpret the language and whether or not the offeree made an intention to revoke. In many American court jurisdictions, they will take the approach of interpreting how the other party might have interpreted the language of the contract. They will also consider all of the offerees circumstances and how they might have thought certain language related to them.

An example would be the fact that a company that supplies materials or buys materials could put a time limit on any offer that they make. In this case, the UCC provision would only be used to fill in the blanks if no time frame was set.

There are problems holding any type of offer open for more than a three-month period. If the offer stays open for more than three months, it must be supported by a consideration which means there must be a formal agreement of some type. When the offer is considered a firm offer, it has only gone one way and has not yet been accepted. For an offer to remain open for more than three months an agreement would have to be made with a promise of payment; the consideration. In this instance, the agreement would be referred to as an option contract which means the offeror is being paid to keep the offer open for an extended period.

Firm Offer vs. Option Contract

Although both firm offers and option contracts prevent revocation, they are legally distinct:

  • Firm Offer: Requires no consideration, but cannot last beyond three months unless additional value is provided.
  • Option Contract: Supported by consideration (such as a payment to hold the offer), and can extend beyond three months.

For example, if a supplier offers to sell 1,000 units at a fixed price for four months, the first three months may be protected under UCC 2-205. To enforce the fourth month, the buyer must provide consideration, effectively turning it into an option contract.

Requirements for a Valid Firm Offer

To be enforceable under firm offer contract law, certain conditions must be met:

  • Made by a merchant: Only merchants (those regularly dealing in the goods at issue) can create a firm offer under UCC 2-205.
  • In writing and signed: Oral promises generally do not qualify; the offer must be documented and signed by the offeror.
  • Definite assurance: The writing must clearly state that the offer will remain open and cannot be revoked.
  • Time limits: The UCC limits irrevocability to a maximum of three months unless consideration is given to extend the period.

This ensures fairness while balancing the risks that circumstances may change, making the deal impractical or unprofitable.

Offeror as Master of the Offer

When a contract is created, it is the offeror who will determine the means of acceptance. This can include such things as how the offer can be accepted and how payment can be received. This essentially means that the offeror has the power to determine what is offered to the offeree and how.

Risks and Practical Considerations of Firm Offers

While firm offers provide stability, they also carry risks:

  • Market volatility: If the price of goods increases, the seller may be stuck with an unfavorable deal.
  • Supply issues: Unexpected shortages can make it difficult for merchants to fulfill firm offers.
  • Overcommitment: Businesses should avoid promising firm offers beyond their capacity, as failure to deliver could lead to breach of contract claims.

For this reason, firms often include specific language clarifying the duration of the offer and conditions under which it remains binding.

Elements of a Valid Offer in Contract Law

Firm offer contract law still relies on the general principles of offer and acceptance. For an offer to be valid:

  1. Intent: The offeror must show intent to be legally bound if the offer is accepted. Casual negotiations or vague statements do not qualify.
  2. Definiteness: The offer must include essential terms—such as subject matter, price, and quantity—so a court can enforce it.
  3. Communication: The offer must be communicated to the offeree, who then gains the power to accept.

A counteroffer, rejection, or lapse of time will terminate the original offer. If accepted, the agreement becomes binding and enforceable.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is a firm offer in contract law?
    A firm offer is a written, signed offer by a merchant stating it will remain open for a set period, and under UCC rules, it cannot be revoked for up to three months.
  2. How does a firm offer differ from an option contract?
    A firm offer does not require consideration but is limited to three months. An option contract requires consideration and can extend longer.
  3. Can a non-merchant make a firm offer?
    No. Only merchants—those who regularly deal in the type of goods involved—can make enforceable firm offers under UCC Section 2-205.
  4. What happens if market conditions change during a firm offer?
    The offer remains binding, even if it becomes unfavorable for the offeror. Merchants must assess risks before making firm offers.
  5. How can businesses protect themselves when making firm offers?
    They should specify time limits, include clear language about irrevocability, and consider using option contracts when longer periods are needed.

If you need help with firm offer contract law, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.