Key Takeaways:

  • Duress in contract law occurs when one party is forced into an agreement through threats, coercion, or undue influence.
  • Physical, economic, and psychological duress can all be grounds for invalidating a contract.
  • Proving duress requires demonstrating wrongful pressure, lack of genuine consent, and no reasonable alternative.
  • Economic duress is increasingly recognized in modern contract disputes, particularly in business settings.
  • Legal remedies for duress include rescission of the contract and damages.
  • Avoiding duress involves ensuring contracts are negotiated freely, with adequate time for review and legal consultation.
  • Courts consider multiple factors when evaluating duress, including the victim’s ability to resist and the immediacy of the threat.

Duress in contract law is focused on the concept of undue influence. This means the use of false imprisonment, threats, force, psychological pressure, or coercion to influence someone to act in a way that is not in their best interest or to act in a manner they do not wish to act.

Overview of Duress in Contract Law

Compelling someone to act in a manner against their better judgment or to do something they don't want to do is against the law. In the eyes of the law, any agreement made by a person under duress is invalid.

When duress is being determined, it is not based on the pressure exerted on the person but by their state of mind. In a contract law court proceeding, in order for duress to exist, there must be an illegal or wrongful act. When a claim of duress is filed, it is because a party wants to prove that their agreement to a contract wasn't made in good faith, making the essential requirements necessary to form a contract unfulfilled. If a party is claiming duress because another party is threatening to file suit for more money, that would be an invalid reason because filing suit is a legal action.

A party fearing for their safety can file duress. An example would be threatening to harm someone's family if they refused to sign a contract. If a wrongful or illegal threatened act takes place, that qualifies as duress.

Types of Duress Recognized in Contract Law

There are several forms of duress that can render a contract invalid:

  • Physical Duress: Involves threats of physical harm or unlawful restraint to force someone into an agreement. This is one of the clearest forms of duress, making a contract voidable.
  • Economic Duress: Occurs when one party exerts unlawful financial pressure, such as threats to terminate a critical business relationship unless unfavorable contract terms are accepted.
  • Psychological Duress: More subtle than physical coercion, this includes extreme psychological pressure or manipulation that deprives an individual of free will.
  • Threat of Legal Action: While filing a lawsuit is a lawful act, threatening frivolous or bad-faith legal actions to force someone into a contract may constitute duress.

Duress and Consideration

Consideration is what is referred to when bargaining and exchanging takes place regarding goods and services. It is vital, and without it, a contract does not exist. When one party benefits but the other only receives what was initially promised, this is duress.

Checking if consideration was given is a quick way to determine if there is a claim for duress. When a promise is made, the promisor is legally bound. This does not constitute consideration. If both parties benefit, then consideration has been established and there is no claim for duress.

There are three consideration types:

  • Executory.
  • Executed.
  • Past consideration.

In contract law, consideration need only be sufficient versus adequate. In this context, adequate is the value of the consideration in terms of the economic value of the transaction. This does not mean, however, that the validity of the consideration is affected. Legally, the only requirement is that the consideration has a minimum economic value.

How Courts Evaluate Economic Duress

Economic duress is a growing area of concern in contract law, especially in commercial settings. Courts generally evaluate economic duress based on:

  1. Existence of an Illegitimate Threat – The pressure exerted must go beyond aggressive business negotiations and involve unethical or unlawful behavior.
  2. Lack of Alternative Options – The affected party must demonstrate that they had no reasonable choice but to accept the unfair contract terms.
  3. Protest or Objection – If the victim immediately protested or attempted to renegotiate the terms, it strengthens their claim of economic duress.
  4. Unjust Enrichment – If one party unfairly benefits at the expense of the other due to economic duress, courts may intervene.

Contracts Entered Under Duress

Duress to an Individual

When an individual enters into a contract because of threats to that person physically, then the contract may be set aside as long as the threat of physical violence was the reason the person entered into the contract. In this case, there is no need to establish that the party would not have entered into the contract had there been no physical threat.

Duress to Goods

Claiming duress due to goods is not recognized as a valid reason to set a contract aside.

Economic Duress

Economic duress is a common claim in disputes of commercial contracts. 

Proving Duress

Proving duress in a contract requires three things be provided:

  1. There must be an existing continuous contract between the defendant and the plaintiff.
  2. The defendant has threatened to end the preexisting contract.
  3. The plaintiff under duress accepts and enters into the contract because of the threat.

Courts also look at other factors when determining if one party is exerting undue pressure on the other party. These factors include:

  • The timeframe in place for each party regarding the completion of contract performance.
  • The level of bargaining power each party had when the agreement was made.
  • The mental state of each party at the time the agreement was made.
  • Determining if each party felt the agreement was fair when it was made.
  • If any contract modification were in place when the contract was agreed to.
  • Whether other legal remedies provide reasonable solutions to the situation.

Examples of Duress in Real-World Contract Disputes

Real-world examples help illustrate how courts handle duress claims:

  • Business Coercion: A small supplier depends on a major retailer for revenue. The retailer demands last-minute price reductions, knowing the supplier has no viable alternative. If the supplier agrees out of necessity, this could be economic duress.
  • Forced Employment Contracts: An employee is threatened with immediate termination unless they sign a non-compete clause with unreasonable restrictions. Courts may view this as an improper use of leverage.
  • Family Influence in Estate Planning: A relative pressures an elderly family member into signing a will that disproportionately benefits them. If undue influence is proven, the contract may be invalid.
  • Threats to Reputation: A businessperson is coerced into signing a contract under the threat of false damaging media exposure. If the claim is credible and affects their decision, it could be a case of duress.

Related Legal Terms

  • Civil lawsuit: When one person claims they've suffered a loss due to another person's actions.
  • Mutual assent: A contract between two agreeing parties.
  • A preponderance of evidence: When evidence by one party is more convincing than that of the other party.

Legal Remedies for Contracts Signed Under Duress

When a court determines a contract was signed under duress, the following legal remedies may apply:

  • Rescission of the Contract: The contract may be declared void, returning both parties to their original positions before the agreement.
  • Restitution: If a party suffered financial losses due to duress, the court may order reimbursement for damages incurred.
  • Injunctions: A court may prevent further enforcement of a contract if ongoing duress is found.
  • Reformation: Instead of nullifying the contract entirely, courts may modify its terms to remove elements influenced by duress.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. How do I prove duress in a contract dispute?

To prove duress, you must demonstrate that the other party exerted wrongful pressure, you had no reasonable alternative but to agree, and you objected to the contract under pressure.

2. What is the difference between duress and undue influence?

Duress involves threats or coercion, often through force or financial pressure. Undue influence, on the other hand, refers to manipulation or abuse of a relationship of trust to gain an unfair advantage.

3. Can a contract be partially enforced if duress is proven?

Sometimes. Courts may modify a contract rather than void it entirely if only specific clauses were signed under duress.

4. Is economic duress difficult to prove in court?

Yes, because it requires showing that the pressure applied was illegitimate and that the affected party had no other reasonable options. A strong legal argument often depends on evidence like financial records, communications, and witness testimony.

5. Can I sue for damages if I signed a contract under duress?

Yes. In addition to rescinding the contract, courts may award damages if you suffered financial losses as a direct result of the duress.

If you need help with duress in contract law, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.