Key Takeaways:

  • Forcing someone to sign a contract is illegal and constitutes duress, rendering the contract invalid.
  • Duress can occur through physical, economic, or psychological pressure, making the contract unenforceable.
  • Economic duress includes coercion through financial threats, while physical duress involves direct threats of harm.
  • A contract signed under duress is voidable, meaning the victim can seek legal remedies to have it nullified.
  • Proof of duress requires evidence, such as threats, lack of reasonable alternatives, and the contract's unfair terms.
  • Legal action, mediation, and contract rescission are possible remedies if a contract was signed under duress.
  • Certain business transactions may involve undue influence, which, while different from duress, can also invalidate contracts.
  • Writing 'signed under duress' may not always protect you, but legal consultation can help you determine your rights.
  • Seek legal help immediately if you feel you’ve been coerced into signing an agreement.

Forcing someone to sign a contract can cause duress from the pressure and will render the contract invalid.

What is Duress?

Duress is a state of mind that can be caused by physical threats, threats on property, and the pressures of the economy. It doesn't matter where the pressure is coming from; if someone signed a contract while in this state of mind, the contract would be seen as invalid.

When Does Duress Occur in Contracts?

If a person feels they have been forced to enter an agreement, they can use duress as a defense. If you were held at gunpoint and forced to sign an agreement, this would be considered duress. This can make the contract invalid.

Another good example of duress is if someone kept a basic human need, like food or water, away from you if you didn't sign the agreement. Blackmail can cause duress as well. However, there are times where duress can't be clearly found.

By hiring an experienced lawyer, you can find out if you have entered an agreement under duress.

Legal Consequences of Signing a Contract Under Duress

Signing a contract under duress has serious legal implications. A contract is only legally binding when both parties voluntarily agree to its terms. When coercion is involved, courts may deem the contract voidable. This means:

  • The victim of duress can challenge the contract’s validity in court.
  • If duress is proven, the court may order the contract to be rescinded (canceled).
  • In some cases, the party responsible for coercion may face civil penalties or even criminal charges, especially if threats of violence or blackmail were involved.
  • Business transactions affected by duress can lead to lawsuits for unfair dealings, particularly in cases of economic coercion.

If you suspect you signed a contract under duress, seek immediate legal guidance to understand your rights and possible courses of action.

Forms of Duress in Contracts Law

In contract law, there are two different forms of duress:

  • Economic Duress. This occurs in commercial contract issues. One party may force another to enter a contract by using the pressures of the economy. However, if the threats involved something like legal action or a typical business deal, it may not be considered duress. The threat must also come from any party signing the original contract.
  • Physical Duress. This occurs when someone is threatened with physical harm, either directly or to their loved ones. If someone is forced to enter the agreement but doesn't plan on following the terms, it will be considered invalid.

Psychological and Emotional Duress in Contracts

While contract law traditionally focuses on physical and economic duress, psychological and emotional pressure can also play a significant role in coercion. Examples of psychological duress include:

  • Manipulation or gaslighting to make the signer believe they have no other choice.
  • Threats of public humiliation or exposure of personal secrets unless the contract is signed.
  • Excessive pressure from authority figures, such as an employer threatening job loss if an employee refuses to sign an agreement.
  • Unreasonable time constraints that prevent a person from properly reviewing the contract.

Courts consider whether a reasonable person in the same situation would feel compelled to sign the contract. If the pressure exerted is deemed excessive and unfair, the contract may be invalidated.

Relevance of Consideration with Duress

Bargaining and exchanging of goods and services is called consideration. Without it, there can be no contract. Checking if there was proper consideration can help check for duress. If it occurred, only one party would get the benefit.

Consideration doesn't include a promise already mentioned in the contract. It may, however, exist if both parties can benefit from the contract. For example, B agrees to do A's chores for a week for $200. However, B wants $300 instead, so A agrees if B does A's laundry as well. This would make for a valid agreement with consideration.

How Can Duress be Proven?

Duress can be proven if the party shows there was an existing contract between the parties, one party threatened to end the contract, and the other party accepted the agreement due to duress. It can be difficult to see if duress applies to a situation.

Other factors the court may look into include:

  • Amount of time given to complete the contract terms.
  • Bargaining power each side had when contract was created.
  • Mental state of each party when contract was created.
  • If the parties believed the contract was fair when first created.
  • If the contract could have been modified with alternatives when first created.
  • If the parties could have solved the problem through other legal solutions.

Difference Between Duress and Undue Influence

While duress and undue influence both involve coercion, they are legally distinct:

  • Duress involves force, threats, or pressure that removes free will.
  • Undue influence occurs when a party in a position of power (such as a guardian, employer, or family member) exerts excessive persuasion, taking advantage of the weaker party’s dependency or trust.
  • Examples of undue influence include an elderly person being pressured by a caregiver to sign over property or an employer convincing an employee to accept unfair contract terms under threat of job loss.

Contracts signed due to undue influence may be challenged in court, but the burden of proof typically requires showing a power imbalance and an unfair advantage taken by the stronger party.

Is the Contract Valid If You are Forced to Sign It?

A contract is not valid is someone forces you to sign it. There are many times where an agreement will be considered invalid due to duress. Some include threats towards your family or business, or if there are no alternatives offered to you about the agreement.

To prove the duress, the circumstances of the contract will be investigated, such as the parties' relationship. It's also possible that writing “under duress” could make the contract voidable. However, this may not hold up in court.

Steps to Take If You Have Signed a Contract Under Duress

If you suspect you signed a contract under duress, you have legal options to challenge its validity:

  1. Gather Evidence – Collect any documents, emails, messages, or recordings that show coercion.
  2. Consult a Lawyer – An experienced contract attorney can evaluate your case and advise on next steps.
  3. File a Legal Claim – If necessary, a court can review the circumstances of the contract signing and declare it void.
  4. Explore Alternative Dispute Resolution – In some cases, mediation or arbitration can help resolve disputes without litigation.
  5. Document the Duress – If you are forced to sign a contract but cannot refuse at the moment, writing “signed under duress” on the document may help establish your claim later. However, courts may still require further proof.

Understanding your legal rights is crucial in protecting yourself from unfair agreements. Seeking legal counsel can help you navigate your options and potentially have the contract rescinded.

Is it Acceptable to Force Someone to Sign a Contract That is Good for Them?

No, it is not acceptable to do so. You can try to persuade or influence someone into signing a contract, but the decision must ultimately be theirs.

What to Do if You Enter into a Contract Under Duress?

You should read and be able to understand the contract before signing the document. If you feel forced to sign the document, you should seek help from a lawyer who is familiar with contract laws.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is it illegal to force someone to sign a contract?

Yes. A contract signed under duress is not legally enforceable. Coercion, threats, or undue pressure can make a contract voidable in court.

2. What are signs that a contract was signed under duress?

Signs include threats of harm, economic pressure, manipulation, lack of reasonable alternatives, and significant power imbalances between the parties.

3. Can economic pressure be considered duress?

Yes. Economic duress occurs when a party is forced into a contract due to severe financial threats, such as being unfairly pressured to agree to avoid financial ruin.

4. How can I prove duress in court?

You need evidence such as written threats, recorded conversations, witness statements, or proof of financial coercion to demonstrate you had no reasonable alternative.

5. What should I do if I was forced to sign a contract?

Seek legal advice immediately. A lawyer can help you gather evidence, challenge the contract, and explore legal remedies such as rescission or compensation.

If you need help with signing a contract under duress, you can post your job on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.