Key Takeaways

  • A mutual benefit corporation is a California nonprofit formed to benefit its members rather than the public, unlike public benefit or religious nonprofits.
  • Common examples include homeowners’ associations, chambers of commerce, trade groups, and professional associations.
  • Unlike charitable nonprofits, donations to a mutual benefit corporation are not tax-deductible, and fundraising is typically limited to members.
  • Upon dissolution, assets may be distributed to members after debts are paid, unlike public benefit or religious nonprofits which must transfer assets to another charity.
  • Filing requires Articles of Incorporation (Form ARTS-MU) with the California Secretary of State, along with bylaws, an EIN, and tax registrations.
  • Mutual benefit corporations can engage in political or lobbying activities with fewer restrictions than 501(c)(3) public charities.

What is a mutual benefit corporation California? A mutual benefit corporation is an organization created for the benefit of a group whose tax-exempt status under IRS rules differs from that of 501(c)(3). A variety of entities fall under the mutual corporation category in California.

California Nonprofit Organizations

A nonprofit organization is generally exempt from paying federal or state taxes but must fulfill certain conditions. A charitable organization is a nonprofit whose earnings from donations are considered charitable donations for tax purposes. To create a California nonprofit tax-exempt corporation, you must apply for and register nonprofit articles of incorporation with the California Secretary of State. The following types of California organizations qualify for nonprofit status:

  • Nonprofit corporations.
  • Unincorporated associations.
  • Charitable trusts.

One of the benefits of an unincorporated association is that it does not require creating an entity. However, each member of the association has personal liability for the organization's misdeeds and obligations. Additionally, laws regarding unincorporated associations aren't clear. The only benefits of charitable trusts are to hold, manage, or distribute property.

Similarities Among California Nonprofit Corporations

Despite their differences, all three types of nonprofit corporations in California—mutual benefit, public benefit, and religious—share several features. Each can apply for tax-exempt status to avoid corporate income tax, franchise tax, and certain state taxes. They are also subject to similar formation rules, including the need to file articles of incorporation, adopt bylaws, and appoint a board of directors. While nonprofits can generate revenue, those funds must be used for the organization’s purposes, not distributed to owners or shareholders.

Types of Nonprofit Corporations

There are three primary types of nonprofit corporations in California based on their activities:

  1. California nonprofit public benefit corporation.
  2. California nonprofit religious corporation.
  3. California nonprofit mutual benefit corporation.

California Nonprofit Mutual Benefit Corporation

Examples of California nonprofit mutual benefit corporations include community associations registered under 501(c)(4) and business chambers of commerce registered under 501(c)(6). As long as a mutual benefit corporation is operational and not dissolved, its members cannot withdraw the organization's assets. The requirements of common mutual benefit corporations are different. Common mutual benefit corporations must:

  • State the exact name of the corporation.
  • Provide a general purpose statement according to the guidelines in California Corporations Code Section 7130.
  • Include the name and physical address of a California resident who will serve as the corporation's resident agent.

Mutual benefit corporations do not qualify for charitable status.

How Mutual Benefit Corporations Differ From Other Nonprofits

Mutual benefit corporations differ from other nonprofit types in three major ways:

  • Mission: Their primary purpose is to benefit members, not the general public. For example, a professional trade association may provide continuing education and networking opportunities to its members, whereas a public benefit nonprofit would focus on services for the community at large.
  • Fundraising: Contributions to mutual benefit corporations are generally not tax-deductible, which can make fundraising more difficult than for charitable organizations. Donations and grants often favor public benefit nonprofits since donors can receive tax incentives.
  • Dissolution: Upon dissolution, mutual benefit corporations may distribute remaining assets to members after debts are settled. By contrast, public benefit and religious corporations must transfer assets to another tax-exempt charitable organization.

How to File Articles of Incorporation With the California Secretary of State

There are several methods of filing your articles of incorporation with the California Secretary of State, including:

  • Via mail, which takes the longest time to process.
  • Filing in person at the window of the Los Angeles or San Francisco offices of the California Secretary of State. This method is faster than mail.
  • Filing at the Sacramento window of the secretary of state is the fastest option, especially if you pay an expedited fee.

Key Steps to Form a Mutual Benefit Corporation

In addition to filing Articles of Incorporation (Form ARTS-MU), the process of creating a mutual benefit corporation generally includes:

  1. Appointing a Board of Directors – California requires at least one director to serve on the board.
  2. Choosing a Corporate Name – The name must comply with California’s corporate naming rules and be distinguishable from other entities.
  3. Drafting Bylaws – These serve as the corporation’s internal operating rules.
  4. Obtaining an EIN – An Employer Identification Number is required for tax and banking purposes.
  5. Registering with Tax Agencies – Mutual benefit corporations may apply for federal tax exemption using IRS Form 1024, and then apply with the California Franchise Tax Board for state-level exemptions.
  6. Licenses and Permits – Depending on activities, the corporation may also need local business licenses or permits.

Templates for Articles of Incorporation are available from the California Secretary of State or registered agent service providers.

California Nonprofit Public Benefit Corporation

A public benefit corporation is created for the benefit of the public under 501(c)(3). California nonprofit corporations in this category include private foundations and charitable organizations. These types of nonprofits can only engage in activities that serve public or charitable causes. To qualify for tax-exempt status, public benefit corporations must:

  • State the exact name of the corporation.
  • Prohibit the corporation managers or directors from any form of benefits. They can receive payment for services rendered to the organization.
  • Restrict the corporation's purpose to charitable, educational, literary, scientific, amateur sports competition, public safety testing, or prevention of cruelty to animals or children.
  • Upon dissolution, donate its assets to another tax-exempt organization.
  • Not try to influence elections or legislation.
  • Provide the name and physical address in California of a resident agent who is a California resident.

The major difference between a public benefits corporation and the other two nonprofit corporations is that it faces a higher level of government regulation and supervision.

California Nonprofit Religious Corporation

To qualify as a California nonprofit religious corporation, an organization must:

  • Have a purely religious purpose.
  • Not distribute its assets to members.
  • Perform charitable activities.

California nonprofit religious corporations are also qualified for tax-exempt status under IRS 501(c)(3). The filing requirements for IRS tax-exempt status for this organization are similar to those for California nonprofit public benefit corporations, but this organization will only engage in religious activities. See the California Corporations Code Section 9130 for required general purpose statement guidelines.

Membership and Governance in Mutual Benefit Corporations

Most mutual benefit corporations operate as membership nonprofits, where members have the right to vote on key matters such as electing directors, amending bylaws, or dissolving the organization. Others operate as nonmembership nonprofits, leaving governance to the board of directors. Some organizations, such as public radio groups, may call supporters “members” but these supporters often lack voting rights—highlighting the distinction between true membership corporations and informal supporter programs.

Political and Lobbying Activities

Unlike public benefit corporations, which face strict limitations under IRS 501(c)(3) rules, mutual benefit corporations often have more freedom to engage in lobbying or political advocacy. This flexibility makes them a common choice for trade associations or business leagues seeking to influence legislation on behalf of their members. However, the scope of permissible activity depends on the organization’s specific tax-exempt classification (for example, 501(c)(4) vs. 501(c)(6)).

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is a mutual benefit corporation in California?
    It is a nonprofit formed to serve the interests of its members, such as a trade association or homeowners’ association, rather than the public.
  2. Are donations to a mutual benefit corporation tax-deductible?
    No. Contributions to mutual benefit corporations are not tax-deductible for donors, unlike those to 501(c)(3) public charities.
  3. Who controls a mutual benefit corporation?
    Typically, members have voting rights to elect directors and influence major decisions. In nonmembership structures, the board of directors controls governance.
  4. Can a mutual benefit corporation lobby or engage in politics?
    Yes. These corporations often have more leeway to lobby or advocate for legislation, especially if organized under 501(c)(4) or 501(c)(6).
  5. What happens to assets if a mutual benefit corporation dissolves?
    After debts are paid, the remaining assets may be distributed to members, unlike public benefit corporations, which must transfer assets to another nonprofit.

If you need more information about what is a mutual benefit corporation, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.