Key Takeaways

  • A California Nonprofit Mutual Benefit Corporation is designed for member benefit rather than the general public.
  • These corporations do not qualify for 501(c)(3) tax exemption but may be eligible under 501(c)(6), 501(c)(7), 501(c)(8), or 501(c)(10).
  • Unlike public benefit nonprofits, mutual benefit corporations can distribute remaining assets to members upon dissolution.
  • They must adhere to specific governance structures, including a board of directors and member voting rights.
  • Fundraising differs from public charities; contributions are not tax-deductible.
  • Articles of Incorporation must be properly drafted with specific clauses to establish legal compliance.
  • Lobbying and political activity rules differ from other nonprofits, allowing more flexibility.
  • Registration with state agencies and obtaining necessary permits is crucial for legal operation.

The California Nonprofit Mutual Benefit Corporation Law applies to nonprofit organizations without tax-exempt status under Internal Revenue Service (IRS) code 501(c)(3). The term usually refers to a group of people or businesses working toward a common goal. Some examples of this type of legal entity are associations formed to operate a condominium complex, a downtown business district, or a homeowners' organization.

What Is a California Nonprofit Mutual Benefit Corporation?

This type of organization has a legal existence separate from the individuals who start or operate it. Those members, agents, directors, and officers enjoy limited protection from liability related to involvement in the business. The corporation can enter into legally binding agreements and take on liabilities as its own without obligating the individuals. Both the federal and state governments have specific filing requirements for this type of entity.

Members join a nonprofit mutual benefit corporation to meet like-minded people and work toward an agreed upon goal, such as improving a community, completing a project, growing a sport, or just sharing interests. An organization like this may see some benefits to exemption from federal, state, and franchise taxes if it seeks exemption under sections 501(c)(6), 501(c)(7), 501(c)(8) or 501(c)(10) of the IRS code and the equivalent sections of the laws of its state.

California nonprofit mutual benefit corporations have two main characteristics that make them unique.

  • The company's assets can only be disbursed to members if the company is dissolved. This cannot happen while the business is actively operating. This is different than a for-profit company, which can distribute assets anytime through dividends to encourage shareholders to invest more.
  • The entity can have any legal purpose. It does not have to be charitable in nature or beneficial to the general public as would be required of a nonprofit public benefit corporation like a school or hospital that enjoys tax-exempt status under section 501(c)(3) of the IRS code. It must, however, focus on a benefit to its members rather than earning a profit, which is why the nonprofit designation can be helpful.

Differences Between Mutual Benefit and Public Benefit Corporations

California distinguishes mutual benefit from public benefit nonprofit corporations in several key ways:

  • Mission Focus: Public benefit corporations serve the general public, while mutual benefit corporations operate for the benefit of their members.
  • Tax-Exempt Status: Public benefit corporations may qualify under 501(c)(3), while mutual benefit corporations typically fall under 501(c)(6) (trade associations), 501(c)(7) (social clubs), or 501(c)(8) (fraternal societies).
  • Asset Distribution: When a public benefit nonprofit dissolves, assets must go to another charity. In contrast, mutual benefit corporations can distribute assets to members after debts are settled.
  • Fundraising and Donations: Public benefit nonprofits can solicit tax-deductible donations, whereas mutual benefit corporations' donations are not tax-deductible for donors.

How Is a California Nonprofit Mutual Benefit Corporation Managed?

This type of entity is led by a Board of Directors, just like any other type of corporation. That group of individuals is responsible for the operation of the business. They elect officers among themselves, at minimum a president, secretary, and treasurer.

The corporation can also have members who can vote on some matters. The membership may have a role in electing the Board members, similar to the rights given to shareholders in a for-profit corporation. Another possible arrangement is to have a membership that doesn't vote. Members receive certain benefits like discounts, access to events, or newsletters but have no role in governance.

How Is a California Nonprofit Mutual Benefit Corporation Established?

  1. Assemble your first set of Board members, a group of people interested in governing the organization.
  2. Layout your plans for how the corporation will operate. Decide what activities the group will engage in and create a preliminary budget of income and expenses. These early discussions should involve who the managers will be and what authority they will have. The requirements for membership must be decided upon as well as what benefits members will receive.
  3. Using the decisions from step two as a guide, put together your Articles of Incorporation and make sure they meet the requirements to submit to the appropriate agency. At a minimum, the Articles must include the company's name and the address of the resident serving as the agent for service of process. If the corporation plans to apply for tax-exempt status, you'll need to include language to support that decision.
  4. Have the appropriate parties sign the documents and mail to Secretary of State, Document Filing Support Unit, P.O. Box 944260, Sacramento, CA 94244-2600 along with the filing fee. You can also choose to hand deliver them to a regional office in Los Angeles or Sacramento for an additional handling fee.
  5. Once you receive approval of the Secretary of State's office, you're ready to draft your bylaws as required by California law. This document goes into more detail on the management of the nonprofit, the address, the membership and governance policies, the bookkeeping methods, and reporting requirements.

Articles of Incorporation Requirements

To legally establish a California Nonprofit Mutual Benefit Corporation, the Articles of Incorporation must include specific provisions:

  • Corporation Name: Must be distinguishable from existing entities and not misleading to the public.
  • Purpose Statement: Must state that the corporation is a mutual benefit nonprofit and not organized for charitable purposes.
  • Service of Process Agent: Must list a registered agent responsible for legal documents.
  • Membership Structure: Defines whether members have voting rights and the process for adding or removing members.
  • Dissolution Clause: Specifies how remaining assets will be distributed to members if the corporation dissolves.

Filing the correct form (ARTS-MU) with the California Secretary of State and paying the applicable fee is necessary for incorporation.

Fundraising and Financial Regulations for Mutual Benefit Corporations

Fundraising for mutual benefit corporations differs significantly from charitable nonprofits. Key financial considerations include:

  • No Tax-Deductible Donations: Unlike charities, contributions to mutual benefit corporations do not qualify for tax deductions for donors.
  • Revenue Sources: These corporations generate funds through membership dues, sponsorships, events, and service fees rather than relying on donations.
  • Fundraising Laws: If the corporation solicits donations, it may need to register with the California Attorney General to comply with fundraising laws.
  • Expense and Surplus Rules: Revenue can be used to cover operational costs and future projects, but profits cannot be distributed as dividends while the organization is active.
  • Political Engagement: Unlike public charities, mutual benefit corporations can engage in lobbying and political activity within certain legal limits.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Can a California Nonprofit Mutual Benefit Corporation qualify for tax exemption?
    Yes, but not under 501(c)(3). It may qualify for exemption under 501(c)(6) (business leagues), 501(c)(7) (social clubs), or 501(c)(8) (fraternal societies).
  2. How does a mutual benefit corporation differ from a public benefit corporation?
    Mutual benefit corporations serve members, while public benefit corporations exist to serve the general public. Public benefit corporations can receive tax-deductible donations, but mutual benefit corporations cannot.
  3. Can a mutual benefit corporation engage in political lobbying?
    Yes, mutual benefit corporations have more flexibility in political lobbying compared to public benefit nonprofits. However, excessive lobbying can affect tax-exempt status.
  4. What happens to assets when a mutual benefit corporation dissolves?
    Unlike public benefit nonprofits, which must transfer assets to another charity, mutual benefit corporations can distribute assets to members once debts are settled.
  5. What is required to start a California Nonprofit Mutual Benefit Corporation?
    To start one, you must file Articles of Incorporation (Form ARTS-MU), appoint a board of directors, create bylaws, obtain an EIN, and register with tax and regulatory agencies.

If you need help with the specifics of the California Nonprofit Mutual Benefit Corporation Law, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from such elite law schools as Harvard and Yale and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.