Key Takeaways

  • A nonprofit can be structured as an LLC, but strict IRS requirements must be met, including ownership by tax-exempt entities.
  • Many states do not recognize nonprofit LLCs unless specific provisions exist in their laws.
  • A nonprofit can own an LLC, often as a subsidiary, to conduct revenue-generating activities while protecting tax-exempt status.
  • Forming a nonprofit corporation is generally more straightforward than creating a nonprofit LLC.
  • Compliance with IRS regulations, including operational limitations and asset distribution restrictions, is crucial.
  • Single-member nonprofit LLCs are possible if the sole owner is a 501(c)(3) organization or a government entity.
  • Certain states, such as Kentucky, Tennessee, and Minnesota, explicitly allow nonprofit LLCs, while others may require additional filings.
  • Legal and financial implications, including tax obligations and governance structures, should be carefully reviewed before choosing this business structure.

Can a Nonprofit Be an LLC?

The answer to the question "can a nonprofit be an LLC" is yes, but it's not as straightforward. If a company can claim ownership by a single tax-exempt nonprofit organization, it may be able to qualify as an LLC as long as other requirements that have been set by the IRS have been met. These requirements can be found in the IRS mandate that is referred to as the “Limited Liability Companies as Exempt Organization Update.”

Forming as a nonprofit corporation can be less complicated and more straightforward, so you don't find as many LLCs forming as tax-exempt entities. To form as an LLC nonprofit, each owner would have to incorporate as a nonprofit corporation, and all of the LLC members must in effect be classified as nonprofit organizations themselves, which makes this process more complicated.

A more common situation where a nonprofit LLC would be formed is if a group of individual nonprofits wanted to join together as one tax-exempt nonprofit, though this situation is rare as well.

In many states, the term nonprofit LLC is incorrect, and these companies are often referred to as "nonprofit liability companies." The states of Minnesota, Kentucky, and Tennessee are the exceptions. In most states, there has been specific legislation enacted to enable an LLC to be formed for any legal purpose which can include nonprofit purposes.

The IRS will not give tax-exempt status to a nonprofit unless all of the members are tax-exempt organizations. Often, a group of charitable organizations will form an LLC and be granted IRS tax-exempt status.

How Nonprofits Can Utilize an LLC Structure

While nonprofits are traditionally structured as corporations, some situations may warrant the use of an LLC. Here’s how nonprofits might incorporate an LLC into their operations:

  • Wholly Owned LLCs: A 501(c)(3) nonprofit can form a single-member LLC that it entirely owns. The LLC’s activities must align with the nonprofit’s exempt purposes, and it cannot have private inurement.
  • Joint Ventures: Multiple tax-exempt nonprofits can establish an LLC together to pursue a common mission while maintaining limited liability.
  • Subsidiary LLCs for Revenue Generation: Some nonprofits create LLC subsidiaries to conduct business activities that generate revenue. The nonprofit must ensure that this does not jeopardize its tax-exempt status.
  • Hybrid Structures: Some nonprofits form a separate for-profit LLC for revenue-generating operations while maintaining a nonprofit parent entity.

While an LLC can provide operational flexibility and liability protection, compliance with state and federal laws is essential to avoid penalties or loss of tax-exempt status.

IRS Rules in Forming an LLC Nonprofit

There are many rules that the IRS requires to be followed for any formation of an LLC nonprofit. The IRS requires the following:

  • The filing of organizational documents that include at least one tax-exempt objective as well as the limiting LLC activities.
  • The verbiage to clearly state that it is operating for charitable purposes of its included members.
  • The language must require that the members be either a government unit, a 501(c)(3) or wholly-owned agencies of a state.
  • Organizational language must prohibit the transfer of any member interest to another that is not a government unit of 501(c)(3).
  • The language must state that interest that is transferred to nonmembers require them to be exchanged at fair market value.
  • If dissolved, the LLC assets will go to a charitable purpose.
  • Any amendment of articles must consider with section 501(c)(3).
  • The LLC may not merge, convert to, or become for profit.
  • There may be no distributions to members who are no longer part of organizations that are nonprofit.
  • There must be a contingency plan if a member were to cease being considered a nonprofit.
  • The organizational language must state enforcement of LLC rules and remedies.
  • All documents must comply with LLC state laws.

Tax Considerations for a Nonprofit LLC

Tax compliance is critical when structuring an LLC as a nonprofit. The IRS imposes the following requirements:

  • Pass-Through Taxation: If an LLC has multiple members, each member must be a tax-exempt entity to maintain the LLC’s exemption.
  • Unrelated Business Income Tax (UBIT): If a nonprofit LLC engages in revenue-generating activities unrelated to its mission, it may be subject to UBIT.
  • Charitable Contributions: A nonprofit LLC does not automatically qualify to receive tax-deductible donations unless it meets IRS exemption requirements.
  • Filing Requirements: Nonprofit LLCs must file Form 1023 (or 1023-EZ) for recognition as a 501(c)(3) and comply with annual filings, such as Form 990.

These tax considerations highlight the complexity of forming a nonprofit LLC and why legal counsel is advisable.

Definition of an LLC

An LLC combines aspects and advantages of both a corporation and a partnership. Most often, LLCs are formed by a business owner's desire to protect personal assets from risk in the event of a lawsuit. LLCs also offer tax advantages and flexibility in management structure.

Pros and Cons of a Nonprofit LLC

A nonprofit LLC has unique advantages and disadvantages that organizations should evaluate before choosing this structure.

Pros:

  • Limited Liability Protection: Shields individual members from personal liability.
  • Flexible Management: More operational freedom compared to corporations.
  • Simplified Compliance: Fewer governance requirements compared to nonprofit corporations.
  • Potential for Partnerships: Easier to form joint ventures with other nonprofits.

Cons:

  • IRS Restrictions: Must be owned entirely by nonprofit entities to qualify for tax exemption.
  • State Law Limitations: Some states do not recognize nonprofit LLCs or require additional filings.
  • Tax Considerations: UBIT and other tax complications may arise if activities are outside the nonprofit’s mission.
  • Unclear Legal Precedents: Nonprofit LLCs are less common, making legal interpretations more complex.

Understanding these factors can help determine whether an LLC structure is the right choice for a nonprofit entity.

Definition of Nonprofits

State laws and IRS rules and compliance will determine whether or not a company can be considered a nonprofit organization. The rules concerning forming a nonprofit have less to do with business structure and more to do with the purpose of forming the business. These purposes are most likely to form a charitable organization often referred to as a 501(c)(3), though under IRS regulations there are 26 types of nonprofit organizations that can be formed.

State Information Concerning Non-Profit LLCs

Before you begin trying to form an LLC, you should first check your state laws and regulations to determine if your business structure will qualify for a nonprofit organization, and find the rules and regulations for forming one from the state agency that oversees business organization.

Some states, such as California will have the necessary forms and instructions available for creating an LLC as well as the steps for forming a nonprofit at the Secretary of State Office. Other states may have requirements such as each organization filing articles of incorporation and then form as a nonprofit corporation, as is the case with Kentucky.

State-Specific Regulations on Nonprofit LLCs

Each state has different rules regarding nonprofit LLCs. While some states have explicit provisions allowing LLCs to operate as nonprofits, others have restrictive regulations.

  • States That Allow Nonprofit LLCs: Kentucky, Tennessee, and Minnesota have laws permitting the formation of nonprofit LLCs.
  • States Requiring Additional Filings: California and New York impose additional compliance steps, such as nonprofit incorporation before LLC formation.
  • States Without Clear Guidelines: In many states, the concept of a nonprofit LLC is not explicitly addressed, requiring legal consultation for proper structuring.
  • Reporting and Compliance Requirements: Some states mandate periodic reports and nonprofit tax filings for LLCs.

Before forming a nonprofit LLC, it is essential to verify the specific state laws and consult with an attorney to ensure compliance.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Can an LLC apply for 501(c)(3) status?
    • Yes, but only if all members are already tax-exempt organizations and the LLC follows the IRS's specific nonprofit LLC guidelines.
  2. What is the main difference between a nonprofit corporation and a nonprofit LLC?
    • A nonprofit corporation is the traditional structure for tax-exempt organizations and has a well-established legal framework, whereas a nonprofit LLC offers flexibility but faces stricter IRS regulations.
  3. Can a nonprofit own an LLC?
    • Yes, a nonprofit can own an LLC as a subsidiary, but it must ensure that the LLC’s activities align with the nonprofit’s tax-exempt mission.
  4. Does a nonprofit LLC pay taxes?
    • If the LLC qualifies as tax-exempt, it does not pay income tax on nonprofit activities. However, unrelated business income may be subject to taxation.
  5. How do I form a nonprofit LLC?
    • The LLC must be entirely owned by tax-exempt organizations, include nonprofit-specific provisions in its operating agreement, and apply for tax-exempt status with the IRS.

If you need help with a nonprofit becoming an LLC, you can post your legal need in UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.