Key Takeaways:

  • IRS Tax-Exempt Standards for LLCs: The IRS has specific requirements under Notice 2021-56 that LLCs must meet to qualify as tax-exempt under 501(c)(3). These include exclusively charitable purposes, nonprofit member status, and dissolution provisions.
  • State-Specific Exemptions: State tax exemptions vary; some states require an LLC to hold title to qualify for franchise or property tax exemptions.
  • Operational Restrictions for Exempt LLCs: LLCs seeking tax-exempt status must adhere to strict operational guidelines, including limiting activities to charitable purposes and restricting asset transfers.
  • Joint Ventures and Hybrid Structures: Nonprofits may form LLCs with other entities for joint ventures. However, mixed membership with for-profit entities can complicate tax-exempt eligibility.
  • LLC Conversion to Nonprofit: LLCs can convert to nonprofit status, but this requires reorganizing as a nonprofit corporation and meeting IRS 501(c)(3) criteria.
  • IRS Scrutiny and Compliance: Tax-exempt LLCs face increased IRS scrutiny, requiring careful documentation of compliance with operational and structural requirements.

Is an LLC tax exempt? In some cases, yes, your LLC can be exempt from federal or state taxation. However, this usually requires completing several important steps. 

Federal Tax-Exemption for LLCs

There are several circumstances when the IRS will exempt an LLC from federal taxation:

  1. The LLC has filed Form 1023 for exemption under Internal Revenue Code 501(c)(3).
  2. The LLC is a disregarded entity, and its sole member is a 501(c)(3) organization.
  3. All members of the LLC are 501(c)(3) organizations and the LLC is treated as a pass-through entity.

In most cases, LLCs that are exempt from federal taxes under 501(c)(3) rules will not be responsible for expenditures from private foundation grants and will also be able to deduct charitable contributions. 

IRS Notice 2021-56 and LLC Exemptions

The IRS issued Notice 2021-56 in 2021, which clarified the standards an LLC must satisfy to qualify as a tax-exempt organization under Section 501(c)(3). This guidance was necessary because LLCs, as hybrid entities, posed unique challenges compared to traditional nonprofit corporations.

Under this notice, an LLC can obtain tax-exempt status if it meets the following key requirements:

  • Charitable Purpose: The LLC's activities must be exclusively for charitable, religious, educational, or other tax-exempt purposes.
  • Nonprofit Members: All members of the LLC must be tax-exempt entities under Section 501(c)(3) or government units.
  • Organizational Documents: The LLC’s articles of organization and operating agreement must:
    • Specify that the LLC is organized and operated exclusively for tax-exempt purposes.
    • Prohibit the transfer of membership interests to non-tax-exempt entities.
    • Include a contingency plan in case any member loses its tax-exempt status.
    • Ensure that, upon dissolution, the LLC’s assets will be distributed to another tax-exempt entity or government unit.

The IRS introduced these standards to prevent abuse of LLC flexibility while ensuring that tax-exempt LLCs remain committed to nonprofit principles.

State Tax-Exemption for LLCs

Even if an LLC has achieved federal tax-exempt status, it does not mean the company is exempt from state-level taxes such as property taxes or income tax. For instance, if you form your LLC in California, the LLC must be a title-holding company to be exempt from the franchise tax and income taxes. If your LLC qualifies for the welfare exemption, it can be exempt from state property taxes. 

Common State-Level Requirements for LLC Tax Exemption

Each state has distinct requirements for an LLC seeking tax exemption. While obtaining federal tax-exempt status is crucial, state tax exemptions often involve additional hurdles:

  • Franchise Tax Exemptions: In states like California, an LLC must operate as a title-holding company or qualify under a welfare exemption to avoid franchise taxes.
  • Property Tax Exemptions: States like New York and Illinois offer property tax exemptions to LLCs engaged exclusively in charitable activities. Supporting documentation demonstrating that all property usage aligns with nonprofit purposes is often required.
  • State Income Tax: Some states automatically align with federal tax-exempt status, while others require a separate application for income tax exemption.
  • Sales Tax: Many states grant sales tax exemptions to tax-exempt LLCs for purchases related to their charitable operations.

Business owners should consult state-specific resources or legal professionals to confirm compliance with local tax regulations.

Nonprofits Forming LLCs

There are a variety of reasons that a nonprofit may wish to form an LLC. For example, a nonprofit may form an LLC to limit liability when managing high-risk assets or engaging in specific activities. It's also possible that the nonprofit wishes to run a business that could put its 501(c)(3) status at risk, which is a good reason for a nonprofit to form an LLC. However, when forming an LLC for this purpose, the business will not be tax-exempt.

Some nonprofits form LLCs because they are interested in partnering with another entity in a joint venture. If the members of the LLC are tax-exempt, or if the member includes both for-profit and non-profit organizations, it's possible for the LLC to be tax-exempt. 

LLCs in Joint Ventures and Hybrid Models

Nonprofits increasingly use LLCs to form joint ventures or pursue hybrid business models. These arrangements can provide flexibility and risk protection, but they come with unique tax considerations:

  • Joint Ventures: When a nonprofit partners with a for-profit business, the LLC may lose eligibility for tax exemption. The nonprofit's tax-exempt status could also be jeopardized if the venture primarily serves commercial interests.
  • Program-Related Investments (PRI): Nonprofits can use LLCs to engage in mission-aligned investments, such as low-income housing or renewable energy, without compromising tax-exempt status.
  • Low-Profit Limited Liability Companies (L3Cs): Although not federally recognized, some states permit L3Cs, which blend nonprofit and for-profit elements. L3Cs prioritize social impact over profit but do not automatically qualify for tax exemption.

Careful legal structuring and documentation are essential to ensure the LLC’s operations align with tax-exempt purposes.

Forming an LLC Nonprofit by IRS Rules

The IRS alone will decide whether your company will be tax-exempt when forming an LLC nonprofit. For an LLC nonprofit to be tax-exempt, all company members must be nonprofit organizations who are tax-exempt. There are also complex rules you must follow when applying for this status.

In your LLC's organizational documents, a statement should be included that limits the activities of your LLC to tax-exempt purposes. The language you use when organizing your LLC must make it clear that the only reason the company exists is the member's charitable purposes. Your LLC's organizational language must also mandate that only 501(c)(3) organizations or government units can be members.

The organizing documents of your LLC must state that company assets and interests can only be transferred to a nonmember for fair market value. This excludes LLC ownership interests. Your organizational language is also required to state that the LLC's assets that are used for charitable purposes will continue to be used for these purposes after the LLC has been dissolved. When making amendments to the Articles of Organization for your LLC nonprofit, these amendments must comply with 501(c)(3) rules.

Your LLC nonprofit is prohibited from transitioning to or joining a for-profit company. You cannot distribute assets to members of your company that are no longer 501(c)(3) organizations. Because it's possible that one or more members may lose their 501(c)(3) status at some time in the future, your organizational language must include a method for dealing with this circumstance.

It's also required that your organizational language direct your LLC's tax-exempt members to enforce their rights in the company and protect their interests as fully as possible. When you are writing the provisions in your LLC's organizing documents, you should be sure that they comply with state laws and that the provisions can be easily enforced. 

Operational Compliance and IRS Scrutiny

LLCs pursuing or maintaining tax-exempt status face heightened IRS scrutiny. This requires strict operational compliance to avoid jeopardizing exemption:

  • Annual Filings: Tax-exempt LLCs must file Form 990 annually, providing financial disclosures and confirming adherence to nonprofit activities.
  • Unrelated Business Income (UBI): If an LLC engages in commercial activities unrelated to its charitable mission, the income may be subject to Unrelated Business Income Tax (UBIT).
  • Governance Practices: The IRS expects tax-exempt LLCs to adopt sound governance policies, including conflict-of-interest policies and compensation reviews.
  • Recordkeeping: Documentation of charitable activities, member qualifications, and compliance with organizational documents is critical to withstand IRS audits.

These requirements ensure that tax-exempt LLCs uphold the integrity of the nonprofit sector and prevent the misuse of LLC flexibility for tax avoidance.

LLC Tax Status

There are no tax categories that are specific to LLCs, mostly because these entities are very new. Single-member LLCs are treated as sole proprietorships by the IRS. The IRS will treat multi-member LLCs as partnerships by default. Although LLCs are not taxed directly, the income that the company earns will be taxed on its owner's personal returns. This is known as pass-through taxation.

Converting an LLC to a Nonprofit Corporation

Business owners may wish to convert an LLC into a nonprofit corporation to secure tax-exempt status. This process typically involves:

  1. Reviewing State Laws: Some states allow statutory conversion from an LLC to a nonprofit corporation, while others require dissolution and reformation as a nonprofit entity.
  2. Drafting Nonprofit Articles of Incorporation: The new entity must be formed under state nonprofit laws, including provisions for tax-exempt purposes and asset distribution upon dissolution.
  3. Obtaining 501(c)(3) Status: The nonprofit corporation must file Form 1023 or Form 1023-EZ with the IRS to apply for federal tax exemption.
  4. Transferring Assets: LLC assets must be transferred to the newly formed nonprofit corporation. This often requires formal agreements and compliance with LLC operating documents.
  5. Notifying Stakeholders: Members, donors, and partners should be informed of the transition to ensure continued support.

Conversion can simplify compliance with tax-exempt requirements and enhance fundraising capabilities, as donors often prefer giving to recognized nonprofit corporations.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is an LLC tax exempt by default?

No, an LLC is not tax exempt by default. It must meet IRS and state requirements to obtain tax-exempt status.

2. What is IRS Notice 2021-56?

Notice 2021-56 outlines the standards an LLC must meet to qualify as tax-exempt under Section 501(c)(3), including having only nonprofit members and serving charitable purposes.

3. Can an LLC with for-profit members be tax exempt?

No, all members of a tax-exempt LLC must be tax-exempt organizations or government units.

4. How can an LLC qualify for state tax exemption?

Requirements vary by state but often include applying separately for property, income, or sales tax exemptions, even if the LLC holds federal tax-exempt status.

5. Can an LLC convert to a nonprofit corporation?

Yes, an LLC can convert to a nonprofit corporation, but the process involves state-specific procedures and filing for IRS 501(c)(3) status.

If you need help making your LLC tax exempt, you can post your legal needs on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.