Key Takeaways:

  • State-Specific Warranty Laws: Statutory warranty requirements vary by state, ensuring consumer protection for various products.
  • Implied Warranties: Many states enforce implied warranties but may allow "as-is" sales with exceptions.
  • Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act: This federal act governs warranty disclosures and consumer rights.
  • Lemon Laws: Protect consumers from persistent product defects through refunds or replacements.
  • Extended Warranties: Regulations vary by state; consumers should assess terms critically.
  • Uniform Commercial Code (UCC): Often adopted at the state level, it standardizes warranty laws, focusing on implied warranties of merchantability and fitness.

Warranty Laws by State

This article discusses warranty laws by state. A warranty is a seller's acknowledgement of liability for the condition and performance of a product. If a defective product is sold, a seller or manufacturer may legally be required to replace, repair, and/or buy back the product. However, each seller may limit their liability in a warranty. For instance, a seller may choose not to warranty a product beyond a certain period of time (e.g., 5 years after sale).

One important type of warranty is a statutory warranty—a warranty mandated by state or federal law. Statutory warranties are often designed to reduce seller fraud. For example, in some states, a seller is legally required to extend warranties for passenger cars. These warranties ensure that consumers are not charged when car repairs are needed to reduce vehicular emissions below regulatory limits.

Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) and State Applications

The Uniform Commercial Code (UCC), adopted wholly or partially by most states, standardizes laws on transactions involving goods. Article 2 of the UCC covers sales and warranties, focusing on implied warranties of merchantability and fitness. States may modify the UCC, leading to variations in warranty application. For example, some states mandate stricter disclosure requirements for disclaiming implied warranties.

Express and Implied Warranties

An express warranty is a spoken or written commitment by a seller or manufacturer that a product is functional and in good condition. Typically, if a product fails a certain number of times during a warranty period, a buyer is entitled to a full refund or a replacement product. An implied warranty of merchantability is a guarantee by a seller that any product being sold is free of defects and is functional. An implied warranty of fitness is a guarantee by a seller that a product is designed to be used as advertised. Implied warranties are automatically mandated by state law and are usually limited to 4 years.

In some states, a seller can disclaim an implied warranty by explicitly disclosing that an item is sold "as-is". However, in the following states, items cannot be sold "as-is":

  1. Connecticut
  2. Kansas
  3. Maine
  4. Maryland
  5. Massachusetts
  6. Minnesota
  7. Mississippi
  8. New Hampshire
  9. Vermont
  10. Washington
  11. West Virginia and
  12. The District of Columbia.

State Variations in Warranty Protections

While federal law provides a baseline, states impose additional protections:

  • Implied Warranty Duration: Varies, commonly capped at four years.
  • As-Is Restrictions: States like Connecticut and Massachusetts disallow "as-is" sales for many products, ensuring stronger consumer rights.
  • Disclaimers: Some states require sellers to present disclaimers prominently, ensuring buyers are informed.

The Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act

An important federal regulation relating to warranties is the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act. This Act requires sellers and manufacturers of consumer goods to clearly delineate the bounds of express warranties and to expressly state the requirements for maintaining warranty coverage. In addition, sellers must also disclose whether warranties are "full" or "limited". Offering limited warranties allows sellers to limit an implied warranty to the duration of the express warranty.

The act also facilitates buyers in suing sellers and manufacturers of consumer goods in breach of warranty cases. For example, the act allows buyers to sue in a federal court (in addition to a state court) by claiming damages to the excess of $50,000—a much lower limit than applied to other types of claims. In addition, buyers can recover attorney's fees and any other types of court-related fees when successful. Furthermore, the act also enables more class action cases to be litigated under federal law.

How State Laws Interact with Federal Warranty Law

States can enhance federal protections under the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act. For example, California extends warranty obligations for environmentally critical products. Sellers in other states must comply with both federal and state laws, ensuring transparency in warranty terms. The act’s overlap with state-specific lemon laws underscores the importance of localized legal expertise.

Lemon Laws

Lemon laws are designed to prevent the sale of defective consumer products by sellers and manufacturers. In particular, in several states, if a problem with a consumer product persists after a minimum number of repair attempts or a minimum period of time, a buyer is entitled to at least a partial refund. In addition, in some states, a buyer can appeal to an arbitration panel about a defective consumer product. Furthermore, in some states, "as is" or "buyer beware" sales of certain consumer products, such as passenger cars, are illegal. However, these laws typically only apply to dealerships—individuals are often not bound by such regulations.

Lemon Law Arbitration Processes by State

Many states offer arbitration programs for lemon law claims, expediting resolutions. For instance:

  • California: Requires manufacturers to cover arbitration fees.
  • Texas: Operates under a state-run arbitration board for quicker resolutions.
  • Florida: Mandates mediation before arbitration for disputed claims.

Extended Warranties

In addition, some sellers allow buyers to pay a premium fee for an extended warranty—seller protection for product malfunctions during a period of time beyond the express warranty. Extended warranty regulations are typically state-specific and product-specific. For example, some states require sellers to maintain a certain level of reserves in order to avoid being regulated as an insurance provider.

When considering extended warranty policies, always review the entire contract carefully. Some policies only offer protection for limited types of claims, rendering them useless to most buyers. Alternatively, some warranty providers require regular product maintenance for the warranty to remain valid. Sometimes, self-insuring yourself by saving the money that you would have spent on the extended warranty maybe your best option.

Regulatory Trends in Extended Warranties

States increasingly regulate extended warranty providers to prevent predatory practices. For example:

  • Reserve Requirements: States like New York require warranty providers to maintain financial reserves.
  • Insurance Regulation: Extended warranties resembling insurance contracts may trigger compliance with state insurance laws.

Accounting Law

In addition to statutory warranty laws, there also exists a Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) that regulates business finances. For example, the FASB requires warranty issuers to provide financial reports to customers. In particular, warranty issuers must disclose:

  1. their method for establishing liability for product failures
  2. their financial accounting for each reporting period including their:
    1. starting balance
    2. subtractions for warranty payouts
    3. increases from newly issued and pre-existing warranties and
    4. ending balance

Best Practices for Warranty Reporting

Businesses offering warranties should adopt transparent accounting practices:

  • Document detailed records of warranty claims and settlements.
  • Regularly assess warranty reserves against historical data.
  • Comply with state-specific reporting obligations to avoid audits or penalties.

FAQ Section:

1. What is the difference between express and implied warranties?Express warranties are explicitly stated in contracts, while implied warranties automatically apply under state laws, guaranteeing a product's basic functionality.

2. Are "as-is" sales legal in all states?No, states like Connecticut, Maine, and Vermont prohibit "as-is" sales for many consumer products.

3. How does the Magnuson-Moss Act protect consumers?It mandates clear warranty disclosures and provides mechanisms for consumers to sue for warranty breaches.

4. What do lemon laws cover?Lemon laws protect buyers from recurring defects in products like vehicles, often entitling them to refunds or replacements.

5. Is an extended warranty worth purchasing?This depends on the terms, exclusions, and reliability of the product. Reviewing contract details and state regulations is essential.

If you need help with writing, evaluating, or claim damages on a warranty, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.