Key Takeaways

  • A product warranty is a legally binding assurance from a manufacturer or seller that a product will meet specific standards of quality and performance.
  • Warranties can be express (explicit promises) or implied (automatic legal protections), and both can trigger remedies if breached.
  • Breach of warranty occurs when a product fails to meet the terms of the warranty, potentially entitling consumers to repair, replacement, refund, or damages.
  • Lifetime warranties often have limitations and exclusions, such as coverage only for the original owner or while the product is manufactured.
  • Understanding consumer rights, state and federal protections, and the nuances of warranty policies (including extended warranties and lemon laws) helps ensure you know your legal options.

Product Warranty Overview

Product warranty is the guarantee a manufacturer of a product gives to the customer regarding the quality of their product and what compensation will be given if the product does not perform as advertised. Warranties will generally have exceptions to them that limit a manufacturer’s obligations. Such exceptions may include:

  • The warranty’s expiration date.
  • The product not being used as intended.
  • The product being resold after purchase.

A manufacturer may include language that places other limitations on a warranty, as well, or they may offer for purchase an extended warranty, which will offer longer protection from the warranty than that which comes with the product. The “fine print” should always be consulted when it comes to warranties.

Legal Foundations and Consumer Rights Under Product Warranties

A product warranty is more than just a marketing promise — it’s a legally enforceable agreement that defines the manufacturer’s or seller’s obligations if a product fails to perform as promised. Under U.S. law, warranties are primarily governed by the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) and federal statutes such as the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, which sets standards for written warranties on consumer products. These laws ensure that consumers receive clear, accurate information about warranty coverage and have legal recourse if those promises are not met.

Consumers should carefully review warranty documents for details about the scope of coverage, duration, remedies, and exclusions. They should also note any conditions that could void the warranty — such as misuse, modification, or failure to follow maintenance instructions. In many states, implied warranties cannot be waived simply by labeling a product “as is,” giving buyers additional layers of protection.

Express Warranties

Express warranties are statements made either in written or verbal form that guarantee a certain level of functionality or quality for a specified time period. Such warranties may not appear as traditional warranties at all, but rather more like advertising claims, such as a light bulb may last for a certain number of hours or years. Any express warranty is required to be designated “full,” meaning it has no time limit or is “limited” and there is a time limit. If an express warranty is written, it will be covered under the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act.

Breach of Express and Implied Warranties

A breach of warranty occurs when a product fails to meet the standards or promises specified in an express or implied warranty. For instance, if a manufacturer guarantees that a laptop battery will last ten hours per charge but consistently fails to do so, the buyer may have grounds for a warranty claim. Similarly, if a product fails to perform its ordinary function under an implied warranty — such as a washing machine that cannot wash clothes — the consumer is entitled to remedies.

When a breach occurs, consumers typically have the right to:

  • Repair or replacement of the defective product.
  • Refund or rescission of the purchase contract.
  • Damages, which may include compensation for losses caused by the defective product.

The remedies available depend on the terms of the warranty and the applicable state law. In some cases, courts may award incidental or consequential damages, such as compensation for food spoiled by a defective refrigerator. However, some warranties attempt to limit these types of damages — a provision that may or may not be enforceable under state law.

Implied Warranties

An implied warranty is a basic warranty that comes with almost all consumer products and is the basic understanding that a product will function as advertised. For example, an implied warranty would mean that one can expect a product advertised as a cell phone to function as a cell phone, and if it does not, then the manufacturer would be in breach of contract. To get around this, retailers may use the term “sold as-is” to void post-purchase obligations, although not all states may allow this.

Lifetime Warranties

Lifetime warranties are warranties that cover a product for much longer than a limited warranty, but often not for the product’s entire period of existence. Such warranties may be limited to the period in which the product is manufactured and sold or a few years after that point, or they may only last as long as the purchaser owns the product, meaning that those who purchase or own it secondhand will not be covered by the warranty. The term “limited lifetime warranty” may be used to indicate exclusions from a true “lifetime warranty,” and such exclusions should then be stated in the fine print.

Extended Warranties and Service Contracts

Extended warranties, also known as service contracts, offer coverage beyond the standard warranty period. While they may provide peace of mind, consumers should evaluate their cost and terms carefully. Many extended warranties exclude key components or require the product to be serviced only by authorized providers. Additionally, these contracts are separate agreements from the original warranty and may not provide the same legal protections under the Magnuson-Moss Act.

Some credit cards also include warranty extensions as a benefit, automatically lengthening a product’s manufacturer warranty if purchased with the card. This can offer additional protection without extra cost — but consumers should verify eligibility and claims procedures in advance.

Other Warranties and Warranty Policies

Some other warranties that may be encountered include:

  1. Credit Card Warranties. Many credit card companies will extend the manufacturer’s written warranty on products bought with the card. This varies from company to company, so the policy of your card or prospective card should be consulted.
  2. Credit Card Chargebacks. Credit card companies may also reimburse you for a defective product bought with your credit card if this is sought within a year of the purchase, the amount in question is greater than $50, and the seller is located in your state or within 100 miles of your address. Also, a claim cannot be made for an amount greater than your credit card’s outstanding balance.
  3. Goodwill Programs. Some companies will offer free or discounted products or repairs to customers who have issues, even if these offers are not stated openly in any document. When it comes to product repair or replacement, it never hurts to ask.
  4. Lemon Laws. Some states have lemon laws for such items as vehicles, pets, and even wheelchairs, which allow customers to receive some or all of their money back if the item in question is defective and cannot be fixed within a given period or after a stated number of attempts.

Some policies pertaining to warranties worth keeping in mind include:

  • Many retailers have implied warranty disclaimers on their websites, often in the terms-of-sale pages, meaning that they, not the manufacturer, are responsible for defective products, if at all.
  • Extended warranties are often not a good investment, since the products covered by them tend not to break during the time covered.
  • Consequential or inconsequential damages may also be covered by a warranty. For instance, if a defective refrigerator resulted in ruined food, the cost of the food might be covered by the refrigerator’s warranty.

Misrepresentation, Advertising Claims, and Warranty Enforcement

Product warranties can also intersect with advertising and consumer protection laws. If a company’s advertising includes specific promises — for example, that a product will “last a lifetime” or “withstand 10,000 uses” — these statements may form part of an express warranty. If the product fails to live up to these claims, consumers may have legal grounds to pursue a breach of warranty or false advertising claim.

Enforcing warranty rights often involves contacting the manufacturer, following dispute resolution procedures, or filing a complaint with state consumer protection agencies or the Federal Trade Commission (FTC). If those efforts fail, consumers may pursue legal action in small claims court or civil court, depending on the amount in dispute. In some cases, successful plaintiffs can recover attorney’s fees under the Magnuson-Moss Act, making legal action more accessible.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What does a product warranty usually cover?
    It typically covers defects in materials, workmanship, or performance. The specific terms, duration, and remedies depend on the warranty language and applicable law.
  2. Can a product warranty be voided?
    Yes. Misuse, unauthorized repairs, modifications, or failure to follow care instructions can void a warranty. Always read the warranty terms carefully.
  3. What happens if a company refuses to honor a warranty?
    Consumers can escalate the dispute to regulatory agencies, pursue arbitration if required, or file a lawsuit for breach of warranty and seek damages.
  4. Are extended warranties worth buying?
    It depends on the product and cost. Many products don’t fail during the extended period, making the coverage unnecessary. Review the exclusions and consider alternatives like credit card warranty extensions.
  5. How long do implied warranties last?
    Implied warranties generally last for a “reasonable” time based on the product’s expected lifespan, but state laws vary — often between 90 days and one year.

If you need issues related to product warranty to be explained further, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.