Key Takeaways:

  • Breach of Warranty Remedies: Can involve arbitration, legal settlements, or court cases to resolve issues related to defective goods or services.
  • Types of Warranties: Express warranties are explicitly provided by sellers, while implied warranties are legally presumed to exist even without explicit statements.
  • Types of Breach: Material breaches affect functionality and performance, while immaterial breaches do not impact usage significantly.
  • Legal Framework: The Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) governs warranties and remedies in 49 states, except Louisiana, which follows a civil law system.
  • Remedies for Breach: May include repair, replacement, refund, rescission, or indemnification, depending on the nature of the breach.
  • Differences from Breach of Contract: Breach of contract involves failure to meet terms of an agreement, while breach of warranty focuses on product/service quality.
  • Legal Actions: Consumers can pursue remedies through statutory claims, common law claims, and consumer protection laws at state and federal levels.

Breach of Warranty Remedies

Breach of warranty remedies could entail solving a warranty breach problem via arbitration or settling the matter in court. If you sign an agreement to buy a product and it ends up defective, you may have to sue the seller for being in breach of a warranty or agreement. An agreement and warranty sound the same, but they come with different legal meanings.

Any time a company offers a service or product to the public, it comes with automatic promises in the form of a warranty pertaining to the quality of such services and goods. Sellers and manufacturers usually provide warranties with products, otherwise known as express warranties. Whether the service or product comes with an express warranty, the law also gives consumers the option of implied warranties to protect them against deceptive sales techniques and defective merchandise. If a merchant is in violation of a warranty, consumers may invoke their rights via federal and state law, including statutory claims and common law.

Legal Consequences of a Breach of Warranty

A breach of warranty can result in legal consequences for the seller, manufacturer, or service provider. The legal repercussions depend on whether the breach was intentional, negligent, or unavoidable. Remedies for breach of warranty may include:

  • Product repair or replacement: The seller must fix or replace defective products.
  • Refund or rescission: The buyer may return the product for a refund.
  • Indemnification: The seller compensates for losses incurred due to a faulty product.
  • Legal claims: Consumers can pursue damages through civil lawsuits, citing breach of contract or violations of consumer protection laws.
  • Arbitration or mediation: Some contracts require disputes to be resolved outside of court.

If a manufacturer fails to fulfill a warranty, consumers may file complaints with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) or pursue action under the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, which governs consumer product warranties.

Breach Types

Breaches can come in immaterial or material form. Immaterial breaches occur when a court decides that damage does not have an effect on warranty terms, such as a mark on the side of a new flat-screen TV. Since the scratch does not prevent the TV from working, it would be considered immaterial. On the other hand, a flat-screen TV that does not operate would constitute a material breach. Merchants create an express warranty by making a certain guarantee regarding the quality of its services and goods.

  • Example:  An appliance manufacturer should guarantee that a refrigerator model is free from defects for a certain time of one year from the purchase date. If a refrigerator does not work during a one-year period because of a manufacturing or design flaw, instead of the damage being done by the consumer, the manufacturer must provide any remedy stated in the warranty to replace the unit.

Other express warranties of a refrigerator may include guarantees by a seller or distributor that the unit would be delivered to a consumer that’s free of damage, or a guarantee from an appliance repair company that assures you that the repairs will last for a certain time period. Also, merchants are not always required to issue express warranties, but it is a good business practice to do so.

Breach of Warranty vs. Breach of Contract

While both breaches involve violations of agreements, they have distinct legal implications:

  • Breach of Warranty:
    • Concerns the quality or performance of goods/services.
    • Provides remedies like replacement, repair, or refunds.
    • Typically governed by consumer protection laws and the UCC.
  • Breach of Contract:
    • Involves failure to fulfill contractual obligations.
    • Can lead to legal penalties, fines, or additional damages.
    • Can result in termination of contract or monetary compensation.

In many cases, a breach of warranty can also lead to a breach of contract claim if the warranty was explicitly included in a contract.

Implied Warranties

Various implied warranties apply regardless of whether express warranties exist. The implied warranty regarding merchantability also applies to the selling of goods. It ensures that goods match the description stated within an agreement and either match or exceed the stated quality.

If a consumer requests goods for a certain purpose and tells the seller of the purpose, the implied warranty regarding its fitness yields additional assurances on the consumer’s end. Such an implied warranty ensures that, in addition to the general notion of merchantability, the goods will be suited for its intended purpose.

The implied warranty pertaining to habitability also protects tenants where residential leases are concerned. While state laws mostly mandate that landlords keep leased properties in safe conditions, such as commencing regular repairs and general upkeep in accordance with housing codes, an implied warranty yields additional protections.

Consumer Rights and Protections

Consumers have several legal protections when it comes to breach of warranty claims. Key laws that protect buyers include:

  • The Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act: A federal law that ensures consumers can seek legal recourse when warranties are not honored.
  • Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) Article 2: Governs sales of goods, including express and implied warranties.
  • Consumer Protection Laws: Various state laws prohibit deceptive sales practices and reinforce warranty protections.

Buyers should review warranties carefully and document defects or failures before pursuing legal action. Consulting with a legal professional can help determine the best course of action.

Uniform Commercial Code

Article Two of the UCC establishes the obligations and rights of sellers and buyers in regards to implied and express warranties in the selling of goods. Sellers must note that it has the authorization to transfer the goods to a buyer and that such goods are free of unmentioned liens. The UCC defines implied warranties of fitness and merchantability, and it establishes parameters in the creation of express warranties.

Moreover, it creates limits on the ability of a seller to exclude an implied warranty from the sales agreement for the buyer to discard such warranties. Consumers may invoke warranties via civil claims for the breach of the agreement. All 49 states, including Puerto Rico, District of Columbia, and additional U.S. territories, have adopted Article Two.

However, Louisiana has a different legal system rooted in European civil law instead of English common law when it comes to the governance of selling goods. Civil codes in Louisiana allow for warranties that are the same in UCC, including a warranty that goods are free of defects and fit for an intended purpose.

How to File a Breach of Warranty Claim

If you believe a product or service has failed to meet warranty guarantees, follow these steps to file a claim:

  1. Review the warranty terms – Check whether the product had an express or implied warranty.
  2. Document the issue – Keep receipts, emails, and records of communication with the seller.
  3. Notify the seller or manufacturer – Many companies have dispute resolution processes in place.
  4. Request a remedy – Ask for a repair, replacement, or refund.
  5. Escalate the complaint – If the company refuses to comply, escalate to consumer protection agencies like the Better Business Bureau (BBB) or Federal Trade Commission (FTC).
  6. Seek legal action – If no resolution is reached, consider arbitration, small claims court, or a lawsuit.

Frequently Asked Questions:

  1. What are the most common breach of warranty remedies?
    The most common remedies include repair, replacement, refund, rescission, and legal compensation.
  2. How does a breach of warranty differ from a breach of contract?
    A breach of warranty relates to the quality or performance of goods or services, while a breach of contract involves a failure to fulfill agreed-upon terms.
  3. Can a consumer sue for breach of warranty?
    Yes, a consumer can sue under state and federal warranty laws if a seller or manufacturer fails to honor a warranty.
  4. What is an implied warranty?
    An implied warranty is a legal assurance that a product will function as expected, even if no express warranty is provided.
  5. What laws protect consumers from breach of warranty?
    The Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, UCC Article 2, and state consumer protection laws safeguard consumers from deceptive or unfair warranty practices.

If you need help with breach of warranty remedies, post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.