Key Takeaways

  • The right of set-off enables creditors to seize funds from a debtor’s account to satisfy a debt, provided certain legal conditions are met.
  • This right applies not only in banking but also in business contracts and insolvency proceedings.
  • There are key legal distinctions between contractual set-off and equitable or legal set-off.
  • Set-off may be limited by regulations or contract terms and is not universally applicable to all debt relationships.
  • Debtors should carefully review set-off clauses in contracts, as they may significantly impact financial risk and asset accessibility.

A set-off contract is a contract that involves a set-off clause, which is a legal provision that allows a lender to seize a debtor's deposits if they default on a loan. In general, set-off clauses are used in loan agreements between lenders and borrowers. They may also be used in other areas of industry where there may be a risk of payment default, such as in manufacturing.

In lending agreements, set-off clauses can be framed in different ways. Typically, a lender will include a set-off clause in the lending contract to ensure they will obtain a larger portion of the amount owed to them if the borrower defaults. When banks make such agreements with their customers, the terms often allow the bank to seize specific assets as predetermined by the clause.

Set-off clauses may also be employed when two parties owe each other money. Often, one of the parties will utilize set-off to lower or erase its liability to the other party. In cases like this, a set-off clause is associated with settling mutual debt between a lender (creditor) and a borrower (debtor) by offsetting exchange claims. In this way, lenders can collect a larger amount than they would be able to collect through bankruptcy proceedings.

A set-off claim is limited to money, and is a defensive claim rather than a substantive claim. Set-off, as a term itself, is both a noun and a verb. As a noun, it is equivalent to "offset," which is often used instead. "Offset," may, at times, be used as a verb, but this usage in the legal world is much less common than "set-off."

Bank Action Regarding Set-Off Clauses

Banks have a legal right to seize the funds or assets of a customer if needed to cover a defaulted loan. In order for a bank or financial institution to exercise their right of set-off, they must meet the following conditions:

  • The bank must transfer funds from the customer's own account.
  • The account from which the funds will be transferred and the account from which the funds would have come must be held with the same bank.
  • The customer must hold both accounts in the same capacity.
  • The debt must be due and payable.

Depending on the set-off clause, banks may be able to access other customer assets, including deposits in savings, checking, a certificate, or money market if the customer defaults. If these assets are held with the bank, they will be more easily available to the bank upon default.

In their set-off clause, banks or other financial institutions might also include their rights to access accounts and other assets in other institutions. These assets may be less accessible to the bank, but the contract gives the bank legal consent to seize these assets nonetheless.

Conditions and Limitations on the Right of Set-Off

While financial institutions may invoke the right of set-off to recover debts, they must operate within legal and contractual boundaries. Set-off typically cannot be applied to:

  • Accounts held in a different capacity (e.g., personal vs. business accounts)
  • Funds protected under law (e.g., Social Security benefits or unemployment)
  • Credit card accounts, due to restrictions under the Truth in Lending Act

Additionally, many banks include language in deposit agreements explicitly authorizing the right of set-off. Without such terms, creditors may need to rely on a court order to access funds.

In jurisdictions where consumer protection laws are robust, banks may need to notify the customer before executing a set-off, especially when it involves consumer accounts.

Set-Off Clauses in Business Contracts

Supplier contracts may include manufacturing set-off clauses. Such a clause might be used in lieu of a letter of credit, as it provides the supplier access to funds in a predetermined lending contract should the buyer default. Often the supplier will include a clause in the contract that gives the supplier the right to access deposit accounts and other assets at a bank or financial institution upon default. In this way, a supplier will be able to acquire payment equivalent to the debt incurred through the manufacturing contract by accessing these funds in the customer's savings, checking, certificate, or money market account.

Types of Set-Off: Legal, Equitable, and Contractual

Set-off rights can arise in multiple forms, each with distinct legal implications:

  • Legal Set-Off: Typically occurs when both debts are liquidated (specific and measurable) and due. It is enforceable as a defense in court without needing a contractual clause.
  • Equitable Set-Off: May apply even if debts are not immediately due or liquidated, provided they are closely connected. Courts evaluate fairness in applying this type.
  • Contractual Set-Off: Arises explicitly from agreement terms. Businesses often negotiate set-off rights to manage risk exposure in supply chain or lending relationships.

Understanding the differences is crucial for enforcing or defending a set-off claim effectively.

Advantages

Set-off clauses are beneficial for the lender when a debtor may be at risk of defaulting on payment. The lender is legally granted access to a debtor's funds and assets at either the lender's firm or another of the debtor's financial institutions. It's important for a debtor to be aware of set-off clauses, as they may ultimately relinquish assets that they might have been able to retain if they had chosen another way of settling debt, such as bankruptcy.

Although not a direct customer advantage of set-off clauses themselves, the Truth in Lending Act prohibits set-off clauses from being applied to credit card purchases. If a customer purchases a defective product, this act will protect them from having their deposits or assets seized.

Risks and Considerations for Debtors

Debtors subject to set-off clauses should be aware of the following risks:

  • Asset Vulnerability: Banks or creditors may access funds without prior notice if the clause allows it.
  • Reduced Negotiation Leverage: Creditors with set-off rights may be less willing to settle or renegotiate terms.
  • Legal Complexity: Disputes over whether a set-off is permissible can lead to litigation, particularly when multiple jurisdictions or obligations are involved.
  • Insolvency Impact: In bankruptcy, set-off rights can affect the order of creditor payments and the amount recoverable.

Careful contract review and financial planning are essential for individuals and businesses exposed to these clauses.

Practical Example of Set-Off in Action

Suppose a business holds both a deposit account and a loan with the same bank. If the business defaults on the loan, the bank may exercise its right of set-off and transfer funds from the deposit account to cover the outstanding loan balance. This action would reduce the debtor’s available cash immediately, but it may also prevent further collection actions.

However, if the business held deposits in a separate bank or under a different legal entity, the original lender would likely need a court order or rely on contractual provisions that authorize set-off beyond its own institution.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is the right of set-off?
    The right of set-off allows a creditor to seize a debtor's funds to satisfy a debt, typically when both parties owe each other money.
  2. Is set-off automatic or does it require permission?
    Set-off may be automatic if contractually agreed upon. Otherwise, creditors often require legal authority or court approval.
  3. Can a bank take funds from one account to pay a different debt?
    Yes, if both accounts are held in the same name and the contract allows it, banks can use one account to cover debts in another.
  4. Does the right of set-off apply in bankruptcy?
    Yes, but it's subject to strict limitations under bankruptcy law. Creditors must generally assert the right before bankruptcy proceedings begin.
  5. How can I protect myself from set-off clauses?
    Review contracts carefully, maintain separate banking relationships, and seek legal advice to understand your risk exposure.

If you need help understanding right of set off, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.