Key Takeaways

  • An exemption clause limits or removes liability for one party in a contract, often used in commercial agreements.
  • These clauses include exclusion clauses (remove liability entirely) and limitation clauses (cap liability).
  • To be valid, exemption clauses must be incorporated into the contract properly and pass a reasonableness test.
  • Courts scrutinize these clauses, particularly where there’s an imbalance of bargaining power or consumer rights are affected.
  • Common types include negligence exclusions, indirect loss disclaimers, force majeure clauses, and liability caps.
  • Misrepresentation or ambiguity in drafting can render an exemption clause unenforceable.

What is an exemption clause? Exemption clauses are terms that can be included in a contract to limit the contractual duties of one party or to restrict the damages available for a breach of contract.

Exemption Clause in a Contract

There can be a variety of terms included in a contract, including exemption clauses. Exemption clauses can serve several different purposes:

  • Limiting damages available to the parties.
  • Controlling the scope of contractual responsibilities.
  • Restricting remedies available for breach of contract.

Essentially, an exemption clause, also called an exclusion clause, is a term that can be used to limit the contracted parties in some way. For instance, in a contract with two people, an exemption clause can be used to state that one party will not be held liable if there is a problem with the contract. If one party wants to include an exclusion clause in a contract, certain statutory contracts must be met. The party must also prove that the exclusion clause is actually a part of the contract.

If an exclusion clause is included in a contract and you sign the contract, you will be bound by the clause. The fact that you did not understand the clause or did not fully read the contract will not prevent the clause from being legally binding . When an unsigned document, such as a ticket, includes an exemption clause, it can result in a variety of complications. In these situations, parties must be notified of the exemption clause ahead of time.

A good way to think of an exclusion clause is as a disclaimer warning you of your risks. Exemption clauses are not viewed very favorably by the law because they abdicate people of responsibility. Even so, these clauses are legally allowed if both parties understand the terms and the clause has been written the right way.

Common Types of Exemption Clauses

Exemption clauses come in various forms, each tailored to limit liability under specific circumstances. Common types include:

  • Negligence Clauses: Aim to exclude or limit liability arising from negligence. These are subject to strict scrutiny by courts.
  • Limitation of Liability Clauses: Cap the amount of damages one party must pay if something goes wrong, such as a service provider limiting liability to the contract value.
  • Force Majeure Clauses: Release parties from obligations in extraordinary events like natural disasters or government actions.
  • Exclusion of Consequential Damages: Prevents claims for indirect or special losses such as lost profits or business interruption.
  • Indemnity Clauses: Require one party to compensate the other for certain damages or losses incurred during the contract term.

Each of these must be drafted with precision and fairness to hold up under judicial scrutiny.

Requirements of Exemption Clauses

For an exemption clause to be valid, there are multiple requirements:

  1. The clause must be found in the actual contract.
  2. When entering the contract, the other party should be alerted to the presence of the clause.
  3. Notice of the clause's existence should be given in a reasonable amount of time.
  4. Reasonableness will depend on the situation surrounding the individual contract.

Because one party usually is forced to accept an exclusion clause, these clauses are usually considered to be very unfair. One example of an exclusion clause would be the terms and conditions of a product, which will usually state that the manufacturer of the product is not responsible for any harm caused by an incorrect use of the product.

The main purpose of an exemption clause is to protect the party who is writing the contract from a lawsuit filed by the other party. These clauses can also be used to distribute risk between both parties of the contract. Exemption clauses are generally separated into two categories: exclusion clauses and limitation clauses.

An exclusion clause can eliminate liability for specific circumstances that are described in the clause. A bank, for instance, could include an exemption clause in contracts related to foreign trade absolving the bank of any liability for injuries unless the other party can prove negligence. Exemption clauses can be included in a contract in one of three ways:

  • Incorporation by signature.
  • Incorporation by notice.
  • Incorporation by previous course of dealings.

Incorporation by signature means that the clause is written into the contract and that both parties have signed the contract. With incorporation by notice, an exclusion clause is included if the party requesting the clause has made an effort to notify the other party of the clause's existence. Incorporation by previous dealings is based on the terms that have already been incorporated into the contract.

The clear benefit of an exemption clause is that it can completely remove liability from one party. The problem with these clauses, however, is that they can be extremely difficult to enforce. Courts will be very quick to overturn exemption clauses if they aren't written the right way, and they often view these clauses with an extreme level of suspicion. Unless an exemption clause is reasonable and clearly written, it will usually not be accepted by the courts.

Enforceability and Legal Limitations

Even if an exemption clause is properly included in a contract, it may still be challenged on legal grounds. Key factors affecting enforceability include:

  • Reasonableness: Under laws such as the Unfair Contract Terms Act (UCTA) in the UK or similar principles in U.S. jurisdictions, clauses must be reasonable in scope and impact.
  • Clarity and Precision: Courts disfavor ambiguous language. If a clause is unclear, it will often be interpreted against the drafter (contra proferentem rule).
  • Bargaining Power: If one party had significantly more power or the clause was presented on a take-it-or-leave-it basis, courts may find it unconscionable.
  • Consumer Contracts: Special consumer protection laws often render certain exemption clauses void, especially those limiting liability for personal injury or defective goods.

Exemption clauses also cannot override statutory protections or be used to avoid core obligations unless explicitly allowed by law.

Drafting Best Practices

To ensure an exemption clause is enforceable, consider the following best practices:

  1. Be specific: Clearly outline what liabilities are excluded or limited.
  2. Avoid vague language: Ambiguity will be interpreted against the drafting party.
  3. Reference applicable laws: Ensure alignment with UCTA, UCC, or relevant consumer protection statutes.
  4. Use plain English: This improves transparency and reduces the risk of dispute.
  5. Balance the clause: Ensure it doesn’t disproportionately favor one party to the detriment of fairness.

Well-drafted clauses not only help mitigate risk but also foster clearer business expectations.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is an exemption clause in a contract? An exemption clause limits or removes liability for one party, such as excluding liability for damages or limiting remedies available for breach.

2. Are exemption clauses always enforceable? No. Courts will only enforce them if they are clearly written, properly incorporated into the contract, and deemed reasonable.

3. Can a party exclude liability for negligence? Yes, but the clause must be explicit, unambiguous, and satisfy reasonableness tests under the law.

4. What happens if an exemption clause is ambiguous? Ambiguous clauses are generally interpreted against the party that drafted them, often rendering them ineffective.

5. Are consumers protected from unfair exemption clauses? Yes. Consumer protection laws often invalidate clauses that limit liability for injury or defective goods.

If you need help understanding what is an exemption clause, you can >post your legal needs on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.