Key Takeaways:

  • LLC Membership Transfer: Unlike corporations, LLC membership transfers need approval from other members and are limited by state laws and the operating agreement.
  • Reasons for Transfer: Members may leave or transfer interests due to personal choices, financial shifts, or state-specific regulations.
  • Methods of Exiting an LLC: Members can either abandon their interest (if allowed) or mutually agree to transfer it, with formal documentation to protect all parties.
  • Tax Implications: Selling LLC interests triggers capital gains or losses and potential tax obligations on profits or forgiven liabilities, with treatment differing for passive vs. active involvement.
  • Transfer Process: Review operating agreements, draft sales agreements, and follow state law requirements; court intervention may be needed if pricing disputes arise.
  • Complex Tax Rules: Sections 731, 741, and 751 of the IRS Code apply to LLC sales, impacting ordinary income and capital gains calculation.
  • Legal and Financial Advice: Due to the complexity, consulting an attorney and a tax advisor is crucial to ensure compliance and minimize tax liability.

Sale of the membership interest in LLC form may take place for several different reasons. Perhaps a member simply decides they want out, or the owner's situation may have changed so they decide to transfer their membership interest to another member. If the LLC only has two members and one will retain ownership, the process is not complicated.

Transferring LLC interest basically means that the member giving up ownership transfers all his rights to the other member, or members. The process may be different, however, depending on the law of the state where the LLC is registered.

Why LLC Membership Sales Are Different

In a corporation, shares of stock are issued and may be transferred freely or even gifted to other owners. In LLCs, however, this does not apply. Since LLCs are more like partnerships, you cannot force partnerships between people without their agreement. You can only transfer an LLC's ownership interests if all the other LLC owners agree, and even then, only if the state law allows for it.

Some states only allow the transfer of ownership interest, but not the transfer of the rights to control how the LLC is run. The only thing the new owner may receive is his share of profits and losses.

Legal Requirements and Restrictions on LLC Interest Transfers

hen transferring a membership interest in an LLC, members must adhere to state regulations and the operating agreement. Unlike corporation shares, LLC interests often cannot be freely transferred, as LLCs are designed to be closely held entities with limitations on membership. Key legal aspects include:

  1. State-Specific Requirements: Some states impose restrictions on the transfer of both ownership and management rights. This can mean that, although a member may receive profits and losses, they may not gain management rights.
  2. Operating Agreement Review: Many LLCs have clauses that require existing members’ consent before any interest can be transferred. Additionally, some operating agreements set forth specific rules for valuations, buyout terms, and procedural requirements.
  3. Third-Party Restrictions: In cases where membership is transferred outside the existing group, it’s essential to verify if any third-party agreements (e.g., loan covenants) restrict such transfers.

How to Get Out of an LLC

One method LLC owners use to get out of their interest in the company is abandonment. Not all states permit it, and it must also be allowed in the LLC's operating agreement. The LLC owner who is giving up their interest must take an action of some sort, such as sending a notice to the other owners that they are doing so. This does not require the other member's consent.

However, simply walking away from the LLC membership interest does not mean that person is no longer responsible for any liabilities they incurred before they abandoned the company. If that person was the guarantor of a debt owed by the LLC, they still have an obligation to the lender.

A much better way is for both members to mutually agree on the member's departure, and for the one who is leaving to officially assign his interest to the other member. This should be done even if the member who is leaving is not being paid for their percentage of ownership. Doing so involves a written document that can cover other issues, such as liens and legal restrictions.

Methods for Valuing LLC Membership Interest for Transfer

Determining the fair market value of a membership interest is critical to a successful sale or transfer. Valuation methods often include:

  • Book Value: Calculating the LLC’s net asset value according to the balance sheet, though this may not fully represent market value.
  • Market-Based Valuation: Considering sales of similar interests in comparable LLCs.
  • Income Approach: Projecting future cash flows of the LLC, discounting to present value. This approach often applies in high-revenue LLCs.
  • Special Provisions: The operating agreement may stipulate valuation methods, especially for internal transfers among existing members.

Tax Implications of LLC Membership Sales

Whenever a sale or exchange takes place, as in the transfer of an interest in an LLC that involves compensation, the selling member usually has a gain or loss on the sale which is taxable. This may be true even if the member who is leaving the LLC does not receive any payment, because leaving the LLC may result in the departing owner's liabilities. The court system has set a precedent that any form of compensation, even if it is minimal, makes the transaction legally a sale.

IRS Code Sections Affecting LLC Interest Sales

IRS Code Sections Affecting LLC Interest Sales

Content: The IRS taxes LLC membership interest sales under specific codes that impact the nature of income and applicable rates:

  1. Section 741: Generally treats the sale as a capital transaction, meaning gains are typically subject to capital gains tax.
  2. Section 751: If the LLC holds "hot assets" (e.g., unrealized receivables, appreciated inventory), a portion of the gain may be classified as ordinary income rather than capital gains.
  3. Section 731: Addresses distributions received by a member upon departure from the LLC, potentially resulting in taxable gain if the distribution exceeds the member’s basis in the LLC.

Tax treatment varies based on the member’s role (active vs. passive) and the LLC’s structure, which can significantly impact total tax obligations​.

How to Transfer LLC Membership Interest

There are several steps to properly transferring a member's percentage of ownership in an LLC:

  1. Consult the LLC's operating agreement, which is a contract between LLC owners that should have been drafted at the time of formation. Any rules or provisions in this agreement determine what you can do regarding the sale of a membership interest. For example, the agreement may require that a member sells his ownership interest at a fair price to the other members.
  2. If the LLC does not have a provision for ownership transfer in its operating agreement, you'll need to consult the state laws regarding LLC administration. Some states require the LLC to be completely dissolved when a member departs. Remaining members can create a new partnership at that time.
  3. A sales agreement must be drafted between the departing member and whoever is authorized to receive the member's share of the LLC. Sample documents for this may be found online, or the member can create it on their own. It should include details such as the date, sales price, and ownership interest percentage. Sign it, and have it notarized when the payment takes place.
  4. Proceed with the transfer in accordance with state law and the operating agreement. Other members should be provided with a formal written notice of the transfer, as well as the sales agreement. If members can't agree on a price for the ownership interest, it will need to be decided by a judge in civil court.

Navigating Potential Legal Disputes in LLC Interest Sales

Disagreements can arise over valuation, buyout conditions, or the interpretation of the operating agreement. If members cannot agree, consider these steps:

  1. Mediation or Arbitration: Many operating agreements include clauses that mandate dispute resolution methods before litigation.
  2. Judicial Intervention: Courts may be involved if there are deadlocks or unresolved valuation disputes, with the power to enforce buyouts or dissolve the LLC if necessary.
  3. Independent Appraisers: Hiring an external expert can provide an unbiased valuation, which is especially helpful if internal valuations differ.

If you need more information or help with sale of membership interest in LLC form, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.