Key Takeaways

  • The main distinction in LLC vs corp lies in taxation, ownership structure, and management flexibility.
  • LLCs provide pass-through taxation and fewer formalities, making them popular among small business owners.
  • Corporations (especially C corps) offer unlimited growth potential, easier access to investors, and stock options.
  • S corps can combine corporate protection with pass-through taxation but have stricter eligibility rules.
  • Choosing between an LLC and a corporation depends on growth plans, funding goals, and tax preferences.

When comparing LLC vs. corp, you'll want to understand each one's major differences and similarities to determine how to best structure your company. Look at the details and small distinctions between each of these business formations.

Because these two entities can be complex and difficult to understand, you might want to get advice from an accountant or a lawyer. Not all professionals, however, are familiar with the current laws about limited liability company (LLC) formation in your state. When you find someone who does understand these laws and their differences, he or she can help you determine whether forming an LLC or a corporation will be the best option for your business. 

Tax Entity vs. Legal Entity

It's important to understand the difference between a tax entity and a legal entity. Limited liability companies and corporations are legal entities, while partnerships, sole proprietorships, S corporations, and C corporations are tax entities. Many new business owners don't understand the differences between these concepts and end up getting confused.

A tax entity is a classification under the IRS and state tax agency. It defines the way these agencies view the business. A legal entity is how all other legal parties, including contractual partners, courts, and the state agencies, will view the business. A corporation is a legal entity, but its tax entity designation will be as either an S corporation or a C corporation.

An LLC is a legal entity, but its owner(s) can choose from several tax entity options. Limited liability company isn't a tax designation, but its taxation options include treatment as:

  • A sole proprietorship
  • A C corporation
  • An S Corporation
  • A partnership

Because it has more options, an LLC is more flexible in terms of taxation. Therefore, the owners, called members, can decide which offers the most benefits. 

Liability Protection and Compliance Requirements

Both LLCs and corporations provide limited liability protection, which means the owners’ personal assets are generally shielded from business debts and lawsuits. However, how this protection is maintained differs.

  • LLC Compliance: LLCs must maintain an operating agreement, file annual reports, and pay state fees. They are less formal, but owners must still separate personal and business finances to preserve limited liability.
  • Corporation Compliance: Corporations face stricter formalities, including holding annual shareholder meetings, maintaining minutes, and issuing stock. Noncompliance can result in piercing the corporate veil, exposing shareholders to personal liability.
  • Registered Agent and State Requirements: Both entity types must designate a registered agent and comply with each state’s filing and renewal rules. Some states (like Delaware and Nevada) are more business-friendly, offering privacy and tax benefits for corporations.

Taxation

While LLCs have flexibility for taxation, corporations have none. One of the drawbacks to forming a corporation is double taxation. This means business profits are first taxed at the corporate level and then again on the dividends paid out to shareholders. S corporations have pass-through taxation, which eliminates the double tax requirement, but not all businesses qualify as S corporations. Depending on a company's circumstances and legal structure, its only choice might be to form a C corporation.

Regardless of how an LLC is organized or structured, it can choose its taxation. By default, LLCs are pass-through tax entities, which means double taxation does not apply, but the members can elect for treatment as an S corp or a C corp if either designation is applicable. Entrepreneurs might not want to form a corporation due to the double taxation requirements, but in some cases, electing for treatment as a C corporation can be a better financial decision. However, for many businesses, this isn't the best choice.

When a company does qualify as an S corp, the taxation differences between S corps and LLCs aren't as significant. Both offer pass-through taxation. One of the main differences comes in the form of profit distribution. Dividends distributed to an S corporation's shareholders aren't subject to employment tax, while profits distributed to an LLC's members are subject to that tax.

Small businesses can avoid major employment tax regulations by electing for treatment as S corporations. However, some drawbacks can make this election a poor choice, so it's important to talk to a professional who understands the differences before making a decision. More paperwork and less flexibility are two examples of drawbacks to forming an S corporation.

Funding, Growth, and Investor Appeal

When evaluating LLC vs corp for growth, consider how each structure raises capital and attracts investors.

  • LLCs are flexible but limited in funding sources. They can add members or take out loans, but venture capital firms usually prefer corporate stock structures.
  • Corporations can issue multiple classes of stock, making them more appealing to investors. Startups seeking to go public or raise venture capital typically form C corporations.
  • Profit Retention: Corporations can retain profits for reinvestment, while LLC profits usually pass directly to members.
  • Equity and Stock Options: Corporations can compensate employees with stock options or restricted shares — a critical advantage in competitive industries.

Business Ownership

In an LLC, the business owners are called members. In a corporation, the owners are called shareholders. The names are different, as are their responsibilities and ownership requirements. For example, an LLC can distribute as much ownership stake in the business as the members wish, regardless of the capital contributions each member makes.

The ownership stake distribution is especially important when considering how the company will distribute profits among its members. If the LLC's operating agreement outlines equal shares of the profits to all members, this means a member that didn't necessarily invest as much as another will receive the same amount of money. 

Choosing Between LLC and Corporation

Your decision should depend on your business size, funding strategy, and tax goals:

  • Choose an LLC if:
    • You prefer flexible management and pass-through taxation.
    • You’re a small business or family-owned venture.
    • You want fewer compliance requirements and less paperwork.
  • Choose a Corporation if:
    • You plan to raise venture capital or issue stock.
    • You expect to reinvest profits or go public.
    • You prefer formal governance with a board and officers.

Example: A consulting firm or family-owned shop might thrive as an LLC for simplicity. A tech startup seeking investors or stock issuance typically benefits from a C corp structure due to scalability and stock flexibility.

Management Structure and Decision-Making

The management structure is another key factor distinguishing LLC vs corp entities.

  • LLC Management: LLCs can be member-managed (where all members share in daily decisions) or manager-managed (where one or more managers handle operations). This flexibility appeals to small and mid-sized businesses.
  • Corporate Management: Corporations must have a board of directors, officers, and shareholders. The board oversees strategy, while officers manage daily operations. This hierarchy provides clear accountability but less flexibility.
  • Administrative Burden: Corporations require more documentation, including bylaws, stock records, and annual meeting minutes. LLCs have fewer reporting requirements and simpler internal agreements.
  • Continuity of Life: A corporation continues indefinitely, even if ownership changes. LLCs may dissolve if a member leaves, unless otherwise stated in the operating agreement.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Which is better for taxes, LLC or corporation? LLCs offer pass-through taxation by default, avoiding double taxation. Corporations (specifically C corps) face double taxation but may benefit from lower corporate tax rates and deductions.

2. Can an LLC become a corporation later? Yes. An LLC can convert to a corporation if the owners plan to raise investment capital or issue stock options.

3. What is the main disadvantage of forming a corporation? The primary drawback is double taxation for C corps and the extensive regulatory requirements for maintaining corporate status.

4. Which entity provides stronger liability protection? Both offer limited liability protection, but corporations tend to have clearer legal precedent in court due to their longer history and formal structure.

5. Do S corporations and LLCs provide the same tax benefits? They’re similar in that both can avoid double taxation, but S corps have restrictions on ownership and stock classes, while LLCs allow unlimited members and more flexible distributions.

If you need help with LLC vs. corp, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.