Key Takeaways

  • The main difference between an LLC or corporation lies in their taxation, ownership structure, liability protection, and compliance requirements.
  • LLCs offer flexible management, pass-through taxation, and fewer formalities, making them ideal for small to mid-sized businesses.
  • Corporations provide strong investor appeal, easier equity financing, and potential tax advantages for large-scale operations.
  • The choice between an LLC or corporation also affects how profits are distributed, how decisions are made, and how ownership can be transferred.
  • S corporations and C corporations have different tax implications and ownership restrictions that should be considered before formation.

The LLC corporation difference primarily lies in taxation. For instance, corporations face double taxation, where the business itself must pay business income taxes, and shareholders must pay separate taxes on their personal tax returns. On the other hand, LLCs do not pay business income taxes, and members only pay taxes on their personal returns.

All business entities must register as a certain business type in the state where they will conduct business. If you choose to incorporate a business, you move from a sole proprietorship (or general partnership) to a business that has an incorporation designation.

In essence, a company becomes a legal business entity that’s separate from the individuals. States recognize business entities formed as:

  • Partnerships
  • LLCs
  • Corporations
  • Sole proprietorships

Corporate Filing Process

The corporation is created through the filing of an incorporation document in the state where the business entity is created, and each member retains a certain amount shares. An LLC affords members with certain liability protections and combines the structure of a corporation with a partnership or sole proprietorship. Both entities register with the states, but LLCs do not incorporate.

The differences between a corporation and LLC can get complicated, but the details can be a deciding factor if you are choosing between a corporate or LLC entity.

  • Note: You should seek the advice of a lawyer or accountant for more information, but you should know that not every lawyer or accountant is fully aware of current LLC laws.

Formation Costs and Ongoing Requirements

When choosing between an LLC or corporation, understanding the cost and compliance differences is critical. LLCs are generally cheaper to form and maintain because they have fewer state-imposed requirements. Most states charge a modest filing fee for Articles of Organization, and ongoing annual reports are often simpler. Additionally, LLCs typically do not need to hold annual shareholder meetings or maintain extensive corporate records.

Corporations, on the other hand, have higher formation costs due to filing Articles of Incorporation and paying state fees that can include franchise taxes. They must also adhere to stricter ongoing requirements, such as annual meetings, detailed corporate minutes, and board resolutions. These formalities can make corporations more expensive to maintain but can also enhance credibility with investors and lenders.

Core Differences

In order to understand differences between an LLC and corporation, you should know the difference between a legal entity and a tax entity. A legal entity is an LLC or corporation, while a tax entity comprises a sole proprietorship/partnership or a C corp and S corp. New business owners tend to get such concepts confused, but the tax entity is simply what the IRS uses to tax businesses. On the other hand, the following state bodies recognize legal entities:

  • States
  • Courts
  • Contractual partners

The corporation is a legal entity that’s given a tax designation in the form of an S corp or C corp. An LLC has can choose any tax identity. For instance, an LLC that’s viewed as a sole proprietorship or partnership can petition for a C-corp or S-corp tax classification. The LLC itself has no special tax designation and must use the tax classifications of other entities.

Ownership, Structure, and Control

Ownership structure is one of the most significant distinctions when deciding between an LLC or corporation. An LLC is owned by its members, who may be individuals, other companies, or foreign entities. Members can directly manage the business or appoint managers, providing significant flexibility in governance. This makes LLCs especially appealing for small businesses or closely held companies seeking simple management and control.

A corporation is owned by shareholders who elect a board of directors responsible for major decisions and oversight. The board then appoints officers to manage daily operations. This layered management structure is ideal for companies planning to scale, attract venture capital, or eventually go public. Corporations also have the advantage of perpetual existence—ownership can change hands through stock sales without affecting the entity’s operations.

Corporate Taxation

When it comes to corporations, they can be taxed in two ways:

  • C corps
  • S corps

Corporations are taxed by default as a C corp, and owners must submit Form 2553 to gain an S-corp tax designation. To obtain an S-corp classification, your business must meet the following conditions:

  • The corporation must have 100 shareholders or less
  • The corporation must be a domestic entity
  • Other entities cannot own an S corp
  • Non-residents and non-U.S. citizens cannot be shareholders in an S corp
  • S corp may only have one stock class (no tiered stock allowed)

Profit Distribution and Tax Strategies

Profit distribution also varies significantly between an LLC or corporation. LLCs can distribute profits in flexible ways, regardless of ownership percentage, as long as it’s outlined in the operating agreement. This flexibility allows members to allocate income and losses based on business needs and tax planning strategies.

Corporations must distribute profits based on share ownership, and dividends are typically subject to double taxation—first at the corporate level and again at the shareholder level. However, corporations can retain earnings to reinvest in growth, potentially reducing immediate tax liability. Additionally, corporations may benefit from certain tax deductions and lower corporate tax rates, which can offset the cost of double taxation for larger, profitable businesses.

S Corp Features

The best feature of an S corp is that it bypasses double taxation associated with C corps. LLCs can be taxed as a C corp and S corp, but LLCs are taxed by default as a sole proprietorship or partnership. This means that an LLC also gets around double taxation by allowing members to pay personal taxes on their individual returns and do not have to pay business income taxes.

S corps and LLCs operate under pass-through taxation. Pass-through taxation occurs when losses and profits pass from the business to shareholders or owners. The owners/shareholders would then note such information on their individual tax returns.

An LLC may also allocate losses and profits among members without restriction. Moreover, money that’s borrowed by the business may enhance the tax basis (and decrease the taxes) of the owners, whereas an S corp does not. Contributing property to establish an LLC is non-taxable, even for minority-stake interest owners, whereas corporate regulations only permit tax-free privileges for contributors who control the company.

LLC owners also pay self-employment taxes on business income, while business owners who work for the LLC are designated as employees. Another advantage of an S corp is that it allows owners to include losses on personal tax returns in the form of deductions. S corp owners may also take out a portion of the profits without Social Security taxation. In addition, an S corp may yield additional savings on Medicare/Social Security taxes, and it permits owners to offset non-business income with business losses.

Raising Capital and Growth Potential

Another important factor when comparing an LLC or corporation is the ability to raise capital. Corporations are typically the preferred choice for businesses seeking outside investment because they can issue various classes of stock, attract venture capital, and eventually list shares publicly. The formal corporate structure also provides investors with well-defined rights and protections.

LLCs, while more flexible, face limitations when it comes to equity financing. They cannot issue stock, and investors may be hesitant due to the pass-through taxation structure and lack of standardized ownership interests. However, for closely held or family-run businesses, LLCs remain a strong option due to their simplicity and lower compliance burden.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Is an LLC or corporation better for tax savings?
    It depends on your situation. LLCs offer pass-through taxation, avoiding double taxation, while corporations can benefit from lower corporate tax rates and additional deductions.
  2. Can an LLC become a corporation later?
    Yes. An LLC can convert into a corporation through a statutory conversion or by forming a new corporation and merging the LLC into it, which is common before seeking outside investors.
  3. Which is better for attracting investors: LLC or corporation?
    Corporations are typically more attractive to investors because they can issue stock and have a clear governance structure, which provides more security and transparency.
  4. Do both LLCs and corporations offer liability protection?
    Yes. Both entity types protect owners’ personal assets from business debts and lawsuits, but this protection depends on maintaining proper business formalities and separation of finances.
  5. Which is easier to run: an LLC or corporation?
    LLCs are generally easier to manage due to fewer compliance requirements and flexible management structures, while corporations require more formalities but offer advantages for growth and capital raising.

If you want to learn more about llc or corporation, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.