LLC as S Corp: How to Elect and Maximize Tax Benefits

Key Takeaways

• An LLC can choose to be taxed as an S Corporation (S Corp) by filing IRS Form 2553, allowing potential savings on self-employment taxes.
• Electing S Corp status doesn’t change the LLC’s legal structure—it only changes how profits and losses are taxed.
• Members who actively work in the business must receive a “reasonable salary,” while remaining profits can be distributed as dividends, avoiding additional self-employment taxes.
• The S Corp election can benefit profitable LLCs with consistent income but may not suit startups or those with fluctuating revenue due to stricter payroll and filing requirements.
• LLCs must meet IRS eligibility rules for S Corps, including having no more than 100 members, all of whom must be U.S. citizens or residents.

An LLC filed as S Corp is when a Limited Liability Company elects S Corporation taxation status with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS).

What Is an LLC?

As a type of business structure, an LLC provides liability protection for the owners, who are called members, of the business just like a corporation structure would provide to its shareholders. LLCs also benefit from the taxation treatment and organizational freedom of a partnership or sole proprietorship.  

Unless an LLC opts to be viewed as a corporation in the eyes of the IRS it will be treated as a pass-through business entity, meaning that the revenue of the company passes through to the members. 

All pass-through business entities, like proprietorships and partnerships, are required to have the profits of the business reported on the personal income tax returns of the LLC members. Corporations face taxes on the business income, and the shareholders also must report any income distribution on their tax returns, so the profits of the company are taxed twice. 

As a Limited Liability Company, the liability of the members of an LLC is limited to their specific investment amount in the company. If the business were to go under or face legal issues, the members could not be held responsible for anything greater than the amount they invested, and their personal assets are protected. This protection is not afforded to owners of proprietorships and partnerships. If a partnership fails, the partners are held personally responsible for all of the business's debts. 

LLCs are one of the most popular business structures used today because of these benefits. Notable features of this business entity type include:

• Liability protection for members
• Pass-through profits to members
• Avoidance of double taxation (unless the LLC chooses corporation tax status)
• Fewer filing requirements and costs with the state
• Fewer requirements for organization, record-keeping, and profit distribution (doesn't have to reflect member's initial buy-ins)
• All profits passed through to members are subject to self-employment taxes
• Not recognized by the IRS as an official classification for federal taxation

LLCs can choose from three different tax classifications while maintaining liability protection for its members. These options are:

• Sole proprietorship (disregarded entity)
• Corporation
• Partnership

Unless the LLC elects corporation status by submitting Form 8832, a single-member LLC is automatically classified as a sole proprietorship and a multi-member LLC as a partnership. If an LLC chooses corporation status, they can submit Form 2553 to elect status as an S Corporation if they meet the necessary requirements. 

What Is an S Corp?

S Corps or S Corporations are a type of corporation treated as pass-through entities even though they are technically corporations, so the income of the corporation, as well as its losses, are passed through to the shareholders (members or owners of a corporation) and reported on their personal tax returns. S Corps are not taxed as their own entity, so they avoid double taxation like partnerships do.

Any corporation that wants to opt for S Corp status must meet the following requirements:

• The corporation must be based in the United States
• The corporation's shareholder number cannot exceed 100 (keep in mind that family members, including spouses, are counted as only one shareholder)
• Other entities may not act as shareholders for an S Corp
• All shareholders must be residents and individuals (some trusts and estates can have ownership in an S Corp)
• There can be one class of stock in the corporation, but that single class may be split into voting and non-voting types

S Corps are appealing to many business owners because they limit taxation on the profits of the company. As a corporation, the income paid to owners and employees is the only income that's eligible for Social Security and Medicare taxes. 

The pass-through income earned by the shareholders is classified as dividend income and therefore is not subject to self-employment taxes. These features allow for additional planning with taxation that's not possible with a basic LLC. 

S Corp status is attractive to many LLC members. These are an S Corp's most notable features:

• Liability protection for members (continued when LLC elects S Corp status)
• Pass-through income characteristic
• More requirements than a typical LLC (more required reporting, meetings, and record keeping)
• No freedom for profit distribution amounts (shareholders must receive amounts in accordance with their capital contributions

How to File for S Corp Status

The process of electing S Corporation status for your LLC involves several steps:

1. Confirm Eligibility: Ensure your LLC meets IRS ownership and structure rules.
2. File IRS Form 8832 (if applicable): Elect to be taxed as a corporation if the LLC hasn’t already done so.
3. File IRS Form 2553: Submit the “Election by a Small Business Corporation” form signed by all members.
4. Meet State Requirements: Some states, like California and New York, have additional filings or franchise taxes for S Corps.
5. Establish Payroll: Pay member-employees reasonable salaries and withhold payroll taxes.

Consulting a tax professional or business attorney can ensure compliance with both federal and state laws.

When It Makes Sense to Choose S Corp Taxation

Electing to have your LLC taxed as an S Corp makes the most sense when:

• The business consistently earns $40,000–$100,000 or more in annual net income after expenses.
• Members actively participate in operations and can justify paying themselves a reasonable salary.
• The business has stable, recurring income, not highly variable or seasonal earnings.
• You’re seeking to minimize self-employment taxes without sacrificing liability protection.

For new or smaller LLCs with irregular income, the costs of payroll and compliance may outweigh the savings. In such cases, remaining a standard pass-through LLC might be more beneficial.

Potential Drawbacks of an LLC as S Corp

While S Corp election can reduce taxes, it isn’t ideal for every business. Key drawbacks include:

• Increased Complexity: S Corps require more formalities than standard LLCs, such as maintaining payroll, issuing W-2 forms, and holding regular member meetings.
• Strict IRS Oversight: The IRS monitors “reasonable compensation” closely. Paying yourself too little can trigger audits or penalties.
• Ownership Restrictions: Non-resident aliens, corporations, and most LLCs cannot be S Corp shareholders.
• Higher Administrative Costs: Businesses may need to hire payroll or accounting services to comply with S Corp rules.
• Limited Profit Allocation Flexibility: Profit distributions must match ownership percentages, unlike standard LLCs that allow flexible distribution arrangements.

An LLC should evaluate whether potential tax savings outweigh the added administrative obligations before filing for S Corp status.

Advantages of Electing S Corp Status for an LLC

Choosing to have your LLC taxed as an S Corp offers several advantages beyond standard LLC taxation:

• Reduced Self-Employment Taxes: Only wages paid to member-employees are subject to payroll taxes. Remaining profits distributed as dividends are not.
• Maintained Liability Protection: Members still enjoy protection from personal liability for business debts and lawsuits.
• Pass-Through Taxation: Avoids double taxation—profits are reported on personal tax returns rather than at the corporate level.
• Professional Credibility: Electing S Corp status can enhance a company’s professional reputation, signaling organizational maturity and compliance.
• Potential for Retirement and Benefit Deductions: Owners can contribute to retirement plans or deduct health insurance premiums under the corporation’s name.

For LLCs with steady profits exceeding reasonable salaries, these tax savings can be significant.

Requirements to File as an S Corp

To qualify for S Corporation tax status, an LLC must meet certain IRS requirements:

• Must be a domestic LLC.
• Have no more than 100 members.
• Members must be U.S. citizens or resident individuals (certain trusts and estates are also eligible).
• Have only one class of ownership interest—all members must have identical rights to profits and distributions.

LLCs that meet these standards can elect S Corp status by submitting IRS Form 2553 within:

• 75 days of the LLC’s formation, or
• By March 15 of the current tax year if applying later.

Failure to meet deadlines may result in delayed S Corp status until the following tax year.

How an LLC as S Corp Works

When an LLC elects to be taxed as an S Corporation, it remains an LLC legally but is taxed differently by the IRS. This election allows business owners to divide income between salaries and dividends, potentially reducing self-employment taxes while preserving limited liability protection.

Here’s how it works:

• Legal Structure: The business continues to operate as an LLC under state law. The S Corp election affects only federal tax treatment.
• Taxation: Owners who actively work in the business must pay themselves a reasonable salary subject to payroll taxes. Any additional profits are treated as dividends, which are not subject to self-employment tax.
• Pass-Through Income: Like a standard LLC, profits and losses “pass through” to the members’ personal tax returns. However, the S Corp structure can reduce the amount subject to Social Security and Medicare taxes.
• IRS Filing: To become an LLC as S Corp, the business must file Form 2553 with the IRS after electing to be taxed as a corporation via Form 8832, if not already classified as such.

This hybrid setup gives small businesses the flexibility of an LLC with the tax efficiencies of an S Corp, making it a popular choice among growing companies that generate steady profits.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Does an LLC as S Corp change my business structure?
   No, electing S Corp status only affects federal tax classification. Your business remains an LLC under state law.
2. How do I know if S Corp election is right for my LLC?
   If your LLC earns consistent profits beyond a reasonable salary for members, S Corp election could significantly reduce self-employment taxes.
3. Can a single-member LLC file as an S Corp?
   Yes. A single-member LLC can elect S Corp status as long as it meets IRS requirements for shareholders.
4. What happens if my LLC misses the S Corp election deadline?
   You may request late election relief by explaining reasonable cause to the IRS, but approval is not guaranteed.
5. Do all states recognize S Corp tax treatment?
   Most states do, but some require separate state-level elections or charge special taxes (e.g., California’s franchise tax).

If you need help with an LLC filed as S Corp, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.