Key Takeaways

  • An S corporation is a distinct legal entity, unlike a sole proprietorship, which is tied directly to the owner.
  • Sole proprietorships are easier and cheaper to start but offer no liability protection.
  • S corps provide liability protection and tax flexibility but come with more formal requirements.
  • An LLC can elect S corp status for tax purposes, offering a hybrid structure.
  • S corps must comply with IRS requirements like issuing reasonable salaries and filing specific forms.
  • Choosing the right structure depends on factors like taxes, legal liability, ownership goals, and administrative preferences.

Is an S-corp a sole proprietorship? To answer this, we must first understand what an S-corp is. An S-corporation is a corporation that does not pay federal income taxes and protects the personal assets of its shareholders. It is formed by filing Articles of Incorporation with the proper authorities, usually the Secretary of State of the state in which it is incorporated.

Advantages and Disadvantages of an S-Corp

An S-corp has the following advantages:

  • It protects the assets of its shareholders. Their personal assets cannot be seized to pay a business debt.
  • It does not pay federal corporate income taxes.
  • There is no "double taxation" at the corporate level and shareholder level.
  • Shareholders are allowed to write off losses on their taxes.
  • Shareholders can be employed by and paid as employees of the corporation while receiving dividends.
  • Stock can be freely transferred with no tax consequences.
  • An S-corp has simple rules for transfer of ownership, unlike some states where the transfer of ownership of an LLC means dissolving the LLC.
  • It establishes credibility with potential customers and investors.

An S-corp has the following disadvantages:

  • In order to become an S-corp, the owner(s) must file Articles of Incorporation, acquire a registered agent, and pay the necessary fees.
  • Paperwork mistakes can lead to termination of S-corp status.
  • An S-corp must choose a calendar year as its tax year unless it can establish a business purpose for a fiscal year.
  • An S-corp can only have one type of stock and no more than 100 shareholders.
  • Shareholder-employee wages can be characterized as dividends, which cannot be claimed as a business expense.
  • It is difficult to allocate loss and income to specific shareholders.
  • Fringe benefits to employee-shareholders can be taxed as compensation.

What Is a Sole Proprietorship?

Sole proprietorships are businesses owned and operated by one person. While no legal paperwork is required, depending on the location, licenses and permits may be necessary. Business taxes are filed on the individual's personal income tax by using a Schedule C, Profit or Loss from a Business, and a 1040. The owner is subject to the self-employment tax and is responsible for all withholding. The biggest risk of a sole proprietorship is personal liability for the business. If your business loses a lawsuit, you are personally responsible.

Key Differences Between an S Corp and Sole Proprietorship

While both structures are popular for small business owners, an S corporation and a sole proprietorship differ significantly in terms of formation, taxation, and liability:

  • Legal Structure: A sole proprietorship is not a separate legal entity; the owner and the business are legally the same. An S corp, on the other hand, is a corporation with special IRS tax status.
  • Liability Protection: Sole proprietors are personally liable for business debts and lawsuits. S corps offer limited liability protection—shareholders are not personally responsible for business liabilities.
  • Taxation: Sole proprietors report business income on their personal tax return (Form 1040, Schedule C). S corps pass profits and losses through to shareholders' personal tax returns but avoid self-employment tax on dividends.
  • Business Continuity: A sole proprietorship ends when the owner stops operating. An S corp exists independently of its owners and can continue if ownership changes.
  • Funding and Investment: S corps can issue stock and raise capital more easily than sole proprietors, who rely on personal resources or loans.

These distinctions are essential in answering the question, "is an S corp a sole proprietorship?"—they are structurally and legally different.

What Is an LLC?

A limited liability company, or LLC, legally separates business assets and personal assets because it is considered independent of its owner(s). It must be registered in the state it does business in. Profits and losses are shared among its members. The biggest drawback of an LLC is that every owner is considered self-employed, meaning they are responsible for the self-employment tax.

How an LLC Can Elect S Corporation Status

Although LLCs are separate from S corps, they can elect to be taxed as S corporations by filing IRS Form 2553. This election allows LLCs to retain their flexible management structure while accessing the tax advantages of an S corp. This is a strategic move for business owners who want limited liability, pass-through taxation, and reduced self-employment taxes.

  • Eligibility: To elect S corp status, the LLC must meet IRS requirements (e.g., no more than 100 shareholders, all must be U.S. citizens or residents, and only one class of stock).
  • Reasonable Salary: The owner must pay themselves a reasonable salary for services rendered. This salary is subject to employment taxes, while remaining profits can be distributed as dividends and are not subject to self-employment tax.
  • Filing Requirements: In addition to IRS Form 2553, S corp LLCs must file corporate tax returns (Form 1120-S) and issue K-1s to members.

This flexibility makes the LLC with S corp status a hybrid option for those who want operational simplicity with tax efficiency.

Which Option Is Right for Me?

There are three things you should consider to decide which option is right for you: simplicity, legal protection, and taxes.

A sole proprietorship is the simplest option, but it leaves you legally and financially vulnerable. The owner personally owns the business and all its assets and is personally responsible for its operation. There is no limited liability protection.

Forming a C-corporation is a tedious process and terrible from a tax standpoint, but it offers excellent legal protection.

Forming an LLC with S-corp status is simple, offers excellent legal protection, and protects some of your income from the self-employment tax. When you are an S-corp, the IRS views you as both owner and employee, which means that your salary can be taxed under the self-employment tax, but dividends cannot be.

If you ask the IRS to grant your LLC S-corp status, you have limited liability protection and are treated as an S-corp for tax purposes. However, this requires special paperwork, and it must be filed at the beginning of the tax year.

When you run a one-person business, the protection you get from incorporation or forming an LLC is limited. An S-corp does shield you from some liability and helps you avoid paying both personal and business taxes, but part of your income may be considered self-employment income. However, an S-corp owner, unlike a sole proprietor or LLC owner, can pay his/her own salary and dividends.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between a Sole Proprietorship and S Corp

When deciding between a sole proprietorship and an S corp, consider the following:

  1. Business Liability: If your business involves risk or liability, an S corp may offer needed protection. A sole proprietorship exposes your personal assets.
  2. Startup and Maintenance Costs: Sole proprietorships are the cheapest to set up and maintain. S corps require more paperwork, state filings, and annual reporting.
  3. Tax Strategy: S corps may offer better tax efficiency by reducing self-employment taxes on dividends. Sole proprietors pay self-employment tax on all net income.
  4. Future Growth Plans: If you plan to raise capital, bring on investors, or hire employees, an S corp provides more scalability and credibility.
  5. Administrative Burden: Sole proprietorships are less demanding administratively. S corps must follow strict IRS rules, hold annual meetings, and maintain formal records.

Consulting a tax advisor or attorney can help clarify which structure aligns best with your business goals.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is an S corp considered self-employed? S corp owners who work for the business are considered employee-shareholders. They are not considered self-employed for the portion of income they receive as dividends, which can reduce self-employment tax.

2. Can I switch from a sole proprietorship to an S corp? Yes, you can form an LLC or corporation and then elect S corp status by filing IRS Form 2553. Be mindful of timing and IRS deadlines for the election to apply in your desired tax year.

3. Do S corps file different tax forms than sole proprietors? Yes. Sole proprietors file Schedule C with their personal tax return. S corps file Form 1120-S and issue K-1s to shareholders for pass-through income.

4. Are there income requirements for forming an S corp? There are no minimum income requirements, but forming an S corp is generally more beneficial once your business earns enough profit to justify the administrative costs and payroll tax savings.

5. How do I pay myself in an S corp vs. sole proprietorship? In a sole proprietorship, you draw money directly from profits. In an S corp, you must pay yourself a reasonable salary and can take additional profits as dividends.

If you need help choosing between an S-corp and a sole proprietorship, post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers, who come from law schools such as Harvard and Yale and average 14 years of legal experience working with or for companies such as Google, Menlo Ventures, and Twillo.