Key Takeaways

  • An insurance indemnification agreement shifts liability for losses or damages from one party to another, commonly seen in business contracts and insurance policies.
  • Indemnity clauses detail the types of losses covered, exclusions, limits, and the procedures for claiming indemnification.
  • Indemnification agreements play a critical role in risk management, especially in high-risk industries and transactions.
  • Properly drafted indemnification provisions and insurance arrangements are essential to avoid unexpected liabilities.
  • Acts of indemnity may provide legal immunity for certain parties under specific circumstances, such as public officials acting for the public good.
  • Common pitfalls include vague indemnity language, failure to address direct claims, and inconsistent limitation of liability provisions.
  • Indemnity insurance policies are crucial for protecting individuals and organizations against covered claims, legal expenses, and future compensation obligations.

What Is Indemnity?

Indemnity is when an individual or business receives compensation for loss or damages. From a legal perspective, it may also refer to gaining immunity from any liability or damages. Indemnity is based on a contractual agreement in which one party agrees to pay for any damages or losses that are caused to another party. For example, in an insurance contract, one party agrees to pay the other party for losses or damages in return for a premium payment that is paid to the insurer.

Indemnity clauses are usually included in insurance agreements. They specify what is covered, what is not covered, and the extent of coverage. An indemnity agreement will usually contain language about a period of indemnity, which is a specific period in which the indemnity will remain valid. Also, many agreements will include a letter of indemnity, which ensures that the obligations of both parties will be met. Guarantees that haven't been achieved will require an indemnity payment.

Indemnity is frequently used in contracts between:

  • Businesses and individuals
  • Businesses and the government
  • Governments and other countries

Occasionally, a business, industry, or government entity needs to subsidize the costs of a major issue on behalf of the public. For example, in 2014 and 2015, the government made $200 million in indemnity disbursements following the bird flu infection that nearly caused the collapse of the entire poultry industry.

The purpose of an indemnification clause is:

  • To protect one party from any losses or damages that are caused by another party
  • Hold harmless the distressed party
  • Defend the distressed party against any third-party lawsuits

Under the current legal theories of tort and breach of contract, the indemnified party can often recover from the damages or losses suffered under the current legal theories of tort and breach of contract. Typically, the costs of defending against third-party claims are covered by the indemnifying party unless it was previously established in the contract that those costs would be also be covered.

An indemnification clause is useful in setting parameters around:

  • Scope
  • Time periods
  • Maximum liability
  • Insurance covenants

To simplify, an indemnity clause is a way to transfer the risk from one individual or group to another party.

What Is an Insurance Indemnification Agreement?

An insurance indemnification agreement is a contractual arrangement in which one party (the indemnitor) agrees to compensate another party (the indemnitee) for specific losses or damages as defined in the agreement. These agreements are central to many business relationships, providing a mechanism to allocate and manage risks associated with contractual performance, professional services, product sales, property leases, and more.

Such agreements typically specify:

  • The scope of indemnification, including what types of losses are covered (e.g., personal injury, property damage, financial losses).
  • Any exclusions or limitations to coverage (e.g., gross negligence, willful misconduct).
  • Procedures for making indemnity claims, including notice requirements and documentation.
  • Whether legal defense costs are included.
  • Maximum liability limits and duration of coverage.

Indemnification agreements are highly negotiated because they determine which party will bear the financial burden if a risk event occurs. For example, in construction contracts, vendors may be required to indemnify the project owner for damages or injuries arising from the vendor’s work. In a business sale, the seller may indemnify the buyer against claims relating to pre-closing activities.

What Is Indemnity Insurance?

Companies or individuals protect themselves against indemnity claims by purchasing indemnity insurance. For example, when a holder is found at fault for causing an indemnity, this insurance will protect the holder from paying the entire amount of the indemnity. Lawsuits are so frequent that many businesses make carrying indemnity insurance a requirement.

Some businesses will purchase deferred compensation indemnity insurance, which will protect the funds that they would be expecting in the future. The number of past claims and the specific agreement will influence the overall cost and the items covered. For example, a property lease will typically include an indemnity clause. The tenant is usually responsible for damages and losses due to fines, negligence, lawyer fees, etc.

Acts of Indemnity

Individuals or businesses that have acted illegally may not be subject to damages or penalties if protected by indemnity. This unique exemption will usually only apply to government officials or police officers. In these positions, the individual may need to break the law in order to accomplish the tasks of his position. A good example would be an illegal act that's committed for the public common good.

Negotiating and Drafting an Indemnification Clause

Negotiating an effective indemnification clause requires careful attention to detail. Considerations include:

  • Clear Language: Define key terms and avoid ambiguities regarding what is and is not covered.
  • Triggering Events: Specify exactly when indemnification obligations arise, such as upon a third-party claim, a court judgment, or notice of loss.
  • Notice Provisions: Establish how and when notice must be given to invoke indemnity rights.
  • Defense and Settlement: State whether the indemnitor must provide a legal defense, and who controls settlement decisions.
  • Liability Caps and Time Limits: Set maximum indemnity amounts and deadlines for bringing claims.
  • Coordination with Insurance: Ensure that insurance policies align with the indemnity provisions and do not exclude relevant risks.

Well-drafted clauses help reduce litigation risks and prevent disputes about the parties’ intentions.

Avoiding Common Pitfalls of Indemnification

Indemnification is used to allocate risk and is commonly litigated and negotiated by attorneys. The complexities surrounding indemnification are often overlooked and misjudged. It's only after signing a contract that a party realizes that they may incur much more risk and liability than they initially thought.

It is recommended that all parties fully understand the indemnity coverage that's provided in the contract. The best way to avoid indemnification-related downfalls include:

  • Insufficiently defining or excluding indemnification procedures
  • Failing to sufficiently address or overlooking direct claims
  • Including a conflicting limitation of liability arrangement
  • Failing to include or overlooking an individual remedy arrangement

Common Applications and Limitations of Indemnification Agreements

Insurance indemnification agreements are prevalent across many sectors, including:

  • Real estate leases (landlord and tenant liabilities)
  • Service contracts (professional liability)
  • Sales of goods (product defect claims)
  • Construction (worksite injuries)
  • Mergers and acquisitions (pre- and post-closing liabilities)

However, not all losses can be indemnified. Most indemnity agreements exclude:

  • Criminal acts or intentional misconduct
  • Penalties not insurable by law
  • Claims resulting from gross negligence in certain jurisdictions

Additionally, courts may limit or strike down indemnity clauses deemed overly broad or contrary to public policy. It is important to understand the applicable legal framework when drafting or entering into these agreements.

How Insurance Supports Indemnification Agreements

Insurance policies play a vital role in supporting indemnification agreements. When a party is required to indemnify another, insurance ensures there are funds available to meet that obligation. Common insurance types tied to indemnity clauses include:

  • Commercial General Liability Insurance: Covers third-party bodily injury, property damage, and legal defense costs.
  • Professional Liability (Errors & Omissions) Insurance: Protects professionals such as consultants, lawyers, or accountants against claims arising from their services.
  • Directors and Officers (D&O) Insurance: Shields executives and board members from claims related to their management decisions.
  • Product Liability Insurance: Covers claims from product defects causing harm.

An insurance indemnification agreement may require one or both parties to maintain certain insurance policies and to provide proof of coverage. Well-drafted agreements often specify minimum coverage amounts, insurers’ financial strength, and notification requirements for policy changes or cancellations.

Types of Indemnification Provisions

Indemnification clauses can vary widely in their structure and effect. Common types include:

  • Broad Form Indemnity: Requires one party to indemnify the other for all losses, including those caused solely by the indemnitee’s negligence. Many jurisdictions restrict or prohibit this form due to fairness concerns.
  • Intermediate Form Indemnity: Covers losses resulting from the indemnitor’s negligence or joint negligence of both parties, but not losses caused solely by the indemnitee’s negligence.
  • Limited Form Indemnity: Covers losses only to the extent caused by the indemnitor’s actions or omissions.

Choosing the right type is crucial, as it can significantly affect risk allocation and the enforceability of the agreement under applicable law.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the difference between indemnity and insurance?

Indemnity is a contractual obligation to compensate for loss or damage, while insurance is a product purchased to transfer or share risk, often used to fund indemnification obligations.

2. Who typically needs an insurance indemnification agreement?

Businesses in high-risk industries, parties to large contracts, landlords, tenants, and professionals (such as consultants or contractors) commonly require these agreements.

3. Does indemnity cover legal fees and defense costs?

Most insurance indemnification agreements can be drafted to cover legal fees and defense costs, but it’s essential to specify this in the contract.

4. Are there limitations on what can be indemnified?

Yes, indemnification cannot usually cover criminal actions, gross negligence (in some states), or penalties uninsurable by law. Contract language and local law govern these limits.

5. How can I ensure my indemnity clause is enforceable?

Use clear, specific language, define the scope and limits, coordinate with insurance policies, and consult with a legal professional to comply with applicable laws and best practices.

If you need help with indemnification for loss, you can post your job on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.