Debentures in Company Law: Types and Risks

Key Takeaways

• Debentures in company law are debt instruments used by companies to raise capital without offering ownership interest.
• Debentures may be secured or unsecured and can come in various forms, such as convertible, redeemable, perpetual, and zero-coupon.
• Convertible debentures can be transformed into equity shares, offering both investment stability and growth potential.
• Secured debentures offer creditor protection through fixed or floating charges on company assets.
• Legal compliance includes registration, trustee appointment, disclosure requirements, and redemption obligations.
• Risks include interest rate sensitivity, default, and lack of control over company decisions for debenture holders.

Debentures in company law may refer to secured debentures, unsecured debentures, registered debentures, bearer debentures, redeemable debentures, irredeemable debentures, and convertible debentures. Businesses usually raise capital by issuing shares in the company or by borrowing from lenders. A debenture is a way for a business to borrow in which the company agrees to repay the debt plus interest.

What Is a Debenture?

A debenture is a bond or promissory note that is issued by a business to a creditor in exchange for capital. The repayment and terms of the loan are completed based on the general creditworthiness of the business and not by a lien, mortgage, or any specific property. An indenture is a legal document that sets the terms for the transaction. Therefore, a debenture is commonly found within an indenture.

A debenture is usually a type of bearer instrument, a type of fixed-income security in which no ownership data is recorded, and the security is issued in physical form to the purchaser. The person holding the debenture at the time of payment will receive the funds even if they're not the original creditor. Coupons representing semiannual or annual payments of interest are attached. They are to be redeemed for payment on the due date.

The creation of a debenture acknowledges the fact that a debt is owed by the issuing company. The term "debenture" includes:

• Stocks
• Bonds
• All other debt securities that were issued by the business

Ordinarily, a debenture is issued with secured borrowings and has either a floating or fixed interest payment attached to it. In less common scenarios, a debenture is issued with unsecured borrowings. In a commercial setting, the term "debenture" will typically refer to the legal document that describes the secured debt.

A debenture is considered a more secure way to invest in a business than purchasing shares because the company must pay the interest on the debenture before any dividend payments can be made to the shareholders. For example, if a company declares bankruptcy, the debenture holders will receive payment before the shareholders. The main disadvantage to being a debenture holder is that they have no control over the decision-making process of the company because they control no shares in the business.

The business has to pay interest to the debenture holder during the period of the loan. A debenture holder may take hold of some or all of the assets of the business as collateral. This would be done to improve the odds of recovering the entire debt from the organization. When a creditor takes control of the assets of a business, it carries a legal interest that the business will not be allowed to sell the assets without receiving permission from the debenture holder or paying off the debt.

Legal Framework Governing Debentures in Company Law

In company law, debentures are governed by both statutory provisions and common law principles that ensure creditor protection and transparency. Most jurisdictions—such as under the Companies Act in the UK or India—require companies to adhere to several legal formalities when issuing debentures:

• Board Approval: Directors must authorize the issue of debentures via board resolution.
• Debenture Trust Deed: For public issues, companies must execute a trust deed outlining terms for repayment, interest, and asset security.
• Appointment of a Trustee: Trustees act on behalf of debenture holders and ensure compliance with agreed terms.
• Disclosure Requirements: Companies must disclose details of debentures (e.g., type, interest rate, maturity date) in their prospectus or offering documents.
• Registration and Charges: If the debentures are secured, the company must register the charge with the appropriate regulatory authority to protect creditor rights.
• Redemption Obligations: Companies must comply with statutory rules on redemption periods and timelines.

These requirements aim to balance investor protection with corporate fundraising flexibility.

Characteristics of Debentures

• The repayment of funds is secured by:
  • The rights of the trustee over the business
  • The tangible assets of the business
  • The guarantor or cosigner
• The tangible property or assets that make up the security are sufficient to meet the entire liability for the repayment.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Debentures

Advantages:

• Predictable Returns: Fixed interest payments make debentures attractive to investors seeking steady income.
• No Ownership Dilution: Companies can raise funds without giving up equity or control.
• Tax Deductibility: Interest paid on debentures is generally tax-deductible for the issuing company.
• Security for Investors: Secured debentures are backed by company assets, reducing risk for lenders.

Disadvantages:

• Fixed Obligations: Companies must pay interest regardless of profit, creating cash flow pressure.
• Credit Risk for Investors: Unsecured or subordinated debentures carry higher risk if the company becomes insolvent.
• Limited Investor Rights: Debenture holders do not participate in management decisions or share in company profits beyond interest payments.
• Regulatory Compliance: Issuing debentures involves legal costs and regulatory filings that may not be suitable for all businesses.

Types of Debentures

• Secured debentures: The assets of the issuing company are essentially held as collateral to encourage payment to its creditors.
  • The charge may be floating or fixed.
  • A floating charge is applied to the general assets, while a fixed charge is applied to a specific asset.
• Unsecured debentures: There are no assets held as additional security.
• Redeemable debentures: Payable at the end of a specific period or through installments
• Irredeemable debentures: The business pays a specific interest rate regularly but provides no data on when principal will be returned.
• Convertible debentures: Debentures that are convertible into shares or any other form of security that are exercised by option of the company or the holder
• Subordinate debentures: Will be repaid after some other privileged debt has been satisfied
• Convertible subordinate debentures: Is subordinate or subject to the prior repayment of other outstanding debts but which can convert into another type of security
• Specific interest rate debentures: Issued with a specific interest rate
• Zero-interest rate debentures: Do not carry a specific interest rate
• Registered debentures: All details of the debenture holder are entered in a register that's kept by the company.
• Bearer debentures: The company doesn't keep a record of the debenture holder. Therefore, the debenture can be transferred by way of delivery.
• Sinking debentures: The repayment is secured because the company is making systematic payments into a sinking fund.

Risks Associated With Debentures

While debentures can be a powerful funding tool, they are not without risks:

• Interest Rate Risk: Rising interest rates can reduce the market value of fixed-rate debentures.
• Default Risk: If the company is unable to meet interest or principal obligations, debenture holders may suffer losses.
• Liquidity Risk: Debentures may not always be easily tradable in secondary markets, especially private placements.
• Market Perception: Companies overly reliant on debt financing may be viewed as high-risk by investors.

Investors and companies should carefully assess these risks when structuring or purchasing debentures.

Debentures vs. Other Debt Instruments

Understanding how debentures differ from similar instruments helps clarify their role in corporate finance:

Debentures offer more flexibility in structure and convertibility than traditional loans or bonds, making them a popular choice in company law frameworks.

Fixed vs. Floating Charge Debentures

In secured debentures, the nature of the charge on assets can affect creditor protection and company operations:

• Fixed Charge Debenture: The security is tied to a specific asset, such as property or machinery. The company cannot sell the asset without the debenture holder’s consent.
• Floating Charge Debenture: The charge applies to a group of changing assets (e.g., stock-in-trade). The company can use or sell these assets in the ordinary course of business until the charge “crystallizes” (typically during insolvency or default).

These structures allow companies operational flexibility while giving investors varying levels of security.

Perpetual and Zero-Coupon Debentures

• Perpetual Debentures: These have no fixed maturity date. The issuing company pays interest indefinitely unless it chooses to redeem the debenture voluntarily. These are rarely used due to the long-term liability but may appeal to long-term institutional investors.
• Zero-Coupon Debentures: These do not carry periodic interest payments. Instead, they are issued at a discount and repaid at face value upon maturity. The difference between the issue price and redemption value represents the investor’s return.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is a debenture in company law?
   A debenture is a legal instrument used by a company to borrow money, typically offering fixed interest without giving ownership or voting rights.
2. What’s the difference between a secured and unsecured debenture?
   Secured debentures are backed by company assets, while unsecured ones rely solely on the company’s creditworthiness.
3. Can debentures be converted into company shares?
   Yes, convertible debentures can be exchanged for equity shares under specified terms.
4. Who regulates debentures under company law?
   Debenture issuance is typically governed by a country's companies act, securities regulators, and listing authorities.
5. Are debentures a good investment?
   They can be suitable for investors seeking predictable income, though risks like default and interest rate changes should be considered.

If you need help with debentures in company law, you can post your job on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.