Consensual Contract Law: Key Concepts and Applications

Key Takeaways

• A consensual contract is formed through mutual agreement without requiring formalities like delivery or notarization.
• These contracts date back to Roman law and cover categories like sales, leases, partnerships, and agency.
• Valid consensual contracts must have lawful purpose, capable parties, mutual consent, and consideration.
• The enforceability of consensual contracts depends on context—some require writing to comply with the Statute of Frauds.
• Unlike real contracts, consensual contracts do not require physical delivery or performance to be binding.
• A contract may be void, voidable, or valid depending on whether the legal requirements are met.
• Consent must be free of fraud, duress, or undue influence for the agreement to be enforceable.

A consensual contract is a contract that is founded on the mere unanimous agreement of interested parties and doesn't need to be implemented through an official procedure.

Consensual Contract Overview

In Roman law, a consensual contract was in four forms in which unofficial consent alone was enough. They are the following:

• The agreement of an agency
• An agreement of partnership
• A sale
• Hiring or letting

An everyday example of a consensual contract is the contract of buying and selling. That is because the moment the seller and buyer agree on a price for an item to be sold and bought respectively, the seller and buyer have mutual actions. However, this is slightly different with lending and borrowing, because until the loaned item or amount of money is handed over, there's no action taken. There may have only been consent.

Key Elements of a Consensual Contract

To be legally enforceable, a consensual contract must typically include the following elements:

• Offer and Acceptance: One party makes an offer, and the other accepts it unambiguously.
• Mutual Consent: Both parties agree to the same terms knowingly and willingly.
• Legal Purpose: The contract’s purpose must not violate public policy or law.
• Capacity: Parties must be legally competent (e.g., not minors or mentally incapacitated).
• Consideration: Something of value must be exchanged between the parties.

Without these elements, the contract may be void or voidable under the law.

Historical Origins and Legal Evolution of Consensual Contracts

The concept of a consensual contract originates from Roman law, which recognized certain agreements as legally binding based solely on mutual consent. These included contracts for sale, lease, partnership, and mandate (agency). Unlike real contracts that required physical delivery or performance, consensual contracts were enforceable immediately upon agreement. Over time, modern legal systems adopted these principles, making mutual assent a cornerstone of contract law. Today, consensual contracts are a default assumption in many jurisdictions when parties voluntarily enter into obligations with clear intent to be legally bound.

Real Contracts

A real contract is an agreement between interested parties to carry out (or refrain from carrying out) a duty regarding a real property. They are contracts in which monetary or other property exchanges are made between contracting parties, and they require more than mere consent. The phrase “real contract” originated from Roman law, and was used in reference to contracts concerning personal and real property alike.

Differences Between Consensual and Real Contracts

While both consensual and real contracts are legally recognized, they differ in key aspects:

This distinction is important in evaluating when a contract becomes enforceable and what evidence is needed to prove its existence.

Valid Contracts

Under state and federal laws, a valid contract is enforceable and has every required element. A valid contract has two basic elements: offer and acceptance. One party offers the contract by spelling out its terms, and the other party accepts (typically in writing). Sometimes it takes time for the other party to accept because acceptance is the endpoint of the negotiation process, which could last for a while.

Also, the purpose of the contract must be lawful, and all parties must accept the terms of the contract, be old enough to give their consent, and be mentally capable of understanding and abiding by its terms. A binding contract must hold a value or price that passes from one party to the other. Value isn't limited to money. It can be an interest, right, or benefit. Contracting parties in a valid contract must profit one way or another. For example, when a party sells their car to some other party, the seller gets money and the buyer gets the car.

Agreements are oral and can be enforced. However, some contracts aren't valid unless they're put in writing. Ideally, agreements involving a huge amount of value or real property, debt, or contracts that won't be effective for a long while, such as a will, should be put in writing.

Enforceability and the Statute of Frauds

Although consensual contracts can be oral or written, certain contracts must comply with the Statute of Frauds to be enforceable. This legal doctrine requires that specific types of agreements be in writing, such as:

• Contracts for the sale of goods over a certain dollar amount
• Real estate transactions
• Contracts that cannot be performed within one year
• Agreements to answer for another’s debt

If a consensual contract falls under these categories but isn’t documented in writing, courts may deem it unenforceable—even if both parties gave valid consent.

Void Contracts

A contract is valid only if the agreement is consensual, lawful, and supported with a promise of value. It also must be executed by parties who are old enough and are mentally capable of understanding and upholding the terms of the contract. Otherwise, it's void.

A void contract can't be enforced under federal and state laws. If someone is hired by an employer and the terms of the employment include illegal job descriptions, that's an example of a void contract. Such a contract is void because it goes against the law and isn't in compliance with the elements of a valid contract.

These contracts are null from the outset, and neither party is bound by its terms. Think of such a contract as one that isn't recognized by the law and can never be enforced because it lacks the elements of a valid contract.

The following are some reasons that make a contract void:

• If a party wasn't sound-minded when signing it
• If a party wasn't old enough to give their consent
• If its terms are impossible to uphold
• If it restricts a party's right(s)

Voidable Contracts

A voidable contract, on the other hand, is valid and can be enforceable under certain circumstances if all involved parties agree to move forward. Any given party can accept the terms of a contract, while any others can oppose the terms for legal reasons as they see fit. So, if the opposing party or parties insist(s) on not accepting the terms of the contract, it becomes voidable.

A contract can be voidable for the following reasons:

• A party was compelled or threatened to sign it
• A party was unduly influenced to sign it
• Its terms were breached
• Parties were mistaken about its terms
• It's fraudulent
• It has false statements

When Consent Is Not Freely Given

A consensual contract may become voidable if the consent of one party was compromised. Common factors that invalidate free consent include:

• Fraud or Misrepresentation: One party is deceived about material facts.
• Duress: One party is forced into the agreement through threats or coercion.
• Undue Influence: A party is pressured by someone in a position of trust.
• Mistake: Both parties misunderstand a fundamental aspect of the contract.

In such cases, the affected party may rescind the contract and be restored to their original position under contract law principles.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is a consensual contract?
   A consensual contract is a legally binding agreement formed by mutual consent of the parties, without requiring physical delivery or formalities.
2. Is a verbal agreement a consensual contract?
   Yes, verbal agreements can be considered consensual contracts if they meet the legal criteria—though some may require written form to be enforceable.
3. How does a consensual contract differ from a real contract?
   A consensual contract is formed by agreement alone, while a real contract also requires the delivery of a thing or performance.
4. Can a consensual contract be invalid?
   Yes. If it lacks capacity, legal purpose, consent, or consideration, or if consent was obtained improperly, the contract may be void or voidable.
5. Are consensual contracts recognized in all legal systems?
   Most modern legal systems recognize consensual contracts, especially in common law and civil law traditions, though enforcement rules may vary.

If you need help with a consensual contract, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.