Key Takeaways:

  • Coercion in contract law occurs when threats or harm force a party into an agreement, making the contract unenforceable.
  • A contract must have free consent from all parties; coercion invalidates this consent.
  • Rescinding a coerced contract releases both parties from their obligations.
  • Legal defenses, such as "unclean hands," can contest claims of coercion if both parties contributed to it.
  • Consulting a lawyer can help assess the presence of coercion and potential legal actions for contract rescission.

Coercion in law of contract means threats or actual harm was used to force someone into entering into a contract. If coercion is involved in the formation of a contract, the agreement will not be legally enforceable.

What is Coercion of Contract?

For a contract to be legally enforceable, both parties must have willingly entered into the contract. On the other hand, if one party was coerced into the contract, meaning threats were used to obtain their acceptance, the contract is not valid. This rule related to coercion applies both to specific terms in a contract and the contract as a whole. Basically, this means that contracted parties must agree to the entire contract and must also agree to all the individual terms.

Examples of Coercion in Contracts

Coercion can take many forms in contract law, ranging from physical threats to economic pressure. For instance, one party might threaten harm to force the other into signing, or a party might leverage financial influence, demanding an agreement under the threat of severe financial harm if not accepted. Coercion can be subtle, such as exploiting a party's economic vulnerability, or overt, such as a direct physical threat. Understanding these examples helps clarify what constitutes coercion and the varied ways it can appear in contractual contexts.

How Does Coercion Effect a Contract?

If it is discovered that coercion was involved in the formation of the contract, the agreement will almost always be rescinded. When contract rescission occurs, the entirety of the agreement is canceled. Both parties are released from their responsibilities as defined in the contract.

Legal Consequences of Coercion

When coercion is proven, the legal outcome often involves nullifying the contract, as the coerced party’s consent was not genuine. Courts may also award damages to the coerced party to compensate for any losses incurred. Moreover, proving coercion requires specific evidence, such as communication records or witness testimonies, to show that consent was influenced by threats or harm. The courts consider each case individually, examining the extent of coercion and its impact on the agreement.

Defending Against Coercion

The idea of ‘unclean hands' is a defense that can be used for coercion in a contract. The general idea behind unclean hands is that one party can't be held liable for coercion because the other party was guilty of the same act. Another way to understand this idea is that both parties coerced each other in order to form the contract.

Despite the fact that both parties are guilty of coercion, the contract would still be canceled. No coercion can exist in a legal contract. It's possible for one party to get out of their contractual obligations by claiming coercion. One party could state that since coercion occurred, they should not be forced to perform the contract.

Legal Recourse for Victims of Coercion

Victims of coercion have several options for legal recourse. They can file a lawsuit seeking to rescind the contract or pursue damages. Legal claims often depend on demonstrating that coercion impacted their decision-making ability. In some cases, proving coercion might also lead to punitive damages if the coercion was egregious. A lawyer can help victims gather the necessary evidence and navigate the legal process.

Do You Need a Lawyer to Help With Coercion?

Contract law, whether it's at the federal or state level, can be very complicated. If you've signed a contract but now believe that coercion was involved, it may be a good idea to consult with a business lawyer. An attorney can examine the circumstances around the formation of the contract and can determine whether or not you were coerced into signing the agreement.

If there was coercion, and you decide to file a court case to terminate the contract, your attorney can be of assistance here as well.

Steps to Take if You Suspect Coercion

If you suspect you were coerced into a contract, take immediate steps to document your experience. Save all related communication, such as emails, texts, or written correspondence, and note any witnesses who can support your claims. Consulting a lawyer is crucial to understand your rights and the strength of your case. An experienced contract lawyer can help you pursue legal actions to rescind the contract or seek compensation if necessary​.

Contracts That Are Unenforceable

A contract is a type of legally binding agreement. This means that once you enter into a contract, you are legally required to perform your contractual duties. The exception to this rule is if you can prove that the contract is legally unenforceable.

Several different situations can create an unenforceable contract. One of the most common reasons that a contract would be unenforceable is that one of the parties did not have legal capacity. Lack of capacity means that a person is incapable of entering into a contract, whether they are under the majority age or have some kind of mental impairment.

Entering into a contract under duress, which is a type of coercion, will make the contract unenforceable. For instance, if you purchase a product from a company, and the company refuses to complete the delivery until you give them more money, this would be a form of duress.

While lack of capacity and coercion are two of the most common reasons a contract would be unenforceable, several other situations may remove a contract's validity, including:

  • Undue Influence: This occurs when one party takes advantage of another, usually because there is a special, preexisting relationship between the two parties. For instance, if a parent pressures their adult child to enter into a contract, this could be undue influence.
  • Misrepresentation: If misrepresentation occurs during the process of contract negotiation, such as making false statements about the quality of a product, it may not be possible to enforce the contract.
  • Nondisclosure: Sometimes, misrepresentation occurs because one party has not disclosed important information to the other party. Nondisclosure will often result in a contract being unenforceable.
  • Unconscionability: If a contract includes terms that would be considered completely unfair, the contract cannot be enforced.

Comparing Coercion with Other Contractual Issues

While coercion involves threats or harm, other factors can also render a contract unenforceable, such as undue influence, misrepresentation, and unconscionability. Undue influence differs from coercion as it typically occurs within a relationship of trust, where one party exerts influence over another, rather than using threats. Misrepresentation and unconscionability focus on false statements or unfair terms, respectively. Understanding these distinctions can help parties identify the specific legal grounds for challenging a contract.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is an example of coercion in contract law?Coercion may include physical threats or financial manipulation, such as demanding a person sign under threat of harm or economic penalty.

2. How does coercion impact the enforceability of a contract?Coercion renders a contract unenforceable because it compromises free consent, allowing the coerced party to potentially rescind the contract.

3. Can both parties be guilty of coercion?Yes, in some cases, both parties might engage in coercive actions. However, this does not make the contract enforceable, as mutual coercion still invalidates free consent.

4. What evidence is needed to prove coercion in contract law?Proving coercion often requires evidence like written threats, communication records, or witness testimony demonstrating that one party forced the other into the agreement.

5. When should I consult a lawyer if I suspect coercion?If you believe coercion influenced your contract, consult a lawyer as soon as possible to understand your rights and potential legal actions.

If you need help with coercion in law of contract, you can post your legal needs on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.