Key Takeaways

  • Coercion in business law involves using threats or unlawful pressure to force someone into a contract.
  • It can be physical, psychological, or economic and may come from a party to the contract or a third party.
  • A coerced contract is voidable, and the harmed party can seek to rescind it.
  • Coercion may involve threats of physical harm, property loss, or unlawful confinement.
  • Courts assess factors like intent, nature of the threat, and relationship between the parties to determine coercion.
  • Legal defenses include demonstrating mutual coercion or proving voluntary agreement.
  • Legal remedies include rescission, damages, or declaring the contract void.
  • Hiring a lawyer is crucial for evaluating coercion claims and pursuing relief.

Those wondering what is coercion in business law should know that, in short, it is the use of or threat to use prejudice, property, or any other act to force a party to enter into an agreement. It can happen physically or psychologically; direct coercion, for instance, occurs when a man is physically made to do something he doesn't want to do. The act can be directed to a person, not just to the other party. It can also come from a stranger to the contract.

Coercion may vary based on state and federal laws. One state may define coercion as someone who makes another person enter an agreement due to being threatened with physical damage. Another state may define it as a party who entered a contract by the other party's threat to take the first party's property. The Hobbs Act is federal protection for someone who is being coerced into a contract or agreement.

What Is Contract Coercion?

Contract coercion happens when you are threatened into an agreement. Federal and state laws require you to enter contracts by your own will. The contract won't be considered legal if you are made to go into a contract. This also applies to a contract's individual terms. The entire agreement must be agreed upon through the consent of both parties.

Key Elements of Coercion in Business Law

To prove coercion in a business contract, certain elements must be established:

  • Threat or use of force: There must be a threat of harm or use of unlawful pressure.
  • Lack of free consent: The coerced party did not enter the contract voluntarily.
  • Intent to compel agreement: The coercing party intended to force the other party into agreement.
  • Unlawful or illegitimate conduct: The pressure applied must be considered unlawful or unreasonable.

Courts also consider whether a reasonable person would feel compelled to act under similar threats, adding an objective standard to coercion claims​​.

What Is the Effect of Coercion on a Contract?

The contract will be canceled or rescinded if coercion is suspected. Both parties will not be held responsible for any of the conditions laid out in the agreement if coercion has, in fact, occurred.

Legal Consequences and Remedies for Coercion

When coercion is proven, the contract is typically deemed voidable. The victim can pursue one or more of the following remedies:

  • Rescission of contract: The agreement can be canceled, and both parties are released from obligations.
  • Restitution: Any benefits or money exchanged under the coerced agreement must be returned.
  • Damages: The injured party may be awarded compensation for losses incurred due to the coerced contract.
  • Declaratory judgment: Courts may formally declare the contract invalid due to coercion.

The burden of proof generally lies on the party alleging coercion​.

Examples of Coercion

  • A tells B he will hurt him if he doesn't give him his car. B gives A his car, causing his agreement to be coerced.
  • A threatens to hurt B if he doesn't give his son, C, a large sum of money. B believes the threat and gives C the money. This agreement is believed to be coerced.
  • A man is captured by the enemies of his home country who make him fight against his country by threatening his life.
  • A husband's wife may be thought to have been coerced by her husband if she commits a crime in his business.

Important Legal Rules for a Valid Coercion Case

  • It must be a committed act of coercion where the other party did something to cause you to agree to the terms of the contract.
  • It must be a threatened act of coercion, whether physical or psychological, which made you go into the agreement to avoid the threat from becoming a reality.
  • It must be the unlawful detainment or threat to take someone's property, such as a car or a home.
  • There must be evidence that the party had the intention to make you enter an agreement before presenting the contract.
  • It can be caused by any one person, not necessarily a party of individuals.
  • Threat of personal physical harm or suicide by the coercing party may be seen as coercion.

The Office of the Law Revision Counsel has a United States Code where these laws, and others, can be found for your convenience.

Types of Coercion in Business Law

Coercion can take many forms in the business context:

  • Physical coercion: Threats of violence or physical harm.
  • Psychological coercion: Emotional or mental manipulation.
  • Economic duress: Threats that impact a person’s financial well-being, such as withholding payment or threatening job loss.
  • Unlawful detention: Holding someone's property or person until they agree to contract terms.
  • Blackmail or extortion: Forcing agreement through the threat of revealing damaging information.

Understanding the type of coercion involved can help in building a strong legal argument​​.

Are There Defenses to Contract Coercion?

In short, yes, there are defenses to contract coercion. For instance, “unclean hands” is a term used to avoid sole liability on one party. This claim can be used to place blame on the other party as well. It can be used to say both parties are guilty of coercion, causing the contract to be voided.

This defense may help avoid legal problems. It can also be used to avoid contract duties. A party may feel they do not need to do what the contract says because they were coerced into the agreement. Coercion, in this sense, can be used for contract defense.

How Courts Determine Coercion

Courts evaluate several factors when deciding whether coercion has occurred:

  • Nature and severity of the threat
  • Timing of the pressure in relation to contract signing
  • Availability of alternative options
  • Whether the victim reported the coercion promptly
  • Relative power dynamics or vulnerabilities between parties

If the court finds that consent was not freely given, it may invalidate the contract or provide appropriate remedies​​.

Should I Use a Lawyer If I Suspect Contract Coercion?

Hiring a lawyer who is knowledgeable in business laws and contracts can be helpful if you suspect coercion applies to the agreement you have signed. The lawyer can give you legal advice and guide you throughout the case. Furthermore, a lawyer may be able to help throughout trial appearances to represent you.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What are signs that a contract was signed under coercion?
    Threats of harm, lack of negotiation, undue pressure, or fear of retaliation are common red flags of coercion.
  • Can coercion make a contract completely void?
    No, it makes the contract voidable at the option of the coerced party. They must act to rescind it.
  • Is economic pressure considered coercion?
    Yes, if the economic threat leaves the victim with no reasonable alternative, it can be considered coercion.
  • Can coercion be claimed if the threat came from a third party?
    Yes, coercion can originate from someone outside the contract if it influenced a party’s consent.
  • What evidence is needed to prove coercion?
    Statements, witness testimony, records of threats, and proof of an unequal power dynamic can support a coercion claim.

If you need help with coercion in business law, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.