Key Takeaways

  • Stakeholders are individuals or groups with an interest in the success or failure of a business, including owners, employees, suppliers, and even political or religious entities.
  • Stakeholders are divided into internal (within the business, e.g., employees and owners) and external (outside the business, e.g., customers, suppliers, and media).
  • The advantages of stakeholders include business experience, acumen, and access to resources that help drive growth and strategic decisions.
  • The disadvantages of stakeholders can include self-interest, resistance to change, and fears of failure that may impede progress or decision-making.
  • Effective stakeholder management is critical to a business’s success, helping prevent conflicts and fostering collaboration to ensure long-term growth.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Stakeholders

The advantages and disadvantages of stakeholders must be understood and managed in order for companies to navigate in the business world. In general terms, a stakeholder is any individual who has an interest in the success or failure of a business. Traditionally, individuals with a vested concern about how the company is run are considered stakeholders. This includes owners, shareholders or members (in the case of limited liability companies or LLCs), and investors in the company.

In addition, employees who depend on the business for their livelihood, suppliers who have entered into agreements with the company and partners who rely on the company to fulfill contractual obligations are looked upon as stakeholders.

However, a stakeholder’s interest in a business need not only be defined monetarily or by ownership shares in a corporation. It can include parties that interact with a company and share common concerns and interests. Thus, religious groups and political parties can be considered stakeholders if the position taken by a company can affect their membership favorably or adversely. This is also true of media companies whose subscribers depend on news about the business to make financial or lifestyle decisions.

Understanding the Complex Role of Stakeholders

Stakeholders hold a pivotal role in shaping the direction of a business. Their influence can be direct or indirect, and understanding the complexities of this relationship is crucial for companies. Stakeholders’ interests often diverge, leading to conflicts or opportunities for collaboration. Internal stakeholders, such as employees and management, are directly involved in day-to-day operations, while external stakeholders, like investors, customers, and regulatory bodies, can influence business decisions without direct involvement. A company's ability to effectively manage both types of stakeholders will often determine its long-term success.

Additionally, stakeholders can sometimes become competitors or allies, depending on how the company positions itself in the market. For instance, a supplier may also be a competitor if they enter a similar product market. Similarly, government regulations can be both a source of support and challenge. Navigating these relationships requires sophisticated stakeholder management strategies, and companies often invest in creating specific roles or departments dedicated to managing these dynamics.

Two Categories of Stakeholders

Stakeholders are essentially divided into two distinct categories: internal and external stakeholders. The amount of influence and the roles they play in the overall accomplishments of the business can vary and change depending on issues ranging from economic conditions to public perceptions of the business.

  • Internal stakeholders are individuals or businesses whose relationship with a business is determined by their existence within the structure of the business.
  • External stakeholders are those with an interest in the operations of a business but do not necessarily have a role in the decisions of the business. They do have the ability to influence the success or failure based on their vested influence and can be every bit as powerful as internal stakeholders.

Identifying Key Stakeholders and Their Interests

In understanding the two categories of stakeholders—internal and external—it’s essential to recognize the diverse interests that each group holds and how those interests can either align or conflict with business goals. Internal stakeholders are typically more invested in the day-to-day workings of the company, and their success is closely tied to the company’s performance. These stakeholders include:

  • Employees: Directly affect company productivity and morale. Their interests often align with job security, fair compensation, and career development.
  • Owners and Shareholders: Hold financial stakes in the company and prioritize growth, profitability, and return on investment.
  • Managers and Executives: Responsible for strategic decision-making and the company’s overall direction. Their interests align with operational efficiency, market competitiveness, and financial stability.

External stakeholders, on the other hand, may not have a direct stake in daily operations but still have significant influence over the company’s success. These include:

  • Customers and Clients: Their satisfaction and loyalty are critical to a company’s market position.
  • Suppliers and Partners: Depend on the company’s stability and are concerned with the reliability of contracts and payment terms.
  • Regulatory Bodies: Ensure the company’s compliance with laws and regulations, impacting how the company operates within its industry.
  • Community and Advocacy Groups: May be concerned with the company’s ethical practices, environmental impact, and corporate social responsibility.

Advantages of Stakeholders

Businesses tend to value stakeholders because of the unique benefits they can bring to the way a company is managed, by the expertise their workforce provides or the ability of individuals to generate capital investments to secure the long-term growth of the business. The two most common advantages include:

  • Business experience. Stakeholders are often individuals that a company hopes to attract who have displayed an ability to successfully manage other businesses or have developed important relationships. Typically, these individuals are found on a company’s board of directors, where they do not necessarily play a role in the day-to-day operations of a business but provide a “big picture” view of things, set plans in order for long-term success, and help the company’s management team avoid costly mistakes.
  • Business acumen. Companies want to attract individuals who can provide guidance when matters get a little sticky. Whereas board members are looking ahead three or five years down the road, sometimes a company needs someone who knows how to deal with a situation happening in the here and now. Perhaps an opportunity arises that could be extremely beneficial to the company but certain matters have to be handled delicately. A level of expertise is required to do this.

Additional Advantages of Stakeholders

Beyond the business experience and acumen already discussed, stakeholders bring several other advantages that can be pivotal for a company’s sustained success:

  1. Access to Capital and Resources: Investors and stakeholders often provide the necessary capital that businesses need for expansion, innovation, or operational needs. Their continued support can be crucial, especially in industries that require large upfront investments.
  2. Strategic Partnerships and Alliances: External stakeholders, particularly suppliers and partners, can offer valuable networking opportunities. A well-established stakeholder base can lead to new business opportunities, market access, and strategic alliances.
  3. Customer Insights and Feedback: Customers, as key external stakeholders, provide direct feedback that can drive product development, improve services, and enhance customer satisfaction.
  4. Brand Advocacy and Reputation Building: Loyal stakeholders often become brand ambassadors. For instance, employees who are advocates of a company’s culture and mission can help strengthen its public image and attract new talent, clients, and investors.
  5. Crisis Management Support: In times of crisis, stakeholders like employees, suppliers, and even local community leaders can lend support, resources, or advice that can mitigate negative impacts on the business.

Disadvantages of Stakeholders

Just as important as stakeholders can be to the success of a business, they can often impact operations for a variety of reasons:

  • Looking out for number one. Perhaps it’s only human nature for people to often place their own interests above those of the business they claim to support. Whenever the issues of money and power intersect, even the best-intentioned individuals can make or force decisions that protect their own pocketbooks or their standing with their own constituents.
  • Standing in the way of progress. People are often wary of change, and in today’s business climate, change is happening at a breathtaking pace. Communication and technological advances are radically affecting relationships between individuals, companies and even countries. For instance, labor and management are often at conflict on key issues, from the impact of globalization on workers’ rights to the effect of automation on jobs traditionally performed by human workers.
  • Fearing Failure. Factors that can contribute to a party interfering with a business’ operation out of a fear that things will not work out is an issue. This is caused by a lack of effective communication in which parties are not kept abreast of developments, creating a lack of control over key decisions, or limiting the responsibilities and power of interests used in exerting a large amount of influence.

Managing stakeholders can be every bit as important to the success of a business as wisely managing its assets. Proactively engaging stakeholders can prevent problems before they occur.

Potential Drawbacks of Stakeholders

While stakeholders play an essential role in a company’s operations, their interests may sometimes conflict, leading to challenges for the business. In addition to the disadvantages already mentioned, other issues include:

  1. Conflicting Priorities and Interests: Different stakeholder groups often have competing priorities. For example, shareholders may prioritize short-term profits, while employees may prioritize job security and better working conditions. This can create friction between management and various groups within the business.
  2. Overbearing Influence: In some cases, certain stakeholders, such as major investors or powerful board members, can exert disproportionate influence over decision-making, potentially undermining the interests of other groups or the company’s broader goals.
  3. Resistance to Innovation: Stakeholders, particularly long-time employees or customers, may resist changes such as product updates, process improvements, or shifts in business strategy. This can delay progress and hinder competitiveness.
  4. Increased Scrutiny and Pressure: External stakeholders, like regulatory bodies and advocacy groups, can impose pressure on a company to adhere to certain ethical or environmental standards. While this can be beneficial, it can also limit the company’s flexibility in decision-making and increase costs related to compliance.

Balancing Stakeholder Influence for Optimal Success

Effective stakeholder management isn’t just about avoiding the disadvantages; it’s about balancing different interests to create value for all parties involved. Businesses that manage stakeholder relationships proactively tend to see more consistent growth and better decision-making outcomes. Engaging in regular communication, setting clear expectations, and involving stakeholders in strategic decision-making can mitigate many of the risks associated with conflicting interests. Moreover, implementing formal stakeholder management processes—such as advisory boards, regular stakeholder meetings, and transparent reporting—can help businesses manage relationships more effectively and keep all stakeholders aligned with the company's overall vision and goals.

FAQ Section

Q1: What is a stakeholder in business?A stakeholder in business is any individual or group with an interest in the company’s success, including employees, investors, suppliers, and even political or community groups.

Q2: What are the main advantages of having stakeholders?Stakeholders bring valuable business experience, capital, resources, and strategic insights. They also provide customer feedback and can support a company in times of crisis.

Q3: How can stakeholder interests conflict in a business?Stakeholder interests may conflict due to differing priorities, such as shareholders seeking short-term profit while employees prioritize job security, or external stakeholders pushing for ethical practices that impact operational flexibility.

Q4: How can a business effectively manage stakeholders?Effective management includes regular communication, setting clear expectations, involving stakeholders in strategic decisions, and using formal stakeholder management processes to ensure alignment.

Q5: Can stakeholders negatively impact a business?Yes, stakeholders can negatively impact a business by exerting too much influence, resisting change, or prioritizing their own interests over the company’s broader goals.

To learn more about the advantages and disadvantages of stakeholders, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.