Key Takeaways:

  • Incorporating an LLC is not the same as forming a corporation; LLCs offer flexibility, while corporations have stricter formalities.
  • Choosing to incorporate an LLC can improve credibility, protect personal assets, and impact tax obligations.
  • Corporations can issue stock to attract investors; LLCs cannot, but they allow more management and ownership flexibility.
  • LLCs have fewer compliance requirements but may face higher self-employment taxes compared to some corporations.
  • The decision between incorporating an LLC or choosing another structure should weigh liability protection, tax treatment, investor needs, and administrative complexity.

Deciding on incorporating an LLC is an important part of setting up your business. Business entities are not one size fits all; you need to decide which business entity works best for your business's strategy and long-term goals.

Some business owners choose to incorporate for the purpose of gaining more legitimacy, while others choose different options for tax reasons. Choosing the business type that works best for your company is necessary to start your business on the right foot.

An Overview of Incorporation

If you choose to incorporate your business, you are converting your business from a sole proprietorship into its own business entity. Incorporation in effect separates the business from its owners and incorporators.

When choosing the original structure of your business, it often falls into one of two categories: limited liability company or corporation. When deciding on which structure works best for your business, you need to assess the advantages and disadvantages of each structure.

Steps to Incorporate an LLC

Incorporating an LLC involves a series of state-specific steps designed to establish the business as a separate legal entity:

  1. Select Your State of Formation: While most businesses choose their home state, some select states with more favorable tax or legal environments.
  2. Choose a Unique Name: The name must comply with state rules and typically must include “LLC” or “Limited Liability Company.”
  3. Designate a Registered Agent: This individual or company will receive legal and tax documents on behalf of your LLC.
  4. File Articles of Organization: This official formation document is submitted to your state’s business filing office, often the Secretary of State.
  5. Create an Operating Agreement: Though not always required, this document outlines the LLC’s management structure, member roles, and decision-making processes.
  6. Obtain an EIN: An Employer Identification Number from the IRS is necessary for tax reporting and opening a business bank account.
  7. Comply with State and Local Requirements: This may include business licenses, permits, and ongoing annual report filings.

Advantages of Incorporation

Some advantages of incorporating your business include:

  • The ability to attract potential investors, as the company is able to offer shares of the company stock.
  • The income splitting that occurs at the corporate level may create an overall lower tax liability.

When Incorporation Might Be Better Than an LLC

Incorporation as a C corporation or S corporation may be more suitable than forming an LLC in certain scenarios:

  • Raising Capital: Corporations can issue multiple classes of stock, making it easier to attract investors and venture capital.
  • Public Trading Potential: A corporate structure is required if you plan to eventually list your company on a stock exchange.
  • Employee Equity Incentives: Corporations can offer stock options and other equity-based benefits, which can be a powerful recruiting tool.
  • Perpetual Existence: Corporations continue to exist beyond the involvement of the original owners, while some LLCs dissolve if a member departs.

Disadvantages of Incorporation

While incorporating has its advantages, the disadvantages a business owner should consider are:

  • A c corporation is subject to double taxation, which occurs once at the corporate level, then a second time at the shareholder level.
  • A corporation must hold annual meetings and record the minutes of those meetings.
  • If electing to structure as an s corporation, you are restricted to only 100 shareholders.

Advantages of Choosing an LLC

LLCs are a good business designation for many reasons, such as the following:

  • Limited liability: LLCs provide business owners with limited liability for business debts by safeguarding owners' personal assets. Owners are only at risk for using the money they have invested in the company.
  • A flexible management structure: A corporation requires a set management structure in which it has directors to oversee major business decisions and officers that take care of the business's day-to-day functions.
  • Pass-through taxation: LLCs can avoid the double taxation that corporations encounter by being taxed at the corporate and shareholder level. In an LLC, taxes pass through the business to the owner's personal tax returns.
  • Ownership flexibility: An LLC has no limit on the number of owners.
  • Less filing requirements: LLCs are not required to hold annual meetings and do not have minute book requirements.
  • Fewer compliance requirements: LLCs require less annual filing requirements as well as minimal formalities to continue to do business. Such requirements include those mandated by the state as well as internal corporate meetings.
  • Better credibility: Forming your company as an LLC provides you with more credibility with your customers than sole proprietorships have because your company has a formal structure.
  • Flexibility with the management structure: LLCs are able to structure its management however its owners see fit. LLCs can choose to be managed by its members or managed by managers.
  • Fewer restrictions: LLCs do not have the restrictions on owners that s corporations require.

Why Some Businesses Incorporate as an LLC Instead of a Corporation

Many business owners choose to incorporate as an LLC instead of forming a corporation because:

  • Lower Administrative Burden: LLCs generally have fewer annual requirements and less paperwork.
  • Flexible Profit Distribution: LLC members can allocate profits and losses in ways that do not directly match ownership percentages, as long as it aligns with the operating agreement.
  • Pass-Through Tax Benefits: LLCs avoid corporate-level taxation, meaning income is reported directly on members’ personal tax returns.
  • Customizable Management: LLCs can be managed by members or appointed managers, offering flexibility not available in the rigid corporate model.
  • Protection from Business Debt: Members’ personal assets are generally shielded from business liabilities.

Disadvantages of an LLC

While there are many advantages to forming your business as an LLC, there are some disadvantages that should be considered before deciding. Some of the disadvantages of an LLC are:

  • You do not have the benefits of income splitting to reduce your tax liability, which is available at the corporate level.
  • An LLC cannot issue stock, so it may have difficulty attracting investors.
  • The formation of your LLC requires filing fees as well as ongoing costs. Fees must be paid when filing your Articles of Organization, and many other states require continued fees, such as annual report fees and franchise taxes.
  • Transferring ownership interest is more difficult in an LLC than it is in a corporation because corporations allow the free transfer of stock. LLCs typically require a set approval process to change ownership or alter the percentage of any owner.
  • Since an LLC is a fairly new kind of business structure, there are fewer legal proceedings and case law to help guide issues with LLCs,

Factors to Consider Before You Incorporate an LLC

While LLCs are popular, certain limitations should be evaluated before deciding to incorporate an LLC:

  • Self-Employment Taxes: In many cases, LLC members must pay self-employment taxes on all earnings.
  • Investor Reluctance: Because an LLC cannot issue stock, some investors may prefer corporations for ease of equity transactions.
  • Varied State Laws: LLC rules and fees differ from state to state, potentially complicating multi-state operations.
  • Conversion Costs: Switching from an LLC to a corporation later to attract investors can involve additional costs and administrative work.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is incorporating an LLC the same as forming a corporation? No. Incorporating an LLC creates a separate legal entity with flexible management and pass-through taxation, while a corporation follows a more rigid structure and can issue stock.

2. Can an LLC be incorporated in any state? Yes, but you should consider your home state’s laws, fees, and tax implications before choosing where to form your LLC.

3. How much does it cost to incorporate an LLC? Costs vary by state and can range from $50 to several hundred dollars, plus potential annual report fees and franchise taxes.

4. Can I convert my LLC into a corporation later? Yes, but conversion can involve legal paperwork, state filings, and potential tax consequences.

5. Do I need an attorney to incorporate an LLC? It’s not legally required, but professional guidance can help ensure compliance with state laws and proper structuring for tax and liability protection.

If you need help with incorporating an LLC, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.