Key Takeaways

  • Actual damages, also known as compensatory damages, are awarded to compensate for proven, quantifiable losses.
  • These damages can include medical expenses, lost wages, and property repair, as well as emotional harm in certain cases.
  • Evidence is critical and includes receipts, bills, pay stubs, and testimony.
  • Emotional distress and loss of companionship may also be factored into actual damages.
  • Actual damages differ from punitive, statutory, liquidated, and nominal damages.
  • Contract disputes and consumer protection violations often involve actual damages.
  • To receive compensation, the injured party must prove the loss was directly caused by the defendant’s actions.

Actual damages refer to the financial amount that is paid to a victim that suffered loss that can be calculated. Actual damages are often known as real damages or, legally, as compensatory damages. These are damages that arose from the neglect or mistake of another party.

Important Components of Actual Damages

Compensatory damages, or damages that are payable, should be measurable and can be proven. A few examples of payable actual damages include:

  • Loss of income
  • Medical expenses
  • Property repairs
  • Business losses
  • Legal fees

It can be difficult to prove actual damages in a family law case. Although some states do allow for actual damages to be recouped when one parent is the cause of measurable loss to the other, specific proof of documentation is required in these cases. The actual damages are only paid out if the judge deems the costs payable by the person who is responsible for the loss. The payout amount will usually not be the requested amount, but instead, the judge will also determine the exact amount of the actual damages occurred.

Actual Damages in Contract and Consumer Law

Actual damages commonly arise in breach of contract and consumer protection cases. In contract disputes, actual damages are awarded to place the injured party in the position they would have been in had the contract been properly performed. This may include compensation for costs incurred due to delays, defective performance, or failure to deliver goods or services.

In consumer law, actual damages are often pursued under statutes like the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA), and Electronic Fund Transfer Act (EFTA). For example, if a consumer’s credit score is damaged due to a reporting error, actual damages may include costs associated with higher interest rates or denied credit applications.

Evidence Needed for Actual Damages

Actual damages that are paid out are often easily provable. The following types of evidence are acceptable as documentation:

  • Receipts for medical care received
  • Receipts of hospital visits
  • Receipts of medical equipment purchased
  • Receipts for equipment repairs
  • Receipts for vehicle repairs
  • Bills for intended repairs
  • Bills for expected medical procedures
  • Paycheck stubs for loss of income
  • Receipts for needed in-home medical care
  • Receipts for home services required due to an injury

Every damage case is unique, so it is important that the plaintiff provide the type of measurable documentation that best supports their individual legal case. Documentation that works for one case may not be ideal for another one.

Burden of Proof for Actual Damages

To successfully claim actual damages, the plaintiff must show:

  • Causation: The defendant’s actions directly caused the loss.
  • Certainty: The damages are not speculative; they are measurable.
  • Mitigation: The plaintiff took reasonable steps to minimize the damage.

Courts typically reject claims based on estimated or uncertain losses. Supporting documentation and testimony help establish credibility and the extent of the actual damages incurred.

Actual Damages for Pain and Suffering

The amount of pain and suffering incurred is also considered a payable damage. These are often known as hedonic damages, and they include pain and suffering in terms of emotional and mental health. This amount can be difficult to calculate in measurable terms. However, the following pieces of evidence can be used to prove evidence of pain and suffering:

  • Testimony of the plaintiff
  • Testimony of the plaintiff's family and friends
  • A medical physician's or therapist's testimony

Pain and suffering damages are often based on a person's difficult to adapt to everyday life after a serious injury. Actual damages in terms of pain and suffering might also include damages paid to the plaintiff's family members.

  • Loss of consortium: This occurs when the spouse also suffers from the injury of the plaintiff. This might include emotional and physical intimacy, loss of assistance around the house and with childcare duties, and a loss of emotional guidance.
  • Loss of guidance and care: This occurs when children suffer from the injury or death of a parent or their primary caregiver. This might include the emotional loss of losing the care of a parent or caregiver or the actual parenting duties the parent can no longer perform.

Limits and Caps on Actual Damages

Some jurisdictions place statutory limits on the amount of actual damages that can be awarded, especially in personal injury or medical malpractice cases. These limits can vary significantly by state and type of claim. However, actual damages generally remain uncapped when they are tied to economic losses with clear documentation.

It's important to consult an attorney familiar with local laws to understand the potential limitations on compensation in your jurisdiction.

Other Types of Damages

It is important to keep in mind that actual damages are not punitive, nominal, or statutory damages. It is possible that a legal case could include compensation from all components of these payable areas. 

  • Punitive damages: Punitive damages, in comparison to actual damages, are a form of a legal consequence. They are damages that are ordered to the defendant in an attempt to punish them for their damaging behavior and to prevent it from occurring again in the future.
  • Statutory damages: Statutory damages are set by law and are standard payments set for injury, loss, or a civil violation. These pre-set damage amounts can speed up the legal process and are a great option when a plaintiff does not have a ton of provable documentation. They are common in cases of intellectual or copyright law, violations of public policy, and in cases of tax evasion.
  • Nominal damages: Nominal damages are minimal compensatory payments that are paid when there were no significant injuries sustained. Nominal damages place the legal blame on the defendant and recognize that although no real harm was done,  property damage or injury was possible.

Comparison: Actual vs. Liquidated and Consequential Damages

In addition to punitive and nominal damages, two other related types include:

  • Liquidated Damages: Pre-agreed amounts stated in a contract, intended to estimate losses in advance. They are enforceable when actual damages are difficult to calculate and the amount is reasonable.
  • Consequential Damages: Also known as special damages, these cover indirect losses that result from a breach but are not a direct result of it (e.g., lost profits due to delayed equipment delivery).

Unlike actual damages, which are direct and measurable, consequential and liquidated damages deal with more indirect or pre-estimated losses.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What are actual damages?
    Actual damages are compensation awarded to cover real, measurable losses caused by another party’s actions, such as medical bills or lost income.
  2. Can emotional distress be considered actual damages?
    Yes, in some cases, emotional distress—often referred to as pain and suffering—can be included under actual damages if supported by sufficient evidence.
  3. How do actual damages differ from punitive damages?
    Actual damages aim to compensate the victim, while punitive damages are intended to punish the wrongdoer and deter similar behavior.
  4. Are actual damages capped by law?
    In certain cases like medical malpractice, some states impose caps on actual damages, particularly for non-economic losses such as emotional harm.
  5. What is required to prove actual damages in court?
    You need documentation like receipts, invoices, testimony, and other evidence to show the extent and cause of the loss.

If you need help with actual damages, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.