Key Takeaways

  • Liquidated damages are pre-agreed amounts in a contract to compensate for specific breaches, often used when calculating actual damages is difficult.
  • These provisions are common in industries like construction and real estate, where delays or breaches can cause significant but hard-to-quantify losses.
  • For enforceability, the amount must be a reasonable forecast of potential loss at the time of contracting, not a penalty.
  • Benefits include predictability, reduced litigation, and mutual clarity on breach consequences.
  • Real-world liquidated damages examples often involve daily monetary charges for late completion of projects, but can also include non-cash remedies like additional shares in corporate agreements.
  • Courts assess reasonableness based on contract formation circumstances, not on losses calculated after the breach.

A liquidated damages example would be a contractor that failed to complete a construction project on time and is charged daily until the project has been finished.

Basics of Liquidated Damages

Liquidated damages are a type of monetary compensation that is provided to an injured party when a contract has been breached. Contracts include liquidated damages in order to cover losses that result from a contract being broken. The amount of the damages will be listed specifically in the contract in most cases, although this is not a strict requirement. If no amount is listed in the contract, the court will decide what level of damages to award.

While liquidated damages can be used in most types of contracts, they are most commonly found in real estate contracts. The reason these damages are used for real estate is that calculating exact losses can be very difficult with these contracts.

Both parties listed in a contract can be protected by liquidated damages, although it may not seem that way at first glance. For example, one party will know the exact amount of money that they will be required to pay if they break the contract and the party that receives the damages will be able to recover their losses without the need to file a costly lawsuit. However, it's important that these damages are not being used to punish the breaching party, as this would make them invalid.

Common Situations Where Liquidated Damages Apply

Liquidated damages are widely used in contracts where breaches can lead to complex or intangible losses. Some common scenarios include:

  • Construction projects: Delays in completing work can cause ripple effects for owners, lenders, and tenants. A liquidated damages clause may specify a daily rate for every day past the agreed completion date.
  • Real estate transactions: If a buyer fails to close on time, the seller may be entitled to keep the buyer’s earnest money deposit as liquidated damages.
  • Service agreements: For example, if a software provider misses a key delivery date, they might owe the client a set fee for each day the system remains unavailable.
  • Manufacturing contracts: A supplier delivering critical components late might owe the buyer an agreed sum per day to cover downtime costs.

Including such provisions helps avoid disputes about the exact amount of harm suffered, provided the agreed amount is a reasonable pre-estimate of likely loss.

Clauses for Liquidated Damages

The liquidated damages clause should be used to define the precise amount of money that will be provided to the party that is harmed by a broken contract.

While these clauses are mostly beneficial, the drawback is that they may not be enforceable depending on how they were written. For example, if the amount listed in the clause is unreasonably high, meaning it doesn't reflect actual losses, courts will refuse to impose the damages. The reason for this is that the damages are acting as a penalty instead of being compensatory. For a liquidated damages clause to be enforced, it must fulfill two requirements. Should the clause fail to meet these criteria, or if there is no clause in place, courts will reserve the right to determine the amount of damages.

When courts are trying to decide if the liquidated damages are reasonable, courts will examine the circumstances when the contract was written as opposed to the circumstances when the breach occurred. If it is decided that the estimated losses were not reasonable, the damages won't be enforced.

Key Elements of an Enforceable Liquidated Damages Clause

To increase the likelihood that a liquidated damages clause will be upheld, contracts typically include:

  1. Clear definition of the triggering event – Specify the exact breach that will result in liquidated damages, such as late delivery, failure to meet quality standards, or missed project milestones.
  2. Reasonable estimate of potential loss – The amount should reflect a genuine pre-estimate of likely damages at the time of contract formation. Excessive amounts risk being deemed penalties.
  3. No punitive intent – The clause should be compensatory in nature, not designed to punish the breaching party.
  4. Mutual agreement – Both parties should acknowledge that actual damages would be difficult to calculate and that the agreed amount is a fair substitute.

Courts often evaluate whether the clause was negotiated fairly and whether it aligns with industry norms

Liquidated Damages Benefits

Predictability is the biggest advantage of a liquidated damages clause. One property knows that they will be shielded from losses if the contract is broken. Liquidated damages also allow for each party to calculate the value that they can receive from fulfilling their duties versus the losses they would incur from breaching the contract.

Another benefit is that the injured party would not need to prove actual damages like they would during a lawsuit. The parties can negotiate damages until an amount is decided that both believe is fair.

Real-World Liquidated Damages Examples

  • Construction delay: A contract specifies that if a contractor fails to finish a building by October 1, they must pay $5,000 for each day of delay until completion. This helps the property owner cover lost rental income or other related costs.
  • Event venue cancellation: If an event organizer cancels within 30 days of the scheduled date, they forfeit their deposit, which serves as liquidated damages to the venue for lost booking opportunities.
  • Corporate agreements: In certain partnership or securities agreements, if a company fails to meet filing deadlines with regulators, it may owe liquidated damages in the form of additional stock units rather than cash.

These examples illustrate that liquidated damages can be monetary or non-monetary, provided they meet legal enforceability standards.

Definitions that You Should Know

For those inexperienced with contracts and liquidated damages clauses, it's important to define a few of the most basic terms that you may encounter when negotiating a contract.

One of the most important terms to understand is actual damages. These damages are monetary compensation awarded when someone suffers a loss. These losses can be in the form of money or property. Actual damages are also commonly referred to as compensatory damages. To receive actual damages, you, the plaintiff in a lawsuit will need to prove that you have suffered a:

  • Loss.
  • Injury.
  • Harm.

It's also important that you understand what a contract is and how it functions. At its essences, a contract is an agreement between two parties. Once this agreement is established, the parties will be legally bound. Usually, contracts are entered into for the purpose of exchanging a good or service for something of value, usually money. For example, you might agree to pay a contractor a certain amount for them to build you a home.

When the parties in a contract have a dispute, it will often end in a court case. The ultimate decision in a court case is known as a summary judgment. These judgments are often issued without a full trial taking place.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is a simple liquidated damages example?

A common example is a construction contract that charges a contractor $2,000 for each day a project is delayed past the completion date.

2. Can liquidated damages be non-monetary?

Yes. Some contracts allow for in-kind payments, such as additional shares in a company, if cash payment would breach financial covenants.

3. Are liquidated damages always enforceable?

No. Courts will not enforce them if they are deemed punitive or grossly disproportionate to the anticipated harm.

4. How do courts decide if the amount is reasonable?

They assess the estimate based on information available when the contract was signed, not after the breach.

5. Why use liquidated damages instead of actual damages?

They provide predictability, save time and legal costs, and help avoid disputes over proving the exact amount of loss.

If you need help understanding a liquidated damages example, you can post your legal needs on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.