Key Takeaways

  • Choosing corporation or LLC: which is better depends on your business’s goals, growth plans, tax preferences, and ownership structure.
  • Corporations offer strong fundraising potential, perpetual existence, and easier transfer of ownership but require stricter compliance and may face double taxation.
  • LLCs provide management flexibility, pass-through taxation, and fewer formalities but can be less attractive to investors and harder to transfer ownership.
  • Governance and compliance requirements are significantly different: corporations must follow strict bylaws, board meetings, and shareholder votes, while LLCs operate through flexible operating agreements.
  • Long-term plans—like going public, issuing stock, or attracting venture capital—often make a corporation the better choice, while LLCs are often ideal for smaller businesses or those prioritizing simplicity and tax efficiency.

To ask which is better – LLC or Corporation – is a common question for new business owners. There are many advantages and some potential disadvantages to operating both types of business structures, and depending on the short and long-term goals you have for your business, one type of business might be a better fit than the other.

Corporation: An Overview

The owners in a corporation are referred to as shareholders. Corporations issue shares to the shareholders, who each own a portion of the business. For example, if the corporation sells 1,000 shares and you own half of the business, you will own 500 shares. The transfer of shares is rather easy and straightforward, as no formal paperwork is needed for transferring shares to another. While there is no paperwork required for the transfer of stocks, there is greater paperwork required when forming a corporation, particularly when it comes to corporate formalities and ongoing requirements. With that said, there are several benefits to operating a corporation, including the ability to expand your business by issuing stock to outside investors.

Governance and Structure of Corporations

Corporations follow a more rigid and hierarchical governance model compared to LLCs. They are managed by a board of directors, elected by shareholders, which oversees major decisions and appoints officers (like a CEO or CFO) to handle day-to-day operations. Corporate bylaws govern how meetings are conducted, how votes occur, and how new shares are issued.

This structure provides predictability and accountability, making corporations attractive for businesses seeking significant investment or preparing for an eventual IPO. However, it also introduces additional compliance requirements—such as annual shareholder meetings, board resolutions, and formal record-keeping—that can be time-consuming and costly for smaller operations.

LLC: An Overview

The owners in an LLC (Limited Liability Company) are referred to as members. Each member will own a portion of the business, known as membership interest. Unlike corporate shares, there are generally greater restrictions on the transfer of membership interest. Some states have laws providing that absent an Operating Agreement, any member who wants to sell his or her membership interest will automatically cause termination of the LLC. However, most LLC members do in fact draft an Operating Agreement to set forth the rules and procedures for how membership interest can be transferred without dissolution of the company. However, while there are transfer restrictions in an LLC, there is great flexibility in its management structure, and it provides many other benefits for its members.

Governance and Structure of LLCs

Unlike corporations, LLCs are not required to have a board of directors or formal officer roles. Members can directly manage the company (member-managed) or appoint managers (manager-managed) based on the terms of the operating agreement, which serves as the internal governance document. This agreement can outline voting rights, profit-sharing, management duties, and procedures for admitting new members.

This flexibility allows LLCs to adapt to the preferences of their owners, making them ideal for closely held businesses or professional practices. However, it also means fewer legal guardrails and less predictability for investors, which can be a drawback for companies seeking outside capital.

LLC Advantages

The LLC business structure offers many benefits to members. Some of the benefits include:

  1. Flexibility in management
  2. Pass-through taxation
  3. Few record keeping requirements
  4. Limited liability protection

The LLC offers great flexibility for members in terms of how they choose to manage the business. The members can choose to manage the LLC on their own (member-managed LLC) or hire someone else to oversee the business operations (manager-managed LLC). The members might also choose another member to manage the business. If the LLC members choose to hire a manager, they will no longer have total authority over the daily operations of the business. Rather, they will continue to have voting powers along with the control over significant business decisions.

The LLC operates as a pass-through tax entity, meaning that all of the LLC’s profits are passed onto the members who then report it on their personal income tax returns. This means that the LLC doesn’t pay corporate income tax.

The LLC also has very little record keeping requirements. Unlike the corporation, the LLC doesn’t require periodic meetings nor are there any legal requirements that the LLC keep meeting minutes of meetings that do in fact occur among members.

The LLC, along with corporations, provides limited liability protection for its members. Therefore, a plaintiff or creditor cannot go after the member’s personal assets in order to satisfy any outstanding debt of the business. Keep in mind, however, that exceptions do exist. For example, if a member engages in fraudulent activity or otherwise does something illegal that would cause harm to the business or a third party, then the member will be held personally liable. Furthermore, if a member personally guarantees a loan or holds the business out as his or her own, then personal liability could occur.

Disadvantages of an LLC

While LLCs offer many benefits, they also come with limitations that could affect growth and financing potential:

  • Investor appeal: Venture capitalists and institutional investors often prefer corporations because of their standardized share structure and clear governance.
  • Self-employment taxes: Members typically pay self-employment tax on all profits, which can be more expensive than shareholder dividends in a corporation.
  • Complexity in multi-state operations: Expanding an LLC across state lines can involve registering as a “foreign LLC” and meeting additional compliance requirements.
  • Transfer restrictions: Selling membership interests can be complicated and may require the consent of other members, unlike the straightforward transfer of corporate shares.

Advantages of a Corporation

There are also many advantages to operating a corporation, some of which overlap with the benefits offered by an LLC. The overall advantages to operating a corporation include:

  1. Simple transferability of shares
  2. Perpetual life
  3. Ability to obtain capital by issuing shares
  4. Limited liability protection

Shareholders can easily transfer their shares to others. Furthermore, the corporation, unlike the LLC, has a perpetual life as the transfer of shares doesn’t cause a dissolution of the business. In fact, the corporation could have an endless existence.

Since the corporation can issue shares, it can more easily obtain capital by selling shares to outside investors. And as previously noted, the corporation just like the LLC, offers limited liability protection to its shareholders.

Key Considerations When Choosing Between an LLC and Corporation

When deciding corporation or LLC: which is better, evaluate your short- and long-term business goals:

  • Growth plans: If you intend to seek investors, go public, or issue stock options to employees, a corporation is often the better choice.
  • Tax preferences: If you prefer pass-through taxation and want to avoid double taxation, an LLC may be more tax-efficient.
  • Control and flexibility: LLCs offer looser management structures, while corporations provide structured governance and investor confidence.
  • Succession and continuity: Corporations offer perpetual existence, whereas LLCs may dissolve upon changes in membership unless otherwise stated in the operating agreement.

Your choice should align with where you see your business in 5, 10, or 20 years. Many companies even start as LLCs for tax simplicity and later convert to corporations as they grow.

Disadvantages of a Corporation

Despite their advantages, corporations also present certain challenges that may make them less appealing to smaller businesses:

  • Double taxation: Profits are taxed at the corporate level and again when distributed as dividends to shareholders (unless structured as an S corporation).
  • Higher compliance costs: Annual reports, shareholder meetings, and detailed record-keeping can be costly and time-consuming.
  • Rigid structure: The formal board and officer system, while providing oversight, can limit flexibility for owner-operators.
  • Complex dissolution: Winding down a corporation is often more complicated and legally intensive than dissolving an LLC.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Is an LLC or a corporation better for small businesses?
    For small businesses seeking simplicity, pass-through taxation, and flexibility, LLCs are often better. Corporations may be ideal if you plan to raise significant capital or eventually go public.
  2. Can an LLC become a corporation later?
    Yes. Many businesses start as LLCs and convert to corporations when they need to issue stock or attract venture capital.
  3. Which is more tax-efficient: an LLC or a corporation?
    LLCs offer pass-through taxation, avoiding double taxation. Corporations may offer tax benefits for retained earnings and reinvestment, particularly under the C corporation structure.
  4. Are corporations better for attracting investors?
    Generally, yes. Investors prefer corporations because of their standardized share structures, governance, and ability to issue stock.
  5. Which business type offers better liability protection?
    Both LLCs and corporations provide limited liability protection, shielding owners’ personal assets from business debts and claims.

If you need help choosing between an LLC or Corporation, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5-percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law, and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.