Key Takeaways

  • LLCs do not have shareholders or issue stock; instead, they have members who own membership interests.
  • Members in an LLC can be individuals or entities, and LLCs can be owned by a single member or multiple members.
  • Unlike corporations, LLCs offer flexible management and profit distribution not based on ownership percentage.
  • LLCs can raise capital through membership interests, loans, or bond issuance, but not through selling shares.
  • LLC operating agreements govern ownership structure, voting rights, and decision-making processes.

Does an LLC Have Shareholders

Does an LLC have shareholders? The short answer to this question is no. However, before you make any decisions regarding whether to file an LLC (Limited Liability Company) or corporation, you should know of the differences between shareholders in a corporation and members in an LLC.

LLCs generally don’t have shareholders, officers, or directors. Rather, the owners of the LLC, also referred to as members, oversee the daily operations of the business. Furthermore, an LLC does not have stock for this same reason.

LLC Ownership Structure

Instead of shareholders, an LLC is owned by one or more members. Members can include individuals, corporations, or even other LLCs. The number of members is not limited, and ownership can be as simple as a single-member LLC or more complex with multiple members involved.

LLC members own a percentage of the business, often referred to as a "membership interest." This interest determines their share of profits, losses, and sometimes voting rights—though these rights can also be defined differently in the LLC’s operating agreement, making LLCs extremely flexible entities.

Unlike corporations that rely on shares of stock to denote ownership, an LLC does not issue stock certificates. Therefore, there are no "LLC shareholders" in the traditional sense.

How LLCs Raise Capital Without Shares

Although LLCs cannot issue stock, they have several alternative ways to raise capital:

  • Issuing membership interests: Members can buy into the company in exchange for a percentage of ownership.
  • Contributions from existing members: Current members may invest additional capital for expansion or operations.
  • Loans: LLCs can take on business loans or accept loans from members.
  • Bond issuance: As previously noted, LLCs can issue bonds as a form of debt financing.

These approaches provide flexibility while maintaining the LLC’s structural integrity.

Benefits of an LLC

Although an LLC doesn’t have shareholders nor do they issue stock, there are still many benefits to operating an LLC, including the following:

• Pass-through taxation

• Limited liability for members

• Issuance of bonds

While the LLC offers limited liability for its members, there is a greater possibility of piercing the corporate veil for members in an LLC as opposed to shareholders in a corporation. This means that if a lawsuit is brought against the LLC for allegations of fraud, the plaintiff can pierce the corporate veil and hold the member(s) personally liable.  

While an LLC cannot issue stock, it can issue bonds to non-members of employees of the company. Bonds are considered a debt instrument that helps an LLC raise capital to expand and grow.

Are There Ever LLC Shareholders?

In legal and practical terms, LLCs never have shareholders. However, some confusion arises when an LLC elects to be taxed as an S corporation or a C corporation. Even in these scenarios, the LLC structure remains intact and the owners are still called members—not shareholders. The taxation election only affects how the business is taxed, not how ownership is structured.

Some LLCs may refer to members informally as shareholders when communicating with outside parties or investors, but this terminology is not legally accurate.

Differences Between a Shareholder and Member

While both shareholders and members have ownership interest in their respective businesses, there are many differences between these two types of ownership, particularly with regard to the following:

• Rights to manage the business

• Rights to transfer ownership interest

• Repayment to creditors

• Profit distribution

In addition to the difference in ownership, it is evident that LLCs and corporations operate differently, especially when it comes to tax treatment.

Business Management

The management of an LLC is setup in the company’s operating agreement, and must be agreed upon by all members of the business. The agreement will specify how the LLC will be managed, and what roles and responsibilities each member will have. This document will also lay out the decision-making process for transfer of ownership rights, what happens when a member dies or goes bankrupt, how to dissolve the business, and the voting rights of each member.

The management structure of a corporation, however, is more formal and controlled by state statute. The owners of the corporation are shareholders who receive stock certificates. These shareholders then choose a board of directors on a yearly basis. These directors will set rules and decision-making processes for the corporation. The board of directors will also obtain additional officers as needed. Therefore, while the board of directors comes up with the management structure, it is the officers who oversee the daily operations of the business.

Transfer of Ownership

In a corporation, each owner (shareholder) has an equal percentage of ownership, along with equivalent voting powers. LLC members, however, can have disproportionate ownership interests, depending on how much money each member contributes to the LLC.

In terms of the right to transfer ownership, C corporations can issue shares to different stock classes. Keep in mind that C corporation profits are taxed at the corporate and shareholders level (double taxation), therefore, small businesses usually choose to operate either an LLC or S corporation. S corporations can only issue one class of stock, with no more than 100 shares being given out. This means that the S corporations number of shareholders is limited since there are so few shares.

LLCs have no limit on the number of members – and the ownership of each member can be entirely different from another member. For example, one member might have 5% ownership in the LLC, whereas another member could have 45% ownership in the LLC. With that said, the member with 5% ownership could have more rights and responsibilities than the member with 45% ownership. This is all laid out in the LLC operating agreement.

LLC Ownership Interests vs. Corporate Stock

The distinction between LLC membership interests and corporate stock is crucial for understanding ownership rights:

  • Transferability: Corporate stock is generally freely transferable unless restricted by a shareholders’ agreement. LLC interests typically require the approval of other members for transfer, depending on the operating agreement.
  • Valuation: Stock has a market-driven value in public companies. LLC interests are often harder to value and may require a formal appraisal.
  • Formal recognition: Shares are issued with stock certificates and recorded in a shareholder registry. LLCs use their operating agreement and member ledger to track ownership.

This distinction means that while LLCs can be just as valuable and complex as corporations, the nature of ownership and control is fundamentally different.

Repayment to Creditors

Creditors can take all shares that are given out in an S corporation. For this reason, if a creditor takes enough shares in the S corp, the creditor could now have an ownership stake in the business. However, creditors of an LLC can only take the charging order, meaning that a creditor can take no more than what the LLC member invested into the company.

Profit Distribution

The LLC operating agreement can indicate that interest in profits can only be distributed to certain members. However, S corp profits are distributed based on the number of shares each shareholder has. Keep in mind that the income earned by LLC members must be included on their personal tax returns as self-employment taxes.

LLC Member vs. Shareholder Tax Considerations

While shareholders of a corporation may receive dividends and file taxes based on investment income, LLC members are subject to pass-through taxation by default. This means:

  • Income is reported on the members’ personal tax returns.
  • Members pay self-employment taxes on profits unless the LLC is taxed as a corporation.
  • Members cannot avoid taxation on profits retained within the business, as shareholders in a corporation might if dividends are not distributed.

This structure offers simplicity but can lead to higher tax burdens for members depending on the LLC’s profitability and the member’s personal income level.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can an LLC issue stock like a corporation? No, LLCs cannot issue stock. They are owned by members with membership interests rather than shareholders with stock.

2. Is it possible to become a shareholder in an LLC? No, LLCs do not have shareholders. You can become a member by obtaining a membership interest, which functions differently from stock ownership.

3. How do LLCs raise money if they can’t issue shares? LLCs can raise capital through membership investments, loans, or by issuing bonds. They do not sell stock to raise funds.

4. What happens if an LLC elects to be taxed as a corporation? Even with a corporate tax election (S corp or C corp), the LLC still has members—not shareholders. The change only affects taxation.

5. Can an LLC convert into a corporation with shareholders? Yes, an LLC can convert to a corporation if desired. This requires legal steps and may include drafting corporate bylaws and issuing stock.

If you need help forming your LLC or corporation, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5-percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law, and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with, or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.