Key Takeaways

  • Prelitigation refers to the early phase of a dispute before a lawsuit is filed, focusing on investigation, communication, and resolution.
  • It involves formal notice, evidence gathering, demands, and attempts to settle outside of court.
  • The process helps parties avoid the time, cost, and stress of litigation.
  • Key steps include notification, investigation, demand letters, negotiation, and possibly mediation.
  • Prelitigation often applies to personal injury, insurance, business, and employment disputes.
  • Outcomes from prelitigation can affect the direction and strength of a future legal case.

What does pre-litigation mean? To someone involved in a lawsuit, it means the opportunity to have a formal process involving several steps prior to litigation. The process opens opportunities for the dispute to be settled with the help of an attorney without the need to go to court.

About the Pre-Litigation Process

Proceedings

During pre-litigation proceedings, an outline detailing the case is presented to a panel for review. Information will also include relevant testimony and evidence. Questions will be asked by the panel of the parties involved who will be required to answer in a non-confrontational or emotional manner.

Process

The pre-litigation process also includes mediation, which is in place to save time and money for everyone involved. Some courts have a mediation department while in other courts, the judge may refer both parties to speak with a mediator. During mediation, an unbiased third party mediates between the plaintiff and the defendant to help resolve the dispute and come to a resolution.

Hearing

When a pre-litigation hearing takes place, many people are involved. This begins with the plaintiff contacting a lawyer. The lawyer, in turn, works with their personnel, such as expert witnesses and investigators. During the hearing, people who may be called on to testify include:

  • Police officers.
  • Insurance Adjusters.
  • Emergency workers.
  • Medical workers.
  • Hospital workers.
  • Physicians.
  • Therapists.

Benefits

Two main benefits of pre-litigation are financial savings and privacy for the parties involved. Speaking with a third party ensures confidentiality. The types of cases that benefit the most are those involving insurance, employment, business disputes, and various civil disagreements.

From a financial standpoint, pre-litigation saves money on direct costs, such as expert witnesses, legal fees, and hours lost at work. Another benefit is that pre-litigation may allow a quicker resolution to a dispute versus spending an extended period in courts, resulting in less stress for the parties involved.

The pre-litigation process follows these steps:

  1. The attorney sends a formal letter.
  2. There is an investigation into the allegations.
  3. A demand is made.
  4. Attempts to settle the dispute are the final step before taking the issue to court.

Formal Notification

When a dispute arises between parties, the first step taken by an attorney in the pre-litigation process is sending a formal notification. This is usually in the form of a letter with notification going to the other party's lawyer and their insurance company.

The notice clearly outlines the "what" and "why" details of the dispute. The lawyer may also request related information. The pre-litigation letter is the standard protocol for initiating the first step in informing the other party's attorney prior to starting an investigation.

Investigation

Prior to taking a case to court, a civil dispute attorney must have all the pertinent facts relating to the case. All required and important information is gathered during the pre-litigation investigation process. The type of information includes copies of insurance claims, employment records, medical records, and any other type of record necessary for the case. This is also the time an attorney will speak with witnesses and take statements.

Demand

Upon completion of the investigation, the attorney for the injured party will send a formal pre-litigation demand, which can be sent in alternate ways. One type of formal demand can be in the form of a claim sent directly to the other party's insurance company.

A second option is sending a formal demand letter for compensation for the injury party. This is sent directly to the other party. The pre-litigation demand can be in simple letter form or it can be a multi-page document that contains copies of the information gathered during the investigation process.

Settlement Attempt

When a formal demand is made, it usually results in an opportunity for the civil dispute to be settled prior to going to court. Disputing settlements is an informal process with discussions between the attorneys for both parties, the client, and an insurance representative.

During the informal discussion, one party may make a counteroffer, make a settlement offer, or reject the settlement. If a more formal discussion is necessary, third-party mediation comes into the picture to help negotiate a settlement before the dispute goes to litigation.

What Is the Prelitigation Phase?

The prelitigation phase is the time period where parties try to resolve a dispute before filing a formal lawsuit. This stage is especially common in civil and personal injury cases, where resolving the issue early can save both time and legal expenses. The prelitigation meaning extends to all the actions taken by attorneys and clients to investigate claims, communicate positions, and attempt settlement before initiating formal litigation.

Common Disputes Handled in Prelitigation

Prelitigation is used across a variety of legal disputes, including:

  • Personal Injury Claims: Including auto accidents, slip and falls, and medical malpractice.
  • Business Disputes: Breach of contract, partnership conflicts, and vendor disagreements.
  • Employment Matters: Wage disputes, wrongful termination, and harassment claims.
  • Insurance Claims: When insurers deny or undervalue valid claims.
  • Construction or Real Estate Disputes: Including non-performance or defective work.

By addressing issues early, these disputes may be resolved more efficiently without proceeding to court

Role of Attorneys During Prelitigation

Attorneys play a critical role in the prelitigation phase by:

  • Evaluating legal merits and potential liabilities.
  • Drafting and sending formal notices and demand letters.
  • Collecting documentation and evidence to support their client's position.
  • Engaging in negotiation or mediation with opposing counsel.
  • Advising clients on potential outcomes and next steps if litigation becomes necessary.

A well-prepared attorney may even be able to secure favorable outcomes without filing a complaint in court.

What Happens If Prelitigation Fails?

If the parties cannot reach a settlement during the prelitigation phase, the plaintiff may proceed to file a formal complaint in civil court. However, the groundwork laid during prelitigation—such as document collection, witness statements, and communications—will serve as a foundation for the litigation process. In fact, a strong prelitigation effort often positions a case favorably once it reaches trial or further legal proceedings.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What does prelitigation mean in simple terms?Prelitigation is the stage before a lawsuit where parties attempt to resolve a dispute through communication, investigation, and negotiation.

2. Is prelitigation required before filing a lawsuit?Not always, but in some jurisdictions or case types (like medical malpractice), it's a required step before litigation can begin.

3. How long does prelitigation last?It depends on the complexity of the dispute, but it can range from a few weeks to several months depending on the willingness to cooperate and settle.

4. Can I resolve a case without going to court during prelitigation?Yes. Many disputes are settled during prelitigation, especially when both parties prefer a quicker, less costly outcome.

5. What role does mediation play in prelitigation?Mediation involves a neutral third party helping the parties reach a voluntary settlement and is often used in prelitigation to avoid court proceedings.

If you need help with what does pre-litigation mean, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.