Key Takeaways:

  • Failure to comply with a mediation agreement can result in legal consequences, including breach of contract claims.
  • Mediation agreements can be legally binding if incorporated into a court order.
  • If a party does not comply, enforcement options include filing a lawsuit, seeking contempt of court, or requesting a court order.
  • Mediation may still be attempted again if initial compliance fails.
  • Alternative dispute resolution (ADR) methods, such as arbitration, may be pursued if mediation fails.
  • Seeking legal assistance ensures that agreements are properly enforced and that parties understand their rights and obligations.

Failure to Comply with Mediation Agreement

The failure to comply with mediation agreement can have a lot of ramifications for all parties involved. The goal of mediation is to reach an agreement in a dispute rather than going through a court trial. It can be a less expensive and faster option than going to court if you can amicably work with a mediator. If you cannot reach an agreement, or if you fail to comply with the agreement, it is important to know what steps to take next.

Legal Consequences of Failing to Comply with a Mediation Agreement

When one party fails to comply with a mediation agreement, the consequences can vary depending on the nature of the agreement and whether it is legally binding. Key potential consequences include:

  • Breach of Contract – If the mediation agreement was signed and included enforceable terms, non-compliance could be treated as a breach of contract, allowing the aggrieved party to seek legal remedies.
  • Court Enforcement – If the agreement was incorporated into a court order, the court may enforce the agreement and impose penalties for non-compliance.
  • Financial Penalties – The non-complying party may be required to pay damages to the other party, particularly if financial losses resulted from the failure to adhere to the agreement.
  • Contempt of Court – If the agreement was court-ordered, a judge may hold the non-compliant party in contempt, leading to fines or even jail time in extreme cases.
  • Reputational Damage – Non-compliance with a mediation agreement can harm an individual’s or business’s reputation, especially in professional or business disputes.

What is Mediation?

Mediation is a type of alternative resolution that parties can use to help resolve disputes instead of going through the court system. The mediation process is a private set of meetings that is confidential to those involved. Both the parties involved and their respective attorneys are assisted by a neutral third party to help develop a mutually acceptable agreement.

What if You Can't Agree During Mediation?

Mediation is a process, not an outcome. The point of mediation is to assist everyone involved to come to an agreement via open communication. If the parties cannot come to a solution through mediation, it does not necessarily mean the mediation failed. Many issues can be solved throughout the process, even if the mediation did not result in a final decision.

If the parties involved cannot come to a settlement in mediation, they would then need to go through an evaluative approach. During this time, the mediator will act in the role of a fictitious courtroom. He or she will consider all the evidence that would be presented had the issue gone to court.

What if We Can't Come to a Final Agreement Through Mediation?

There are three options you have if you cannot reach an agreement via mediation:

  1. Go to court for a trial. If you fail to make progress through mediation, you can take your issue to court for the judge to decide. This route does not mean the mediation was not successful, as smaller issues could have been resolved as the process moved along.
  2. Try mediation a second time. You can begin a new mediation if you want to try the process again. You can choose a different mediator if you think the current mediator was not helpful.
  3. You can continue to negotiate on your own. If mediation did not yield an agreement, you can continue to work on your own to reach a settlement.

Can We Still Go to Court if Mediation Fails?

If you cannot reach an agreement through mediation, you can still go to court to resolve your dispute. You do not give up your right to go through litigation if you want to try mediation first. However, it can be a lot more costly since you will be paying for both mediation and litigation.

The dispute resolution will also take longer because you will lose control of your dispute once you take it to court.

Alternatives to Court if Mediation Fails

If mediation does not result in an enforceable agreement or if a party fails to comply, there are alternative dispute resolution (ADR) methods to consider before proceeding to litigation:

  • Arbitration – A neutral arbitrator can issue a binding decision, often making it a faster and less expensive alternative to litigation.
  • Settlement Conferences – Some courts offer facilitated negotiations between parties before a case proceeds to trial.
  • Private Settlement Agreements – The parties may negotiate a new agreement outside of court with the help of attorneys or a neutral mediator.
  • Binding Mediation – In some cases, a mediator may be given authority to render a decision that becomes binding on the parties.

These options can save time and money while still achieving a resolution.

Is the Agreement Reached in Mediation Enforceable?

Enforcing an agreement made through mediation is going to depend on the type of situation you are in. The mediation agreement could be a part of a court order or an informal agreement that does not have a legal impact.

One thing to remember is that everyone involved in the dispute has to be at the mediation. If anyone is not there, his or her written consent has to be provided before the mediation is over.

All the terms and conditions of the mediation need to be fully summarized in front of all parties involved. It should be transcribed so that all parties can sign the mediation. All parties then declare the dispute over and both parties are responsible to follow the mediation agreement.

The attorneys may want to have the parties also sign a liability release. If there is no legal case filed, the attorneys will then have everyone sign a contract that binds the parties to the agreement.

If one party does not comply with those terms after signing an agreement, it is considered a broken contract.

How to Enforce a Mediation Agreement

If a party fails to comply with a mediation agreement, the aggrieved party has several enforcement options:

  1. Negotiation & Communication – Before taking legal action, the parties can attempt to resolve the issue through further negotiation or discussion.
  2. Legal Action for Breach of Contract – If the mediation agreement is considered a binding contract, the aggrieved party can file a lawsuit for breach of contract.
  3. Court Motion to Enforce – If the agreement was made part of a court order, the aggrieved party can file a motion to enforce the agreement.
  4. Contempt Proceedings – If the agreement is legally enforceable, the violating party may face contempt of court proceedings.
  5. Arbitration or Further Mediation – In some cases, arbitration or a second round of mediation may be required to resolve the dispute.

Seeking legal counsel is advisable when considering enforcement action to ensure that the appropriate legal steps are taken.

FAQ Section:

1. What happens if one party does not comply with a mediation agreement?

If the agreement is legally binding, the non-compliant party may be sued for breach of contract or face contempt of court if it was included in a court order.

2. Can a mediation agreement be enforced in court?

Yes, if the mediation agreement was incorporated into a court order, it can be enforced through a motion to enforce or contempt proceedings.

3. What legal remedies are available if a party breaches a mediation agreement?

Legal remedies may include filing a lawsuit for breach of contract, seeking damages, or requesting the court to enforce the agreement.

4. Can mediation be attempted again if a party does not comply?

Yes, parties can return to mediation to attempt to resolve compliance issues before resorting to litigation.

5. How can I ensure a mediation agreement is enforceable?

To ensure enforceability, it’s best to have the agreement reviewed by an attorney, include clear terms, and, if possible, integrate it into a court order.

If you need help with failure to comply with a mediation agreement, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law, and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.