Torts and Contracts Are Examples of Civil Legal Obligations

Key Takeaways

• Torts and contracts are examples of civil law, where parties can be held liable for damages rather than face criminal penalties.
• Contracts are based on mutual agreement, while torts arise from duties imposed by law, often without prior agreement.
• Tort liability is often based on negligence, intent, or strict liability, while contract liability is based on breach of agreed terms.
• Remedies differ: contract law emphasizes compensatory remedies, whereas tort law may also allow punitive damages.
• Understanding the differences helps determine the proper legal approach when disputes arise.
• You can consult a qualified attorney on UpCounsel for personalized legal assistance with tort or contract issues.

Contract Law

Contract law deals with the fulfillment of promises made by parties in voluntary agreement. In contracts, the rights and obligations of the contracting parties are based on the provisions of the agreement between the parties. The parties entering into a contract must form the agreement willingly without force. The contract can only be valid if the parties involved agree to the provisions of the agreement.

In other words, a party cannot force another party to enter into a contract. For this reason, damages arising from contractual disputes are often due to a misunderstanding between the parties as the provisions of the contract are clear to them. Damages awarded in contract disputes are usually not punitive, rather, they help restore the rights of the aggrieved party.

Contract law is concerned about the formation, drafting, and outcomes of agreements. These conditions make the contract legally enforceable, and failure to uphold the provisions lead to liability, i.e., the duty of obligation of both parties to each other regarding the contract. Remedies of contract breach include specific performance, rescission, and reformation of the contract.

Key Elements of Contract Law

To be legally enforceable, a contract must meet certain essential elements, including:

• Offer and Acceptance: One party must make an offer that the other party accepts.
• Consideration: Each party must exchange something of value.
• Legal Capacity: All parties must have the legal ability to enter into a contract (e.g., not minors or mentally incapacitated).
• Legal Purpose: The contract must not be for an illegal activity.
• Mutual Assent: All parties must agree to the contract's terms knowingly and voluntarily.

Contract disputes often revolve around breaches such as non-performance, delays, or misrepresentation. Courts evaluate the language of the contract and conduct of the parties to determine liability and appropriate remedies, including damages or specific performance.

Tort Law

Tort law is concerned about involuntary responsibilities to ensure our actions are not detrimental to others. In Tort law, the courts create rights and obligations under common law using precedence from three categories including:

• Negligence
• Nuisance, and
• Trespass

Tort focuses on injuries such as the action of a person that harms another person's property, reputation, health, and others. Unlike contracts, torts are not based on the consent of the parties involved. Generally, torts occur when a party's action affects the profit, safety, health, or privacy of another. If the offender can establish that the aggrieved consented to their harmful actions, it can ask the court to dismiss the victim's damages claims. In torts claim, damages serve as a compensation for the loss the victim suffered. Additionally, tort suits can end in the court awarding punitive damages to punish the defendant.

There are two aspects of Tort Law including:

• Intentional Tort, and
• Unintentional Tort

The two aspects use different methods of considering liability. Liability is present if the action of the defendant includes assault, battery, intentional or unintentional harm to motion, negligence, tort against a person or property among others. The concept is called "duty of care" for every individual to all. Equitable remedies of torts include mandatory injunctions and prohibitive injunctions to prevent future torts. For example, a driver must use the road appropriately under prevailing road and weather conditions to ensure that he or she does not drive in a way that will endanger the lives or property of other road users.

Categories and Examples of Tort Law

Tort law generally falls into three main categories:

1. Intentional Torts – Actions taken to deliberately harm another, such as assault, battery, false imprisonment, defamation, or fraud.
2. Negligent Torts – Failures to exercise reasonable care, such as car accidents caused by distracted driving or slip-and-fall injuries.
3. Strict Liability Torts – Liability imposed regardless of intent or negligence, often found in product liability cases or when dealing with inherently dangerous activities.

For example, a business may be liable under strict liability if a defective product harms a consumer, even if the business took every precaution. This reflects the principle that individuals and entities must act in ways that do not unreasonably harm others.

Differences Between Tort and Contract Law

While torts and contracts are examples of civil claims, they differ significantly in their foundations and remedies:

A key distinction is that contract law applies only when there is an agreement, while tort law can apply to anyone whose conduct harms another, regardless of any agreement.

Voluntary Assumption

Voluntary assumption of a contract can increase the tort liability obligation over what is applicable under normal circumstances. For example, a host is not liable if his visitor had too many drinks at his party and hit a pedestrian while driving home. Alternatively, a nightclub may be liable if it sells too much drink to its patrons and allows them to drive their cars out of its parking lot while drunk.

Civil Law

Contract law and tort law fall within the purview of civil law. In civil law, court orders and money are used to enforce judicial decisions, not jail time. In civil cases, the suing party is known as the plaintiff while the offender is called the defendant. When you are sued in a civil case, you will be summoned to appear in court rather than being arrested. Instead of State prosecution, the suing party also appears in court with an attorney.

If the court rules against you, the judge will order you to perform an act such as paying money to the plaintiff or restoring their rights. You only go to prison if you didn't follow the court's decision, and found to be in contempt of court. Contract law is not concerned about the innocence or guilt of the disputing parties. The court's job is to identifying who is right.

Common Scenarios of Torts and Contracts

Understanding real-world examples helps clarify how tort and contract law apply:

• Contract Example: A freelance designer agrees to complete a website by a set deadline. If the designer fails to deliver, the client may sue for breach of contract.
• Tort Example: A store owner fails to clean a spill, and a customer slips and suffers injury. The customer may sue the store under tort law for negligence.

In some situations, both tort and contract claims can arise. For instance, a professional might be sued for both breach of contract and malpractice (a tort) if their conduct violates both agreed terms and a legal duty of care.

Criminal Law

In criminal law, the defendant is innocent until proven guilty. Thus, the case must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt. A crime is an action that violates public law and pits the offender against federal or State authorities. The State oversees the prosecution, and the office of the District Attorney represents the victim in court. If found guilty, the defendant can serve time, do community service, pay a fine, or face capital punishment according to the severity of the crime.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What do torts and contracts have in common? Both are part of civil law and can result in legal liability, but they differ in how the obligations arise—contracts are voluntary, torts are imposed by law.

2. Can a single action be both a tort and a contract breach? Yes. For example, a negligent service provider may breach both a contract and commit a tort if their behavior causes harm outside the agreement.

3. Are torts always based on intent? No. Torts can be intentional, negligent, or based on strict liability, which does not require proving fault.

4. What is the statute of limitations for tort and contract claims? It varies by state and type of claim. Generally, tort claims have shorter limitation periods than contract claims.

5. Do torts and contracts both result in monetary compensation? Yes, but torts may also result in punitive damages, while contract law generally aims to restore the injured party to their original position.

If you need more information about torts and contracts, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.