Key Takeaways:

  • Contract claims arise when one party fails to fulfill its contractual obligations, leading to potential legal action.
  • Remedies for contract claims include monetary damages (compensatory, consequential, liquidated) and equitable remedies such as contract rescission or reformation.
  • Government contract claims have specific legal requirements, including submission deadlines and dispute resolution protocols.
  • Proper contract management and documentation can help prevent contract disputes.
  • Alternative dispute resolution (ADR) methods, such as mediation and arbitration, can be used to resolve contract disputes efficiently.
  • Understanding common contract claims, including breach of contract, fraud, and misrepresentation, helps businesses mitigate risks.
  • Contract claim management is crucial for minimizing financial and legal repercussions in both private and government contracts.

Contract claims are court cases that result from a breach of contract. When a party breaches a contract, and another party files a claim, the injured party will have access to a variety of remedies, including monetary damages and enforcement of the contract.

What is a Contract?

When two parties reach an agreement, this agreement is a contract. A contract creates a legal obligation between both parties. Both parties in a contract must fulfill their duties as specified in the contract. For instance, one party could be bound to deliver certain goods after receiving payment from the other party. An exchange of value, known as consideration, is a requirement for a contract to be legally valid.

Although courts lend more credence to written contracts, a contract can be either written or verbal. It's also possible for a person to enter into a contract through their actions. Parties can use contracts for the sale of both goods and services. A valid contract includes three important features:

  1. Mutual Assent: All contracted parties should understand the contract's subject matter and its specific terms.
  2. Offer and Acceptance: One party makes an offer indicating their willingness to enter a contract, and the other party unambiguously accepts the offer.
  3. Consideration: The parties agree to exchange something of value, whether money or performance of an act.

Contract Claims and Remedies

When a contract breach occurs, there are several different remedies that are available to the injured party. The remedies available in contract claims will depend on the nature of the breach, and can be either equitable or legal.

A legal remedy usually involves the party that breached the contract providing monetary restitution for the losses suffered by the other party. Legal remedies can take several different forms:

  1. Compensatory damages
  2. Consequential damages
  3. Liquidated damages

An equitable remedy requires that the breaching party take steps to make up for the breach. Equitable remedies can include canceling the contract, known as rescission, or reforming the contract. Both contract claims and remedies can be very complicated because it can be difficult to determine the actual harm caused by a contract breach. For a contract breach to exist, there must be four crucial elements:

  1. Formation of a contract.
  2. The contract includes enforceable performance terms.
  3. One party does not perform their contractual obligations.
  4. The failure to perform injures the other party.

Types of Contract Claims

Contract claims can take several forms, depending on the nature of the alleged breach or issue with the agreement. The most common types include:

  1. Breach of Contract – A party fails to fulfill its contractual obligations, either through non-performance, delayed performance, or substandard performance.
  2. Material vs. Minor Breach – A material breach significantly impacts the contract’s purpose, potentially allowing the non-breaching party to terminate the agreement. A minor breach does not substantially harm the contract’s purpose but may warrant damages.
  3. Anticipatory Breach – One party indicates that they will not fulfill their contractual obligations before the deadline, allowing the other party to take legal action in advance.
  4. Fraud or Misrepresentation – If one party provides false or misleading information to induce the contract, the harmed party may seek damages or rescission.
  5. Failure to Perform Under Good Faith and Fair Dealing – Many contracts include an implied duty of good faith; a violation can result in legal claims.

Contract Claims in Government Contracts

Government contract claims have distinct rules and procedures, governed primarily by the Contract Disputes Act (CDA). Key considerations include:

  • Filing Deadlines: Contractor claims must typically be submitted within six years of realization.
  • Contracting Officer's Decision: The contracting officer reviews claims and attempts resolution at their level before escalation.
  • Dispute Resolution: If mutual agreement fails, disputes may be resolved through Boards of Contract Appeals or the U.S. Court of Federal Claims.
  • Certified Claims: If the claim exceeds $100,000, the contractor must certify it, attesting to its accuracy and good faith basis.

Understanding these procedures is crucial for businesses engaging in government contracts to avoid losing their claims due to procedural errors.

How Contract Claims Are Evaluated

When you hire a lawyer to bring a contract claim, the first issue that they will examine is if a valid contract was actually formed. For a contract to exist, one person must have proposed specific terms that the other party accepted. This process of offer and acceptance is commonly referred to as a meeting of the minds.

Documenting a contract in writing is the easiest way to prove the formation of an agreement, although there is no specific requirement that contracts must be in writing. Many contracts are verbal, and some contracts are formed through the actions of the party. If there is a written and signed contract, however, it should be easy to prove formation. If a contract is not in writing, proving formation and legal enforceability can be very difficult, even for the most experienced attorneys.

Once your attorney establishes that a contract was indeed formed, they will examine whether the agreement is legally enforceable. For a contract to be enforceable, it must contain detailed terms and clearly specify the responsibilities of all parties involved. Without specific terms, it will be hard to prove whether offer and acceptance has actually occurred. Also, a lack of defined terms will make it less likely that the Courts will enforce the contract. A contract is not enforceable if it requires that the parties participate in illegal acts.

If a contract exists and it is enforceable, your attorney's next step will be proving that a breach of the contract actually occurred. Contract breaches are a result of a failure to perform, meaning one or both of the parties has not fulfilled their legal obligations. For example, if you've paid for goods and then the company you paid did not deliver your goods, this would be a failure to perform.

The Role of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) in Contract Claims

To avoid costly litigation, many contract disputes are resolved using Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) methods, such as:

  1. Mediation – A neutral third party helps the parties negotiate a mutually acceptable resolution.
  2. Arbitration – A binding or non-binding resolution process where an arbitrator renders a decision outside of court.
  3. Negotiation – The parties attempt to resolve the dispute informally without third-party involvement.

ADR is often faster, less expensive, and more confidential than traditional litigation.

Best Practices for Preventing Contract Claims

Avoiding contract disputes starts with proactive contract management. Key strategies include:

  • Clearly Defined Terms: Ensure all contract terms are unambiguous and address potential contingencies.
  • Regular Documentation: Maintain detailed records of performance, communications, and contract modifications.
  • Compliance Monitoring: Ensure all parties adhere to their obligations through periodic reviews.
  • Dispute Resolution Clauses: Include mediation or arbitration clauses to outline procedures for resolving potential conflicts.
  • Legal Review: Have contracts reviewed by a qualified attorney to identify potential risks before signing.

These preventive measures help mitigate risks and reduce the likelihood of contract-related disputes.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What should I do if the other party breaches a contract?Document the breach, notify the breaching party, review dispute resolution clauses, and consult an attorney for potential legal action.

2. What damages can I recover in a contract claim?Damages may include compensatory (to cover losses), consequential (to address secondary effects), or liquidated (pre-agreed damages in the contract).

3. How long do I have to file a contract claim?Statutes of limitations vary; general contract claims may have a four to six-year window, while government contracts have specific deadlines under the Contract Disputes Act.

4. Can a contract claim be settled outside of court?Yes, many contract claims are resolved through negotiation, mediation, or arbitration, reducing legal costs and time.

5. What are the key elements of a valid contract claim?A contract claim requires a valid contract, clear enforceable terms, a breach, and resulting damages.

If you need help with contract claims, you can post your legal needs on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.