Key Takeaways

  • Contract disputes often stem from unclear terms, performance failures, or differing interpretations.
  • Breaches can be minor or material, each with distinct legal remedies.
  • Industry-specific disputes, like in construction or IP, require tailored approaches.
  • Government contract disputes follow a formal legal process under the Contract Disputes Act.
  • Common resolution methods include negotiation, mediation, arbitration, and litigation.
  • Best practices—such as clear language, defined expectations, and dispute clauses—help prevent conflicts.
  • Emerging issues include disputes from AI contracts, remote work terms, and cybersecurity obligations.

Contract disputes occur when one or both parties to an agreement disagree about the terms and conditions. A contract is only valid when both parties fully understand the agreement and are willing to accept its terms. If the agreement is not mutual, it may be challenged in court.

Breach of Contract

Contract disputes usually occur when a party breaches the contract, which means they do not do what they have promised to do in the agreement. Types of contract breaches include:

  • A material breach, in which one party does not perform his or her duty and, as a result, the contract is irreparable. The party affected by this breach can sue the party who has breached the contract for damages.
  • A minor breach, also called an immaterial breach, in which the core of the contract is not changed. Both parties still must fulfill the contract when a minor breach occurs, but the party who has not breached the agreement can still sue the other party for damages.

A breach may occur not only when the terms of the contract are not performed at all, but also when they are not done in accordance with the specifications indicated and/or when they are not completed on time.

In the case of a contract breach, one or both parties may sue for damages and/or to have the terms of the contract legally enforced. Ideally, disputes can be resolved in mediation before a lawsuit is filed. Binding arbitration is another form of alternative dispute resolution.

Common remedies for contract breach include:

  • Cancellation and restitution
  • Specific performance
  • Damages

Damages are the most common breach of contract remedy and may include:

  • Compensatory damages designed to restore the injured party to the position he or she was in prior to the breach.
  • Punitive damages beyond full compensation for wrongful acts.
  • Nominal damages when a breach has occurred without measurable financial loss.
  • Liquidated damages, which are those specifically indicated in a provision of the contract.

Specific performance is when the court orders the party who has breached the contract to fulfill its terms, which is typically ordered if damages are insufficient. The damaged party can also sue for restitution after canceling the contract.

Legal Consequences of Breach of Contract

A breach of contract can lead to legal action, financial penalties, and reputational damage. In addition to damages and specific performance, legal consequences may include:

  • Injunctions – Court orders preventing a party from taking certain actions.
  • Rescission – Canceling the contract and restoring both parties to their original state.
  • Reputational Harm – Businesses involved in frequent contract disputes may lose credibility and future opportunities.
  • Loss of Business Relationships – Contract breaches can erode trust and impact long-term partnerships.

Contract Disputes Act of 1978

Standard processes for resolving government contract disputes were established by the Contract Disputes Act of 1978. This Act was designed to provide a fair, transparent process for definitive resolution. Both the contractor and the government bureau in question should negotiate in good faith and strive to settle the dispute at the lowest possible level. This is the contracting officer, who issues a final decision that can be challenged in either the Board of Contract Appeals or U.S. Federal Claims Court. These decisions may, in turn, be appealed in either the U.S. Federal Circuit Court of Appeals, the intermediate appellate authority, and the U.S. Supreme Court.

Key Steps in Resolving a Government Contract Dispute

Government contract disputes must follow a structured resolution process, including:

  1. Negotiation with the Contracting Officer – Initial step to resolve the dispute informally.
  2. Formal Claim Submission – Contractors must submit a detailed claim outlining damages and evidence.
  3. Final Decision from the Contracting Officer – A written ruling that can be appealed.
  4. Appeal to the Board of Contract Appeals or Court of Federal Claims – Legal recourse if the contractor disputes the decision.
  5. Potential Supreme Court Review – If necessary, disputes can escalate to the highest court.

Common Types of Contract Disputes

Contracts are only valid when they include an accepted offer and some form of payment (consideration) for the products or services received. Disputes may include but are not limited to those associated with:

  • Offer and acceptance
  • The definition of a technical term used
  • Contract drafting and review
  • Errors in the contract
  • Coercion or fraud
  • Breach of contract

Contract Disputes by Contract Type

Contract disputes can arise across all types of agreements. Understanding which types are most frequently contested can help parties take proactive steps during contract creation. Common examples include:

  • Sale of Goods Contracts: Disputes may involve defective products, delayed delivery, or non-payment.
  • Service Agreements: Conflicts often arise over scope of work, performance standards, and completion timelines.
  • Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs): Breaches may involve unauthorized disclosures or disputes over what constitutes confidential information.
  • Franchise Agreements: These may involve disagreements about territorial rights, branding, or operational requirements.
  • Licensing Contracts: Disputes often stem from unclear usage rights, royalty payments, or exclusivity provisions.
  • Lease Agreements: Common issues include maintenance responsibilities, rent increases, and early termination clauses.

Industry-Specific Contract Disputes

Contract disputes vary across industries, with common issues including:

  • Construction Contracts – Delays, cost overruns, non-payment, and defective work.
  • Employment Contracts – Wrongful termination, non-compete clause enforcement, and wage disputes.
  • Intellectual Property Agreements – Licensing disagreements, patent infringements, and trademark misuse.
  • Real Estate Transactions – Breaches related to lease agreements, purchase contracts, and zoning laws.

High-Risk Situations for Contract Disputes

Contract disputes are more likely to occur in certain high-risk scenarios, including:

  • Rapidly Changing Business Environments: Fast-paced industries (e.g., tech or biotech) may experience disputes due to unclear contractual adaptation to evolving products or services.
  • Cross-Border Agreements: International contracts often lead to misunderstandings over jurisdiction, applicable law, or language translation issues.
  • Ambiguity in Terms: Vague or undefined terms can lead to differing interpretations and disputes over obligations.
  • Oral Agreements: Though sometimes enforceable, verbal contracts often lack the clarity and documentation necessary to resolve conflicts easily.

Emerging Trends in Contract Disputes

As business and legal landscapes evolve, new trends impact contract disputes, such as:

  • AI & Smart Contracts – Automated dispute resolution based on blockchain and AI-driven analysis.
  • Remote Work Agreements – Increased contractual conflicts due to flexible work arrangements.
  • Regulatory Compliance – Greater scrutiny on contracts in highly regulated industries like finance and healthcare.

Technology and Contract Enforcement

As technology transforms contract formation and enforcement, new challenges are emerging:

  • Smart Contracts: These self-executing contracts use blockchain technology. Disputes may arise over programming errors, unclear triggers, or external dependencies (e.g., "oracles").
  • Cybersecurity Obligations: With data breaches on the rise, contracts now often include specific cybersecurity responsibilities. Disputes can occur if one party fails to meet data protection standards.
  • AI-Created Contracts: AI-drafted agreements may lack nuanced legal reasoning, leading to increased scrutiny and disputes over interpretation or enforceability.

Remedies for Contract Disputes

Contract disputes are typically resolved by either equitable or legal remedies. The latter is usually in the form of financial damages awarded to the plaintiff for his or her loss. With equitable remedies, the parties take action to correct the dispute.

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) Methods

Many contract disputes are settled outside of court through ADR methods:

  • Mediation – A neutral mediator helps parties find a mutually acceptable resolution.
  • Arbitration – A third party makes a binding decision after reviewing evidence.
  • Negotiation – Direct discussions between parties to reach a compromise.
  • Mini-Trials – A non-binding process where each side presents their case before executives or legal experts.

Avoiding Contract Disputes

When both parties are clear on the terms of a contract, disputes are less likely to occur. Take the following steps when entering a contract to prevent future disagreements:

  • Document all contract negotiations in writing throughout the process, including offer history, quantities, prices, and all other terms and conditions.
  • Be clear on the contract goal and be able to clearly state points of negotiation.
  • Double-check terms and conditions each time a contract update is made and take special care when working with a new negotiator or changed product specs.
  • Clarify the definitions of industry terms, legal words, and other jargon to prevent misunderstanding.
  • Work with an experienced contract attorney who can assist with the negotiation process.

Best Practices for Preventing Contract Disputes

To reduce the risk of disputes, businesses and individuals should:

  1. Use Clear and Precise Language – Ambiguous terms lead to misinterpretation.
  2. Define Performance Expectations – Specify deadlines, deliverables, and quality standards.
  3. Include a Dispute Resolution Clause – Specify mediation or arbitration as the preferred method of resolution.
  4. Regularly Review Contracts – Update contracts to align with changes in laws and business practices.
  5. Leverage Contract Management Software – Digital tools help track obligations, deadlines, and compliance.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What causes most contract disputes?
    Most disputes stem from unclear terms, performance failures, payment issues, or breach of obligations.
  2. What are examples of contract disputes in business?
    Examples include disputes over defective products, service delays, non-compete violations, or intellectual property use.
  3. Can a verbal agreement cause a contract dispute?
    Yes, especially if one party fails to fulfill its part. Some verbal agreements are enforceable, but proving terms can be challenging.
  4. What industries face the most contract disputes?
    Construction, tech, real estate, and healthcare are common sectors where disputes frequently arise.
  5. What is the best way to resolve a contract dispute?
    Start with negotiation or mediation. If that fails, arbitration or litigation may be necessary, depending on the contract’s dispute resolution clause.

If you need help with contract disputes, you can post your legal needs on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers on its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.