Key Takeaways

  • A sole proprietorship is the simplest structure for consulting but lacks liability protection.
  • An LLC provides limited liability protection and potential tax flexibility.
  • Key factors to consider include liability risk, administrative complexity, and client perception.
  • Many consultants transition from sole proprietorships to LLCs as their businesses grow.
  • Choosing between an LLC or sole proprietorship for consulting affects taxes, compliance, and growth potential.

A sole proprietorship consulting business is a popular choice for individual entrepreneurs who want to start their own venture and have specific expertise in a valuable area, such as technology or design. This is a flexible business that allows you to work from home or in an office setting as you help clients bolster their own companies. When starting a consulting business, you need to determine the best entity for your business, obtain the required permits and licenses, consider tax issues, prepare contracts, and purchase insurance.

Selecting a Business Entity

Although many consultants operate a sole proprietorship, you may also want to establish an independent business entity that provides personal liability protection, such as a corporation or limited liability company (LLC). This protects your personal assets in the event that your business is sued.

Choosing Between an LLC or Sole Proprietorship for Consulting

When deciding whether to form an LLC or operate as a sole proprietorship for consulting, it's important to evaluate the trade-offs between simplicity, liability protection, and long-term growth.

A sole proprietorship is easy and inexpensive to set up. It doesn’t require formal registration beyond basic licensing. However, it offers no personal liability protection—meaning your personal assets could be at risk in the event of lawsuits or debts.

An LLC (Limited Liability Company) is a separate legal entity that shields your personal assets from business liabilities. Although it involves some filing fees and administrative upkeep, an LLC can lend more professional credibility, especially when working with corporate clients or high-value contracts.

Consider forming an LLC if:

  • You want liability protection.
  • You plan to scale your consulting business.
  • You work with clients who require a formal business structure.
  • You're concerned about being personally responsible for legal or financial risks.

Consider starting with a sole proprietorship if:

  • You're just testing your business idea.
  • You have minimal risk of legal exposure.
  • You're working with a small number of clients or as a side hustle.

For many consultants, starting as a sole proprietorship and converting to an LLC later is a common strategy.

Obtaining Licenses and Permits

Even sole proprietors must obtain a federal tax ID number, known as an employer identification number (EIN). This can be requested for free at the IRS website. In some states and municipalities, you may also need a business license. If you are operating the consulting business under a different name than your legal name, you will need to register a fictitious or DBA (doing business as) name. Some states require consultants to obtain a professional license. If you will be selling products, you need to file for a sales tax permit. If you are operating the business out of your home, be sure to check local zoning regulations before you begin.

Understanding Business Taxation

Your business will be subject to different tax laws depending on whether you choose to operate a sole proprietorship, LLC, partnership, or corporation. Sole proprietorship income and losses are reported on the owner's individual tax return using Schedule C. Your clients will provide a 1099-MISC form that details the amount they have paid you for your services. As an independent contractor, you will be responsible for paying federal self-employment tax and making quarterly estimated tax payments. If you run a home-based business, you may be eligible for a deduction.

Tax Considerations When Choosing Between LLC and Sole Proprietorship

Tax treatment is a major factor when deciding between an LLC or sole proprietorship for consulting.

  • Sole Proprietorship Taxes: Income passes through directly to your personal tax return (Schedule C). You'll pay self-employment tax (Social Security and Medicare) on net profits and may make quarterly estimated payments.
  • Single-Member LLC Taxes: By default, the IRS taxes a single-member LLC the same as a sole proprietorship. However, you can elect S Corporation status to potentially reduce self-employment taxes by splitting income between salary and distributions.
  • State Taxes and Fees: LLCs often have annual fees and franchise taxes, which vary by state. Sole proprietors generally avoid these costs unless required by local regulations.

Working with a tax advisor can help determine the best setup to optimize your financial situation and minimize liabilities.

Purchasing Business Insurance

The appropriate insurance will vary depending on the purpose of your consulting business.

  • Premises liability insurance covers accidental injuries that occur at your workplace.
  • Property insurance will cover the loss of your physical business equipment, such as your computer and other technology.
  • Professional liability insurance may be required depending on your area of consulting.

Developing Contracts

Because the services you offer vary depending on client needs, it's important to make sure each project is clearly commemorated with a formal contract. You may also want to develop general policies that can be posted on your website or given to clients before work begins. These policies could include billing requirements, how travel time is charged, how payment is given, and who pays for expenses.

Specific client agreements should cover the details of payment, billing, and expenses and delineate the scope of work, terms, and conditions of the project. For an agreement to be legally enforceable, it must contain written agreement from both parties as well as an exchange of consideration, or item of value.

Advantages of Incorporating

Many consultants struggle with the question of whether to continue as a sole proprietor or incorporate their business into a separate entity. Some of the advantages of incorporating include:

  • Limited personal liability for business obligations, debts, and legal judgments
  • Potential tax savings depending on the specifics of your business finances
    • S corporations, which have no more than 100 shareholders, are subject to pass-through taxation at the individual rate.
    • C corporations are taxed at a flat rate of 35 percent.
  • The ability to maximize retirement fund contributions to reduce taxable income
  • Reduced chance of tax audit compared to a sole proprietorship; self-employed individuals are audited by the IRS more commonly than established businesses are
  • The ability to purchase an affordable healthcare plan at a corporate rate
  • Increased credibility with current and potential clients, investors, and stakeholders

How an LLC Can Strengthen Your Consulting Brand

Beyond liability and taxes, forming an LLC can enhance your consulting business’s image. Clients may view LLCs as more established and professional, especially for B2B engagements. This added credibility can be crucial for:

  • Winning corporate contracts.
  • Building trust with clients who may be wary of informal arrangements.
  • Demonstrating long-term commitment to your consulting practice.

Additionally, forming an LLC allows you to open a business bank account, apply for financing, and more easily separate your personal and business finances—all of which signal reliability and professionalism.

Disadvantages of Incorporating

Incorporating is not the right choice for every sole proprietor. Sometimes, doing so can be cost-prohibitive or subject your business to arduous regulations. Talk with an attorney and tax professional before taking this step.

When a Sole Proprietorship May Be the Better Fit

Despite the benefits of LLCs, a sole proprietorship may still be the right choice for new or low-risk consultants. You may prefer to remain a sole proprietor if:

  • You have limited startup funds and want to avoid formation or annual fees.
  • Your services carry minimal legal liability.
  • You want to focus on quickly launching and testing your business model with minimal paperwork.

However, keep in mind that as your consulting business grows or your client list expands, it may be worth reassessing your structure to ensure you're adequately protected and positioned for scale.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Is an LLC better than a sole proprietorship for consulting?
    An LLC offers liability protection and can enhance credibility, making it ideal for growing or client-facing consulting businesses. Sole proprietorships are simpler and cheaper for low-risk ventures.
  2. Can I switch from a sole proprietorship to an LLC later?
    Yes, many consultants start as sole proprietors and form an LLC later as their business grows or risks increase.
  3. Do I need an EIN for a sole proprietorship consulting business?
    If you hire employees or want to open a business bank account, you’ll need an EIN, even as a sole proprietor.
  4. Does forming an LLC reduce my taxes as a consultant?
    An LLC taxed as an S corporation can reduce self-employment tax liability under certain conditions, but you should consult a tax advisor.
  5. What’s the cost difference between an LLC and a sole proprietorship?
    Sole proprietorships have virtually no formation costs. LLCs require state filing fees, annual reports, and sometimes franchise taxes, depending on your location.

If you need help with establishing a sole proprietorship for your consulting business, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.