Key Takeaways:

  • Scope of Work: Clearly define the scope to avoid misunderstandings and ensure project success.
  • Intellectual Property: Establish ownership rights for any IP created during the project.
  • Payment Terms: Outline a clear payment structure with provisions for milestones and penalties.
  • Confidentiality: Include NDAs and confidentiality clauses to protect sensitive information.
  • Warranties: Define the warranties and liabilities associated with the software.
  • Maintenance: Set terms for ongoing support and maintenance after delivery.
  • Termination: Provide clear terms for contract termination and the associated consequences.
  • Avoid Ambiguity: Ensure all terms are clear and specific to prevent disputes.

Software contracts outline the legal terms and conditions of using a specific type of software, whether for business or personal use.

Simple Rules for Negotiating Software and IT Contracts

The first rule is that you shouldn't pay for maintenance or support on the product before it is necessary. On the first day that the software is set up, you obviously won't need support or maintenance because you're not actually using the software yet. You'll have no need for support on the product until the software company's implementation or customization team has finalized the product, which can take months or longer. It makes no sense to pay maintenance fees for a product that is not ready to be used.

As upgrades and updates become available for the software, the software company's team can take care of the installation process, which should be part of the customization process. If any type of annual or monthly maintenance fee is enforced prior to completion of customization of the software, you could end up paying for a service you won't need or use. When negotiating a software contract, you should try to delay the start of support and maintenance fees until after the system has gone live and the vendor has customized it for your needs.

Within the contract, you should request that the vendor defines the go-live date as the date on which the customization process is complete or you accept the final product after it has been customized. Upon approval, the maintenance contract can begin on the go-live date. If you can negotiate a reduction in the maintenance and support period timeline, you could end up saving quite a bit of money.

One exception to this rule is if your software vendor has a good reason to start the maintenance period prior to the go-live date. For example, a vendor might set a lower price for the software with a plan to make up the cost difference in the required maintenance fees. In this case, a maintenance term that is shorter or starts later could result in the software vendor losing money on the sale.

Some vendors also need support or maintenance during the customization process. Members of the software maintenance team might have access to make changes or handle tasks that the team assigned to customization isn't able to handle. It's smart to listen to the software vendor to get a better idea of why a maintenance period starts early. You can always ask questions when negotiating a software contract. You could find out that the vendor doesn't have a good reason to start fees before the software goes live.

Key Elements of a Software Contract

When drafting or reviewing a software contract, it's essential to understand the core components that should be included. These elements form the foundation of a solid agreement and ensure that both parties have clear expectations. Here are the key elements that every software contract should cover:

  1. Scope of Work (SOW): Clearly define the services or products to be delivered, including specific functionalities, features, and deadlines. This section should be as detailed as possible to prevent scope creep and ensure that both parties have a mutual understanding of the deliverables.
  2. Intellectual Property Rights: Specify the ownership of the intellectual property (IP) created during the contract. Typically, the client will want to retain ownership of the software developed, while the developer may retain ownership of any pre-existing tools or components used.
  3. Payment Terms: Outline the payment structure, including milestones, payment schedules, and any penalties for late payments. It's also important to include provisions for additional costs that might arise due to changes in scope or unexpected issues.
  4. Confidentiality and Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs): Include clauses to protect sensitive information shared during the project. This ensures that proprietary data or trade secrets are not disclosed to third parties.
  5. Warranties and Liabilities: Define the warranties provided by the developer, such as guarantees on the software's functionality or support for a specific period. Also, outline the liabilities of both parties in case of breaches or failures.
  6. Maintenance and Support: Clearly state the terms for ongoing maintenance and support after the software is delivered. This could include bug fixes, updates, and any associated costs.
  7. Termination Clause: Detail the circumstances under which either party can terminate the contract, and the procedures for doing so. This section should also cover what happens to payments, deliverables, and IP rights if the contract is terminated early.
  8. Dispute Resolution: Include a dispute resolution mechanism, such as mediation or arbitration, to resolve any conflicts that may arise during the contract term.

Don't Use NDAs for Data Security

The next rule comes from a common mistake among software buyers: relying on nondisclosure clauses or agreements (NDAs) to protect your personal or business data. An NDA is designed to protect your trade secrets, but not to protect any private data accessed or held by the software vendor. A nondisclosure clause in a contract states that the signer won't share or use any confidential information for purposes other than what is outlined and intended in the terms of the contract.

An NDA works well for protecting:

  • Customer lists
  • Secret recipes
  • Source code
  • Business plans

An NDA doesn't offer sufficient data security terms. The terms in a standard NDA don't typically include information about procedures that will protect information. Instead, the language is generic and talks about taking reasonable precautions. What you should use is a data security clause, which is specifically designed to protect data and the procedures involved with securing data.

A data clause will often require that employees must have background checks and also outline the response and notification plan for a data breach. One of the most important things to include in a data clause is how data security will be externally audited. Some examples include:

  • SOC 2
  • SSAE-16
  • ISO 27001

A data clause should also address how compliance will be enforced with any privacy policies, laws, and e-discovery policies. The e-discovery policies in a data clause will cover how and when the software vendor can transmit data to another party in the event of a lawsuit or other legal action.

Common Pitfalls in Software Contracts

Navigating software contracts can be complex, and there are several common pitfalls that businesses should avoid to ensure a successful partnership:

  1. Ambiguity in Terms: Vague or poorly defined terms can lead to misunderstandings and disputes. Always ensure that the contract language is clear, specific, and leaves no room for multiple interpretations.
  2. Ignoring Compliance Requirements: Software contracts should take into account any relevant legal and regulatory requirements, such as data protection laws (e.g., GDPR) or industry-specific standards. Failing to include compliance terms can lead to legal issues and potential fines.
  3. Overlooking Termination Consequences: Many contracts lack detailed provisions regarding the consequences of termination. Ensure that the contract specifies what happens to the software, data, and payments if the agreement is terminated early.
  4. Insufficient IP Protection: Neglecting to clearly define who owns the software and associated IP can lead to disputes later on. It's crucial to establish whether the client or the developer retains IP rights, especially for custom software.
  5. Inadequate Dispute Resolution Mechanisms: Without a clear dispute resolution process, minor disagreements can escalate into costly legal battles. Include a well-defined process for resolving disputes, such as mediation or arbitration.

If you need help with software contracts, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.